Why Negotiating With Iran Won't Work | Victor Davis Hanson
96 min
Listen through the publisher, then discuss the episode here or arrange an in-person Roundtable. Your city determines where to meet.
Roundtables are designed for groups of four, with a shared subject and room for everyone to speak. Come for discussion, with no dating expectation.
Decades of failed diplomacy with Iran have raised questions about whether Tehran can be trusted to honor a deal and whether negotiations can prevent further conflict. As Trump takes military action against Iran, growing divisions within MAGA are fueling clashes over the war, America's relationship with Israel, and the influence of neoconservatives. Steve Bannon and other prominent conservatives are challenging Trump's approach, exposing a deeper divide over the future of American foreign policy. CovePure - Visit CovePure.com/VDH, where they’re giving our listeners a special 40% discount for Black Friday and holiday shopping! Allegiance Gold - Visit http://protectwithvictor.com to learn about a special Liberty Offer. City Journal, published by the Manhattan Institute - Visit our college rankings and see how your school measures up at http:/collegerankings.city-journal.org Alliance Defending Freedom - Go to http:/JoinADF.com/HANSON or text HANSON to 83848 to make your tax-deductible gift today. NEW FILM, The Immigration Crisis That Will Destroy The West, presented by The Heritage Foundation, OUT NOW: https://youtu.be/pX0rwaEs5jA?si=p-Brtu2N961oMS9y
Episode information is provided by the publisher. Listening takes place on the publisher’s service.
The industry is operating on flawed assumptions. Most days, our technological landscape feels unshakeably miraculous. You can save hundreds of thousands of documents in organized folders and send messages to a friend on the other side of the world in mere seconds; the internet crams all recorded knowledge into your pocket; personal agents sit at your beck and call to schedule doctor appointments or retrieve any information you might need; and AI software can crunch more data in one minute than you could in a lifetime. We’ve made it. Except this week things felt precarious. Black Friday Deal! Steepest discount we've ever done. Suspension of the Rules. A “software Beirut”? Apps and emails and agencies going down? Advisories to stockpile supplies? On this week’s Suspension of the Rules, Isaac, Kmele, and guest host Audrey Moorehead break down AI-related fears and how they’re thinking about the past week’s news. You can watch here. (https://youtu.be/WE5W7gWozQs?si=lC7wGwKSxi2IPy4p) The Gre
For review: 1. Iraq has reached a compromise with the powerful Iran-backed militia Kataeb Hezbollah, three senior security officials said, after Prime Minister Ali al-Zaidi readied security forces to move against the group. Reflecting the gravity of the situation, Iraqi Shiite political sources said Esmail Qaani, commander of Iran’s elite Revolutionary Guards’ Quds Force, arrived in Baghdad late on Monday to help defuse tensions with Kataeb Hezbollah, Tehran’s most powerful militia ally in Iraq. 2. Lebanese President Joseph Aoun launched a lengthy rebuke of Iran in an Independence Day address, arguing that the Islamic Republic does not have the right to interfere in Lebanon’s internal affairs, as it long has via support for its local terror proxy, Hezbollah. 3. Yemen’s Houthis launched strikes on the Saudi capital Riyadh on Saturday, after vowing reprisals for a “special operation” by the Saudi-led coalition fighting them. The coalition later said it had “intercepted and destroyed” thr
On this week’s edition of “Happy Hour,” Emily Jashinsky tackles whether America’s political system is irreparably broken, the growing distrust of political institutions, and why voters are increasingly fed up with corruption and self-serving politicians. She discusses Thomas Massie’s political future, the possibility of breaking up the two-party system, why she generally distrusts ProPublica’s reporting, and the ethics of the Supreme Court. She also weighs in on the dangers of authoritarian communism, foreign influence in Washington, and why maintaining faith in elections is so important. Emily addresses the political risks of embracing artificial intelligence, which careers might survive the technological revolution, and why she struggles to unplug from work. Finally, she shares her favorite time to visit Washington, D.C., her thoughts on Robert Pattinson as the next James Bond, and more… Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company.
