The murder trial of a Florida man accused of brutally killing a British woman he met on a violent fetish website entered its second day Wednesday. Jurors have heard disturbing allegations involving a terrified victim, a shallow grave and a bloody knife allegedly mailed to a friend hundreds of miles away. Florida prosecutors have laid out a chilling account of the woman’s final days, including evidence they say points to a calculated killing. Dwain Hall maintains he was simply trying to help a woman who told him she wanted to die. Hall, 54, is on trial in Marion County, Florida, for the October 2025 killing of Sonia Exelby, a 32-year-old music tutor with a history of mental illness from Portsmouth, England. Exelby traveled to the United States to meet him after the two reportedly communicated online for two years on a fetish website. Prosecutors have detailed Exelby’s history of mental illness and suicidal thoughts, alleging that Hall exploited her struggles and manipulated her.
LAmag
A vulnerable British music tutor told a 'sadist' accused of grooming and murdering her 'I can't be without you' in the months before her death, a court has heard. Sonia Exelby flew from her home in Portsmouth to Florida in October last year to meet Dwain Hall, a 54-year-old mechanic who worshipped the Egyptian god of death. The 32-year-old, who had a long history of mental health struggles, spent two years talking to Hall on a hardcore fetish website and offered to pay him to help brutally end her life. But prosecutors allege that she got cold feet after she arrived in the US and travelled with Hall to a remote Airbnb near the town of Reddick, Florida. Hall is accused of pressing ahead regardless – continuing to beat and abuse Ms Exelby before stabbing her to death. He denies kidnapping and murdering Ms Exelby.
Daily Mail
A self-described “sadist” is on trial for the kidnapping and killing of a British woman who flew to Florida to meet him after they met on a fetish website, according to court records. Dwain Hall, of Ocala, was arrested on murder and kidnapping charges on November 17, 2025, in connection with the discovery of Sonia Exelby’s remains buried in Marion County a month earlier, on October 17, 2025, according to the Florida Department of Law Enforcement. Authorities in the United Kingdom considered Exelby, 32, endangered and missing after she traveled to Florida and missed her return flight to England on October 13, 2025. U.K. authorities called on the Florida Department of Law Enforcement to help investigate. During the investigation, evidence on Exelby’s computer indicated “she was suicidal and traveling to the United States to be possibly sexually abused, tortured, and murdered,” according to Hall’s arrest affidavit filed in court and obtained by Us.
Us Weekly