What If Matthew Farwell Got a Hung Jury? Prosecutors Would Do THIS
16 min
Listen through the publisher, then discuss the episode here or arrange an in-person Roundtable. Your city determines where to meet.
Roundtables are designed for groups of four, with a shared subject and room for everyone to speak. Come for discussion, with no dating expectation.
What if Matthew Farwell's jury hung instead of reaching a verdict? Bob Motta of Defense Diaries says federal prosecutors would try him again, because U.S. attorneys take a loss personally. A not-guilty verdict would be a different story: Farwell would walk out of the courthouse, and Motta says the state couldn't stop that right away. Any state case would land with a new Norfolk DA who doesn't take office until January, and Motta says his wife's research points to a double jeopardy problem for a state murder charge. What's left is a case over what prosecutors say Farwell did when Sandra Birchmore was a teen, and Motta calls that evidence amazing. Tony and retired FBI behavior chief Robin Dreeke ask whether a televised state trial would expose Farwell to far more people than this federal case, which has played out with no cameras, ever has. Listen Anywhere You Get Podcasts: https://pod.link/1655749292 Want to comment and watch this podcast as a video? Instagram https://www.instagram.com/hiddenkillerspod/ Facebook https://www.facebook.com/hiddenkillerspod/ Tik-Tok https://www.tiktok.com/@hiddenkillerspod X Twitter https://x.com/tonybpod #SandraBirchmore #MatthewFarwell #HiddenKillers #FarwellVerdict #HungJury #BobMotta #RobinDreeke #DoubleJeopardy #TrueCrime #HiddenKillersLive
Episode information is provided by the publisher. Listening takes place on the publisher’s service.
This week’s Headline: On November 10th, 2026, ex-cop Matthew Farwell was found guilty in the death of Sandra Birchmore and her unborn child. In 2010, he met Sandra when she was just 12, through a police youth program in Stoughton, Massachusetts, where he was an instructor. By 15, he was sexually abusing her. Years later, she threatened to expose him and got pregnant. When she was found dead, investigators ruled it a suicide. It would take the FBI and 40,000 text messages to prove otherwise. Want all three parts of every case all at once? Need More to Binge? Follow me on Social Instagram: @Crimehouse (https://www.instagram.com/crimehouse/) TikTok: @Crimehouse (https://www.tiktok.com/@crimehouse) X: @crimehousemedia (https://x.com/crimehousemedia) America’s Most Infamous Crimes is hosted by Katie Ring
The former executive director of the Arkansas Supreme Court's Office of Professional Programs has been charged with 65 felonies for allegedly tampering with bar exam scores over at least eight test administrations. Prosecutors say Nancie Givens took points from some examinees and added them to others, pushing some to a passing score and, in at least one case, turning a passing score into a failing one. She is also accused of deleting roughly 11,400 files to cover it up. Givens has pleaded not guilty. This episode breaks down the charges, the timeline, and the legal fallout—including whether convictions obtained by attorneys who may not have legitimately passed could be challenged. General information only, not legal advice. Based on public records and news reports. Thanks for listening to Gavel & Gazette. Legal news, explained. General information only, not legal advice. This episode includes AI-generated content.
Harvey Levin and Mark Geragos break down the disturbing sexual assault allegations against Kim Zolciak and Kroy Biermann’s 15-year-old son, KJ Biermann. With prosecutors pushing to try him as an adult, the two debate whether his parents’ explosive divorce and troubled family history could impact his case, and whether his alleged past behavior could be used against him in court.