Is the Republican Party heading for a major reckoning in 2028? Dave Rubin joins The Chicks on the Right for a brutally honest conversation about Trump's final two years, the future of the GOP, and the growing divisions threatening conservatives. Dave weighs in on the Republican Party's recent election losses, whether JD Vance, Marco Rubio, or Ron DeSantis can carry Trump's agenda forward, and why he's increasingly concerned about the political direction of America. The conversation heats up as Dave takes on Nick Fuentes, the rise of extremist voices on the right, and the socialist movement gaining influence within the Democratic Party. He also discusses radical Islamism, antisemitism, the dangers of online outrage, and why he believes Western civilization faces serious challenges. Plus, with cyberattacks, banking disruptions, and nationwide outages raising concerns, Dave shares his thoughts on whether Americans should be preparing for more chaos. And don't miss the lighter side of Dave
Thanksgiving is here, and some of your aunts and uncles may have softened their stances since last year. So, should you engage when politics comes up? And if so, how? Jessica Tarlov, co-host of Raging Moderates and Fox News’s The Five returns to the show to offer some tips for handling Thanksgiving (and the rest of the year), discusses her new book, and she and Sarah listen to some voters talk about how political divisions have affected their lives…and what those voters think of people who think differently. Show links: Raging Moderates with Scott Galloway and Jessica Tarlov (https://www.youtube.com/@RagingModerates) Jessica’s book, I Disagree: Winning Arguments Without Losing Friends (https://www.penguinrandomhouse.com/books/803493/i-disagree-by-jessica-tarlov/) Feeling frustrated by the state of American democracy? The Context, a podcast from the Charles F. Kettering Foundation, explores the challenges facing democracy, how to fix what’s broken, and what we can do to make it work bet
Hey everybody, Tom Bilyeu here. On today’s episode of Impact Theory, we’re taking on a topic that’s got the whole world holding its breath: the escalating crisis between the United States and Iran. As tensions ratchet up, we’re asking the tough questions—how did we get stuck in this “escalation trap,” and what does it mean for America’s global leverage, our economy, and our very sense of security? The conversation focused on why the traditional idea of “strategy” might be failing policymakers, using powerful analogies—like chess versus roulette—to show how doubling down in conflict can spiral out of control. We’ll break down the risks of tactical “wins” that create even bigger crises, the real leverage Iran holds with control of the Strait of Hormuz, and the mounting pressure on President Trump as political support erodes and legacy hangs in the balance. A key theme that emerged is what happens when military might runs into decentralized opposition, and why high-stakes gambles—like the
President Donald Trump's first ever trilateral summit with Vladimir Putin and Xi Jinping raises questions about the future of the war in Ukraine and whether a peace agreement could finally be within reach. Victor Davis Hanson and Sami Winc examine the summit on today’s edition of “Victor Davis Hanson: In His Own Words,” discussing Russia's declining influence, potential territorial concessions in Ukraine, and Europe's frustration over Trump's peace negotiations. Hanson criticizes Hillary Clinton's attacks on Trump's diplomacy; he also argues that European leaders have weakened their influence by neglecting defense spending and relying on American military protection. They discuss Elon Musk's shifting political allegiances, and Hanson warns that distancing himself from MAGA may not protect him from Democrat investigations. They also discuss the potential economic benefits of artificial intelligence and the challenges facing Hakeem Jeffries as Democrats prepare to take control of the Hou
JD Vance’s relationship with Tucker Carlson and the growing divide within MAGA over the Iran war could spell trouble for Republicans heading into 2028. Victor Davis Hanson breaks down Republican infighting, the rise of antisemitism in American politics, and the hypocrisy behind Hillary Clinton’s criticism of Trump’s foreign policy. My Patriot Supply - Go to https:/preparewithvdh.com and save. Home Title Lock - Go to https://hometitlelock.com/victor to apply promo code VICTOR for a FREE title history report and a FREE TRIAL of their Triple Lock Protection. Simple - Visit https:/Simple.life to get your personalized weight loss plan. Alliance Defending Freedom - Go to https:/JoinADF.com/HANSON or text HANSON to 83848 to make your tax-deductible gift today. NEW FILM, The Immigration Crisis That Will Destroy The West, presented by The Heritage Foundation, OUT NOW: https://youtu.be/pX0rwaEs5jA?si=p-Brtu2N961oMS9y
Marco Rubio delivered a powerful defense of American sovereignty in his speech to the Federalist Society. Meanwhile, democratic socialists are turning on their own party’s leadership as the radical left grows increasingly emboldened following the midterms. Allegiance Gold - Visit http://protectwithvictor.com to learn about a special Liberty Offer. Vaer Watches - Go to http://www.vaerwatches.com/vdh City Journal, published by the Manhattan Institute - Visit our college rankings and see how your school measures up at http://collegerankings.city-journal.org (http://collegerankings.city-journal.org/) NEW FILM, The Immigration Crisis That Will Destroy The West, presented by The Heritage Foundation, OUT NOW: https://youtu.be/pX0rwaEs5jA?si=p-Brtu2N961oMS9y “The Counterrevolution: The Fall and Rise of Donald Trump and the MAGA Movement” NOW: https://www.amazon.com/Counterrevolution-Fall-Donald-Trump-Movement-ebook/dp/B0GF1K43WM
Platforms should prioritize preventing harassment even when this limits some expression.
Share your view, then see how readers voted. No sign-in required. This poll is shared across stories.
Do you agree or disagree?
Common Quandary
A Common Quandary to discuss
Another conversation to explore, separate from this news story.
One friend is rich, one is broke, and everyone ordered differently. How do you split dinner?
A group of longtime friends traditionally divides restaurant bills equally. Their incomes have grown increasingly unequal, and one friend now declines gatherings because even their share is difficult to afford while others order without thinking about price.
When should friendship adjust for differences in wealth?