Australian Federal Courts (19 November 2026)

Listen through the publisher, then discuss the episode here or arrange an in-person Roundtable. Your city determines where to meet.
Roundtables are designed for groups of four, with a shared subject and room for everyone to speak. Come for discussion, with no dating expectation.
Twelve decisions in the Federal Courts edition for Thursday 19 November 2026: two from the Full Court of the Federal Court and ten from the Federal Court of Australia. The opening story: a car rental licence fee set at the greater of a turnover share and a passenger-based minimum offended the Northern Territory's retail tenancy law, but void did not mean a refund: the lease still provides for a review, and market rent applies. Then an urgent hearing without an interpreter, a child's best interests claim recorded but never considered, a template for liquidators of a trustee company, and the registry. Both Full Court rulings were covered in today's Courts of Appeal brief and are listed below. Commercial Desk (opening story). Kingmill Pty Ltd v Darwin International Airport Pty Ltd [2026] FCA 1747 (Charlesworth J, 19 November 2026) - Signal: Doctrine. Under s 28 of the Business Tenancies (Fair Dealings) Act 2003 (NT), the rent review mechanism is identified by its substantive operation: in a "greater of" formula it is the annual selection between the two sums. Section 28(3) looks to outcome (the label "ratchet" is irrelevant); the selection of the higher sum offended it, and the minimum fee could not be severed alone. "Void" denies only the proscribed legal effect, so the lease still provides for a review of the rent and ss 28(2) and 28(7) apply; the tenant cannot elect turnover rent or recover restitution. The combined formula was not a s 28(2) basis and the severability clause could not save it; rent for the second to fifth contract years is current market rent under s 28(7)(b). Application granted in part; restitution claim failed; costs reserved. JADE (https://jade.io/article/1305137) Public Law Desk. Paumolevuka v Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia [2026] FCA 1767 (Hill J, 18 November 2026) - Signal: Practice and Procedure; Illustrative. Review under s 39B of the Judiciary Act 1903 (Cth) of an FCFCOA refusal to extend time requires jurisdictional error. There is no right to an interpreter; the test is unacceptable unfairness, having regard to both parties and time pressure. The unrepresented applicant was at a material disadvantage and the court was on notice, but the breach was immaterial: his only ground attacked cl 050.212(3)(b), leaving the legally separate cl 050.223 finding unchallenged, and the urgency arose from his own delay. Application dismissed; interim injunction discharged. JADE (https://jade.io/article/1305140) LGC24 v Assistant Minister for Citizenship, Customs and Multicultural Affairs [2026] FCA 1748 (O'Callaghan J, 19 November 2026) - Reasons that record two claims going to a child's best interests and deal with only one disclose that the other was overlooked; a bare recording is not consideration. In the husband's linked s 501(3) refusal, the Minister's actual knowledge of the claim from the wife's decision 80 days earlier obliged him to consider it. Both errors material. Certiorari and mandamus in each proceeding. Reported as legal doctrine only. JADE (https://jade.io/article/1305138) Practice and Procedure Desk (a worked example). Price, in the matter of Leed Steel Pty Ltd (in liquidation) [2026] FCA 1773 (Beach J, 19 November 2026) - Signal: Illustrative. A template for liquidators of a corporate trustee seeking appointment as receivers of trust assets under s 57 of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth): the right of indemnity and equitable lien; the indicia of trading solely as trustee; nunc pro tunc orders; dispensing with security under rr 14.21 and 14.22; conferral of s 420 powers with carve-outs; the whole of the liquidation costs payable from trust assets with s 556(1) priority where the trustee never traded on its own account. JADE (https://jade.io/article/1305136) Covered in today's Courts of Appeal brief (overlap line only here). R and N Hunter Pty Ltd ATF The Hunter Family Superannuation Fund v Count Financial Limited [2026] FCAFC 143 (Derrington, Anderson and Feutrill JJ, 19 November 2026) - Signal: Doctrine. Financial adviser and client is not an accepted fiduciary category; any duty is tethered to an occasion of advice; silence implies a recommendation to retain only on an obligation, representation or expectation; fiduciary questions unsuited to Pt IVA common questions; misleading conduct claims fail. Appeal dismissed. JADE (https://jade.io/article/1305143) AGL Retail Energy Limited v Australian Energy Regulator (No 2) [2026] FCAFC 146 (Markovic, McEvoy and Younan JJ, 19 November 2026) - Signal: Illustrative. Costs follow the overall event, no issue-by-issue apportionment; the r 39.04(2) variation power is exceptional and no backdoor for arguments not made. Variation substantially refused. JADE (https://jade.io/article/1305142) Registry (list only, no outcome stated). Watson Webb Pty Ltd v Comino (No 3) [2026] FCA 1777 (Halley J, 19 November 2026) - costs. JADE (https://jade.io/article/1305179) Essential Metals Limited (No 2) [2026] FCA 1743 (Jackson J, 13 November 2026) - scheme approval. JADE (https://jade.io/article/1305166) Peters v Microsoft Corporation [2026] FCA 1754 (Kennett J, 19 November 2026) - misleading conduct. JADE (https://jade.io/article/1305145) Barnden (Trustee), in the matter of Ross (Bankrupt) v Macedo (No 5) [2026] FCA 1762 (Markovic J, 19 November 2026) - bankruptcy, interim property sale. JADE (https://jade.io/article/1305139) DJI20 v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship [2026] FCA 1755 (Kennett J, 19 November 2026) - appeal grounds. JADE (https://jade.io/article/1305146) Rani v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship [2026] FCA 1769 (Sarah C Derrington J, 19 November 2026) - visa refusal. JADE (https://jade.io/article/1305141) Theme music by Michael Green SC.
Episode information is provided by the publisher. Listening takes place on the publisher’s service.
Listen at the source ↗












