English-language podcasts

Scottish Football Podcast

What is going wrong at Aberdeen?

29 min

Listen through the publisher, then discuss the episode here or arrange an in-person Roundtable. Your city determines where to meet.

Roundtables are designed for groups of four, with a shared subject and room for everyone to speak. Come for discussion, with no dating expectation.

Stephen Robinson is out at Aberdeen after a torrid start to the season, but is changing the manager really enough to solve the problems at Pittodrie? Charlotte Cohen is joined by Michael Grant and JJ Bull to ask why Robinson couldn’t make it work and how much responsibility lies with the club’s hierarchy and recruitment. Why have the Dons struggled to find stability? What does the next manager need to change? And should Aberdeen look close to home for Robinson’s successor, or could an overseas coach finally provide the identity and long-term direction the club has been searching for? 00:02:04 — Why Robinson had to go 00:03:23 — Why couldn’t he make it work? 00:08:15 — Was Robinson doomed from the start? 00:13:04 — Are Aberdeen’s problems bigger than the manager? 00:16:19 — What must Aberdeen do differently now? 00:21:53 — Who should be the next Dons manager?

Episode information is provided by the publisher. Listening takes place on the publisher’s service.

Listen at the source ↗

Featured places to meet in Palo Alto, CA

Explore these places and arrange a conversation through ThinkMatch.

City guide for Palo Alto, CA

More from Scottish Football Podcast

Scottish Football Podcast

The Premiership is back: Can Falkirk really finish third?

28 min

The Premiership is back with a bumper six-game Saturday and plenty at stake. Are high-flying Falkirk genuine contenders to finish third, or can St Johnstone bring them back down to earth? Celtic remain top, but why have performances left supporters wanting more, and can struggling St Mirren cause a surprise? David Currie is joined by Scott Allan and Moira Gordon as they assess Hibs' revival against in-form Dundee United, Hearts' injury problems ahead of their trip to Dundee, and whether Motherwell can become the first side in 13 matches to beat Rangers. 01:33 — Can Falkirk really finish third? 03:40 — St Johnstone eye the top six 06:32 — What’s missing at Celtic? 12:52 — Are Hibs finally turning a corner? 18:31 — Hearts hurting ahead of Dundee trip 22:15 — Can Motherwell stop Rangers’ unbeaten run?

Discuss this episode

Scottish Football Podcast

Who should be worried in the Premiership bottom four?

25 min

Just four points separate Motherwell, Hibs, Aberdeen and Kilmarnock at the bottom end of the Premiership, so who should be most worried? Jane Lewis is joined by former striker Conor Sammon and football writer Alison McConnell to assess the survival fight. Are Hibs finally turning a corner after back-to-back wins? Can Motherwell build some momentum after a difficult start? And what impact can new Aberdeen boss Mario Frick make? Plus, with Killie leaking goals, can Neil McCann find a way to tighten things up ahead of a huge showdown with Aberdeen at Rugby Park? 00:01:33 — Is it time for the bottom four to worry? 00:02:48 — Are Hibs turning a corner? 00:08:45 — Why hasn’t it clicked for Motherwell? 00:12:39 — How crucial is experience in a relegation fight? 00:14:20 — Can Mario Frick lift Aberdeen? 00:21:18 — Can Kilmarnock stop leaking goals?

Discuss this episode

Scottish Football Podcast

Pocognoli: The Case For The Defence

27 min

Six games, two wins and three defeats. Scotland’s new era hasn’t gone to plan, so what needs to change before qualifying resumes in March? Stephen McGowan and Rory Loy join Martin Dowden to assess a worrying run of form. Is the system getting the best from the players? Should Scotland be making more use of their younger talent? How much responsibility lies with the players, the manager and those who appointed him? And with confidence draining away, can Scotland turn things around and reach Euro 2028 on merit? 00:01:54 — Apathy and frustration: How bad is it? 00:05:32 — Is Scotland’s system the problem? 00:08:59 — Should the players take more responsibility? 00:13:22 — Why are Scotland so easy to play through? 00:16:25 — Will the SFA stick or twist? 00:18:09 — Can Scotland still qualify on merit?

Discuss this episode

Community Poll

Residents should help decide which activities are allowed in shared public spaces.

Share your view, then see how readers voted. No sign-in required. This poll is shared across stories.

Do you agree or disagree?

Choose one answer

Common Quandary

A Common Quandary to discuss

Another conversation to explore, separate from this news story.

A disgraced billionaire's name is on the beloved campus library. Does it come down?

A major donor funded a beloved public building decades ago. New evidence shows they also caused serious harm that was legal and accepted by many peers at the time. Removing the name may jeopardize future donations.

What does an institution owe the truth when its history funded the present?

Explore this quandary