The results of a suburban Twin Cities mayoral election that was decided by random drawing after an exact tie have been overturned, city officials said. Incumbent Mayor Bob Nelson and challenger Halyn Roth each received 1,401 votes on initial tally, triggering a state law that requires tied elections to be settled by chance. Days later, City Council member Barbara Goodboe-Bisschoff drew Nelson as the winner. After the drawing, Roth requested a recount. During that recount Tuesday, Roth challenged a ballot that had a scribble by Nelson's name and a tiny mark by Roth's. The Spring Lake Park City Council's Municipal Canvassing Board voted 3-1 to sustain the challenge. After the recount, Roth's vote total stood at 1,403, while Nelson had 1,402. Accordingly, the board declared Roth the winner. "This was a contentious evening, and emotions on both sides were high," Roth said on social media after the board's meeting. "I will have more to say soon, as I'm still processing this myself.
CBS News
It’s not rare in elections to have a tied vote. In the Philippines, election officials pick the winner of a tie with a toss coin. In the 3 November midterm elections in the United States, the mayoral contest in Spring Lake Park, Minnesota saw two candidates getting 1,401 votes each. Under state law, election officials can choose the method for deciding the winner. The election official, Dan Buchholtz, and the city attorney chose to settle the deadlock by drawing names, rather than flipping a coin, CNN reports. Each candidate’s name was written on a piece of paper and placed inside a toothpick capsule stripped of its label. The capsules were then placed inside a tote bag and council member Barbara Goodboe-Bisschoff pulled one out, revealing the name of incumbent mayor Bob Nelson, officially making him the winner, according to CNN. Nelson’s challenger, Halyn Roth, however, filed for a vote recount. If Roth ends up with more votes in the recount, he’ll win, Buchholtz told CNN.
Daily Tribune
Challenger and mayor-elect Halyn Roth (left) and incumbent Spring Lake Park Mayor Robert Nelson (right). (FOX 9) SPRING LAKE PARK, Minn. (FOX 9) - The City of Spring Lake Park has certified Halyn Roth as mayor-elect following a successful ballot challenge during Tuesday's recount, giving him a one-vote victory. Spring Lake Park mayor race The ballot that was challenged in the Spring Lake Park Mayoral Race. The Spring Lake Park City Council voted 3-1 to sustain Roth's challenge. (Supplied) Big picture view: Halyn Roth challenged the ballot pictured above. The Spring Lake Park Canvassing Board voted 3-1 to sustain Roth's challenge, saying the ballot "constituted an overvote rather than a vote for Nelson. Mayor Nelson recused himself from the vote." The ballot shows the bubble next to Robert Nelson's name is marked, but not fully filled in. In addition, the board believes the markings next to Roth's name constitutes an overvote.
FOX 9 Minneapolis-St. Paul