Lindsay Clancy: One Juror Changed WHAT Happens Next?!
51 min
Listen through the publisher, then discuss the episode here or arrange an in-person Roundtable. Your city determines where to meet.
Roundtables are designed for groups of four, with a shared subject and room for everyone to speak. Come for discussion, with no dating expectation.
The Lindsay Clancy jury did not agree. Eleven jurors leaned toward acquittal; the twelfth did not. That disagreement ended a trial about the deaths of her three children. But the defense says the court had more work to do before declaring a mistrial. Two notes from the foreperson questioned whether the holdout was following the judge’s directions on reasonable doubt. Judge William Sullivan spoke to jurors, reiterated the instructions, and on September 4, 2026 declared that a unanimous verdict was out of reach. Lindsay’s lawyers argue further inquiry might have revealed a basis to replace the juror. Prosecutors say the jury was genuinely deadlocked and that questioning the juror’s thinking would cross a line courts are not supposed to cross. Defense attorney Kevin Reddington is also seeking scrutiny of the holdout’s confidential questionnaire and phone use. He alleges the juror looked up a psychiatric term, ‘altruistic filicide,’ during deliberations. The juror’s attorney denies improper conduct and says the defense accepted him before trial, then challenged him after the vote. An October 21 ruling denied the defense’s bid to question the juror or inspect the records. The November 2 hearing brought renewed arguments about dismissal, double jeopardy and preserving material; no decision to throw out the case was made. Tony Brueski, criminal defense attorney Bob Motta, and former FBI behavioral expert Robin Dreeke separate a juror’s disagreement from actual misconduct. They discuss why these allegations are serious, why they remain allegations, and what the law protects when jurors deliberate. The case returns November 16. The next fight is not about replaying every witness. It is about whether this jury was allowed to finish its job. Listen Anywhere You Get Podcasts: https://pod.link/1655749292 Want to comment and watch this podcast as a video? Instagram https://www.instagram.com/hiddenkillerspod/ Facebook https://www.facebook.com/hiddenkillerspod/ Tik-Tok https://www.tiktok.com/@hiddenkillerspod X Twitter https://x.com/tonybpod #LindsayClancy #HoldoutJuror #BobMotta #RobinDreeke #HiddenKillers #ClancyTrial #JurorMisconduct #DoubleJeopardy #Massachusetts #TrueCrime
Episode information is provided by the publisher. Listening takes place on the publisher’s service.
This week on the Mark Levin Show, 2028 Republican Presidential candidates must directly address the urgent threats to the country - Marxism and Islamism. These candidates should deliver bold, courageous speeches that clearly explain what is happening in the country, identify those responsible, and directly challenge these threats rather than leaving such warnings to a small number of media voices. Also, it is difficult to believe so many major outages affecting entities such as the NSA, FAA, airline systems, Microsoft, and Apple services could be merely coincidental. The timing and scale of the incidents are troubling and remain inadequately explained. President Trump had proposed a major modernization and restructuring of air traffic control in 2017 that Congress failed to enact. Had those reforms been adopted, many current FAA failures might have been avoided. Later, does Senator John Kennedy know anything about originalism? Originalism is not pure textualism. The meaning and intent
Thanksgiving is here, and some of your aunts and uncles may have softened their stances since last year. So, should you engage when politics comes up? And if so, how? Jessica Tarlov, co-host of Raging Moderates and Fox News’s The Five returns to the show to offer some tips for handling Thanksgiving (and the rest of the year), discusses her new book, and she and Sarah listen to some voters talk about how political divisions have affected their lives…and what those voters think of people who think differently. Show links: Raging Moderates with Scott Galloway and Jessica Tarlov (https://www.youtube.com/@RagingModerates) Jessica’s book, I Disagree: Winning Arguments Without Losing Friends (https://www.penguinrandomhouse.com/books/803493/i-disagree-by-jessica-tarlov/) Feeling frustrated by the state of American democracy? The Context, a podcast from the Charles F. Kettering Foundation, explores the challenges facing democracy, how to fix what’s broken, and what we can do to make it work bet
Iran says it shot down a U.S. drone over the Strait of Hormuz as CBS News reports the U.S. and Israel are weighing a new assault on Iran. MIKE DROP NEWSROOM | 21 NOVEMBER 2026 Iranian state TV claimed Saturday that Iran downed a U.S. drone near Qeshm Island; the U.S. has not confirmed it. CBS News reported, citing sources, that the U.S. and Israel are considering a new assault in the short term, driven by Israeli concern over how fast Iran is rebuilding its missile production and moving sites underground. President Trump told Israel's Channel 12 he is not rushing any decision. At the same time, the New York Times reported Israeli warnings that Iran has made progress on chemical and biological weapons and could use them against U.S. officials, though some U.S. officials doubt those warnings. Mike Ritland breaks down why a single intelligence source shouldn't drive a decision this big, how corroboration works when lives are on the line, and what would actually change his mind. Also cover
Billions in taxpayer dollars allegedly lost to fraud, Chinese-backed efforts to undermine American energy production, and a growing wave of AI-powered cyber threats. Is America doing enough to protect itself? John Solomon and Amanda Head are joined by Minnesota Congressman Pete Stauber, who discusses the expanding welfare fraud scandal, efforts to hold those responsible accountable, and allegations that Chinese-funded organizations are working to obstruct American mining and energy projects. Stauber also addresses permitting reform and the battle over America's critical mineral independence. Then, American Energy Institute CEO and former Texas state representative Jason Isaac warns that proposed electricity price controls could discourage investment, threaten grid reliability, and ultimately drive energy costs even higher. He also examines China's influence over global oil markets, America's growing energy production, and how AI data centers could generate their own electricity rather