Is the Republican Party heading for a major reckoning in 2028? Dave Rubin joins The Chicks on the Right for a brutally honest conversation about Trump's final two years, the future of the GOP, and the growing divisions threatening conservatives. Dave weighs in on the Republican Party's recent election losses, whether JD Vance, Marco Rubio, or Ron DeSantis can carry Trump's agenda forward, and why he's increasingly concerned about the political direction of America. The conversation heats up as Dave takes on Nick Fuentes, the rise of extremist voices on the right, and the socialist movement gaining influence within the Democratic Party. He also discusses radical Islamism, antisemitism, the dangers of online outrage, and why he believes Western civilization faces serious challenges. Plus, with cyberattacks, banking disruptions, and nationwide outages raising concerns, Dave shares his thoughts on whether Americans should be preparing for more chaos. And don't miss the lighter side of Dave
Michael Knowles is about to get a CRASH COURSE in Grand Theft Auto 6 from two REAL tough guys! In this hilarious new video, Michael sits down with two self-proclaimed gangsters who teach him the ins and outs of GTA 6, from surviving the streets to mastering the criminal underworld. Can Michael keep up with these two tough guys, or is he about to discover he's NOT cut out for a life of crime? Watch as Michael gets schooled in GTA 6, and let us know if he has what it takes to survive! - - - Today's Sponsor: Helix Sleep - Take Helix’s two-minute sleep quiz to find the right mattress from more than 20 models, then try it at home with free U.S. shipping and a full 365-night sleep trial. - - - DailyWire: Watch Daily Wire's new movie "Confession" only at: https://www.dailywire.com/videos/confession Don’t dress like a squish. Shop my merch here: https://dwplus.shop/MichaelKnowlesMerch - - - Socials: YouTube — https://youtube.com/@MichaelKnowles Facebook — https://www.facebook.com/michaelknowle
Have you heard about the man in Colorado who used a “killdozer” to settle a zoning dispute, or the Emperor who pickled his wife’s lover? If you love Scams, Money, and Murder, you are going to love this extra episode of The UnBelievable from Rewind Studios and the History Channel for Thanksgiving. Each episode opens a cabinet of curiosities filled with the strangest-but-true stories from history. When it comes to history, the truth is always more unbelievable than you think. Follow The UnBelievable for a new episode every Friday: https://pod.link/6815976107 Thank you to our experts who contributed to this episode: David O’Keefe, Mitch Horowitz, Larissa Tracy, Rebecca Hsu, Rutledge Wood, Allie Delury, Holly Frey, Sami Jarroush, Paul Sutter, Matthew Steiner, Kavitha Davidson, Yohuru Williams, Narayanan Kasthuri, Chris Mowery, Brandy Schillace, Jason Sweet, and Pryia Krishna.
Matthew Farwell’s conviction settled the federal case against him. It did not settle what may have happened to evidence, what other officers knew, or how many cases depended on his work as a Stoughton police detective. Tony Brueski is joined by retired FBI agents Jennifer Coffindaffer and Robin Dreeke to connect two questions that belong together: could there be more arrests in the Sandra Birchmore case, and should prosecutors review the cases Farwell once investigated? These are not the same question, and neither has an automatic answer. William Farwell, Matthew’s twin, testified under federal immunity. Former Stoughton deputy chief Robert Devine has contested an oversight board’s findings concerning the “Marty Riggs” Facebook account, saying he was hacked. Neither has been charged in Sandra’s death. Coffindaffer lays out what investigators would need: corroborated communications, authenticated account access, consistent timelines and proof of each person’s conduct. Knowing somebody i
Alex Murdaugh's murder retrial has a new question hanging over it, and it starts with a shirt. The defense says SLED's lead agent, David Owen, described blood spatter to the grand jury even though the agency's own lab had found no human blood in tested stains. It also challenges his claim that shotguns at Moselle were loaded like the weapon used to kill Paul. At the November 13 hearing, Judge Debra McCaslin heard the arguments and did not toss the charges. She said she would try to issue a written decision by November 20. Before adjourning, she asked whether prosecutors could return to a grand jury and keep the April 5, 2027 retrial date. That's a practical question, not a verdict about anyone's honesty. Creighton Waters argued that Owen's statements were not intentionally deceptive and that the spatter expert continued to stand by his interpretation. The State also points to the kennel video and other evidence it says supports the indictment. The defense counters that the grand jury s
Alex Murdaugh's murder conviction is gone because the Supreme Court found his court clerk, Becky Hill, put her fingers on the scales of justice. Nick Reiner can't bring back the lawyer he wants because the woman running his trust is holding the money until a court decides whether he can inherit from the parents he's accused of killing. Eric Faddis, a defense attorney and former prosecutor, takes on both in this full episode. For Alex, that means the no-blood lab result on his T-shirt, the lead state investigator's grand jury testimony that wasn't true, and why Hill was never charged over the jury. For Nick, it's whether about $558,000 that came due before his parents died is already his, what a private lawyer can do that a public defender can't, and why his heroin history could hurt an insanity defense. Both men are presumed innocent. Alex goes back on trial in April. Listen Anywhere You Get Podcasts: https://pod.link/1655749292 Want to comment and watch this podcast as a video? Instag
Creators should be compensated when their work is used commercially to train AI systems.
Share your view, then see how readers voted. No sign-in required. This poll is shared across stories.
Do you agree or disagree?
Common Quandary
A Common Quandary to discuss
Another conversation to explore, separate from this news story.
An old friend refuses to use someone's new name. Do you correct them at the reunion?
At a reunion, an old friend repeatedly uses the name a former classmate had years ago. They say shared history gives the old name affectionate meaning; the classmate has clearly introduced themselves with a different name.
When does preserving your shared past deny who someone is now?