Guilty Verdicts have been delivered by a court in Florida against Dwain Hall. The jury took just one hour to decide he kidnapped and murdered Sonia Exelby, a talented pianist and music tutor from Portsmouth. She had been struggling with severe mental illness and Dwain Hall groomed and preyed on her online for two years. He lured her over to the US, he filmed her, beat her, tied her up, murdered her and buried her in a shallow grave. Today her siblings saw justice delivered and as Dwain Hall was given two life sentences, Sonia's brother told him: "You took her from us." Jack was in the courtroom and he and Caroline have all the details from an emotional day. The Trial is part of The Crime Desk. Visit thecrimedesk.com (https://plus.thecrimedesk.com/exelby-podcast?sc_promo=EXELBY) for more information. Email us [email protected] WhatsApp us +447796657512 (start your message with ‘Trial’) Presenters: Caroline Cheetham and Jack Hardy Editor: Tom James and Chelsey Ranore Creative Direct
After some life updates (which is all the people really want to hear anyway), Jonah Goldberg turns his hand to ruminating on Trump’s villainous stupidity, the trilateral summit with Vladimir Putin and Xi Jinping, nuclear policy, New York City’s supermarkets, socialist contempt for the middle class, GDP, Ro Khanna, the Bulwark squabble, recent tech failures, the National Popular Vote Interstate Compact, and magical thinking about politics. Show Notes: —LFG AO Pod (https://thedispatch.com/podcast/advisoryopinions/should-lame-ducks-hibernate/) —Special Event: Advisory Opinions: Live! (https://www.capcitycomedy.com/shows/393484) —Mamdani on supermarkets (https://x.com/MorePerfectUS/status/2123188786926391338/video/1) —Irving Kristol in The Public Interest: “Rationalism in Economics” (https://www.nationalaffairs.com/public_interest/detail/rationalism-in-economics) —American Compass’ postelection survey (https://americancompass.org/post-midterm-survey/) —Dan Senor Remnant (https://thedispatc
Matthew Farwell’s conviction settled the federal case against him. It did not settle what may have happened to evidence, what other officers knew, or how many cases depended on his work as a Stoughton police detective. Tony Brueski is joined by retired FBI agents Jennifer Coffindaffer and Robin Dreeke to connect two questions that belong together: could there be more arrests in the Sandra Birchmore case, and should prosecutors review the cases Farwell once investigated? These are not the same question, and neither has an automatic answer. William Farwell, Matthew’s twin, testified under federal immunity. Former Stoughton deputy chief Robert Devine has contested an oversight board’s findings concerning the “Marty Riggs” Facebook account, saying he was hacked. Neither has been charged in Sandra’s death. Coffindaffer lays out what investigators would need: corroborated communications, authenticated account access, consistent timelines and proof of each person’s conduct. Knowing somebody i
Alex Murdaugh's murder retrial has a new question hanging over it, and it starts with a shirt. The defense says SLED's lead agent, David Owen, described blood spatter to the grand jury even though the agency's own lab had found no human blood in tested stains. It also challenges his claim that shotguns at Moselle were loaded like the weapon used to kill Paul. At the November 13 hearing, Judge Debra McCaslin heard the arguments and did not toss the charges. She said she would try to issue a written decision by November 20. Before adjourning, she asked whether prosecutors could return to a grand jury and keep the April 5, 2027 retrial date. That's a practical question, not a verdict about anyone's honesty. Creighton Waters argued that Owen's statements were not intentionally deceptive and that the spatter expert continued to stand by his interpretation. The State also points to the kennel video and other evidence it says supports the indictment. The defense counters that the grand jury s
Alex Murdaugh's murder conviction is gone because the Supreme Court found his court clerk, Becky Hill, put her fingers on the scales of justice. Nick Reiner can't bring back the lawyer he wants because the woman running his trust is holding the money until a court decides whether he can inherit from the parents he's accused of killing. Eric Faddis, a defense attorney and former prosecutor, takes on both in this full episode. For Alex, that means the no-blood lab result on his T-shirt, the lead state investigator's grand jury testimony that wasn't true, and why Hill was never charged over the jury. For Nick, it's whether about $558,000 that came due before his parents died is already his, what a private lawyer can do that a public defender can't, and why his heroin history could hurt an insanity defense. Both men are presumed innocent. Alex goes back on trial in April. Listen Anywhere You Get Podcasts: https://pod.link/1655749292 Want to comment and watch this podcast as a video? Instag
New local ventures should actively contribute to the surrounding community.
Share your view, then see how readers voted. No sign-in required. This poll is shared across stories.
Do you agree or disagree?
Common Quandary
A Common Quandary to discuss
Another conversation to explore, separate from this news story.
A parent clearly built the winning science project. Who should lose the prize?
An elementary student submits an elaborate science project far beyond their apparent ability. The parent proudly describes working together all weekend, and the child clearly learned something, but other students completed simpler projects themselves.
What is a fair response when help improves learning but distorts achievement?