Gruesome Murder Cases Where the Truth Is Still Disputed
162 min
Listen through the publisher, then discuss the episode here or arrange an in-person Roundtable. Your city determines where to meet.
Roundtables are designed for groups of four, with a shared subject and room for everyone to speak. Come for discussion, with no dating expectation.
This gripping episode examines five infamous cases where verdicts failed to end public debate. From Lizzie Borden's 1893 acquittal to Sam Sheppard's media circus trial, Michael Peterson's staircase mystery, and Adnan Syed's podcast-fuelled controversy, each case demonstrates how juries deliver answers whilst leaving fundamental questions stubbornly, maddeningly unresolved for generations.
Episode information is provided by the publisher. Listening takes place on the publisher’s service.
My sister Shannon McDonald Goldstein, a criminal defense attorney, joins me to dig into two cases that have haunted us for decades and are back in the spotlight with new documentaries: Natalee Holloway and JonBenét Ramsey. We go back to that senior trip to Aruba and walk through Joran van der Sloot's ever-changing stories, the local connections that slowed the investigation, and how it became a 24/7 media frenzy. Then we revisit the JonBenét case 30 years later, from the pageant world we know a little too well to the questions about what the Ramseys knew, and whether DNA could finally give us answers. We also share our own wild spring break stories, and Shannon explains why the three minor siblings in the K.J. Berman case just got their own attorney. You won't want to miss this one!
Alex Murdaugh's murder retrial has a new question hanging over it, and it starts with a shirt. The defense says SLED's lead agent, David Owen, described blood spatter to the grand jury even though the agency's own lab had found no human blood in tested stains. It also challenges his claim that shotguns at Moselle were loaded like the weapon used to kill Paul. At the November 13 hearing, Judge Debra McCaslin heard the arguments and did not toss the charges. She said she would try to issue a written decision by November 20. Before adjourning, she asked whether prosecutors could return to a grand jury and keep the April 5, 2027 retrial date. That's a practical question, not a verdict about anyone's honesty. Creighton Waters argued that Owen's statements were not intentionally deceptive and that the spatter expert continued to stand by his interpretation. The State also points to the kennel video and other evidence it says supports the indictment. The defense counters that the grand jury s
In the 20th century, a secret society known as the Priory of Sion claimed to protect a hidden bloodline tied to Jesus Christ and Mary Magdalene, a revelation that, if true, would rewrite the foundations of religious history. The group alleged that this lineage had been preserved for centuries and concealed from the public by powerful institutions. In today's first episode of Cults & Cons, Vanessa Richardson examines the origins of the Priory of Sion, the documents that brought it to global attention, and the man behind its most controversial claims. As the story spread through books and media, it blurred the line between historical theory and elaborate hoax. Was the Priory of Sion a genuine secret society guarding a hidden truth, or a myth that spiraled far beyond its origins? And for more cases just like this one, be sure to check out the Crime House Original, Conspiracy Theories, Cults, & Crimes. Need More to Binge? Follow me on Social X: @crimehousemedia (https://x.com/crimehousemed
At 1:42 a.m., a message appeared in a fraternity group chat at Cornell University. What was happening inside that house—and how many people knew? In October 2024, a Cornell student known as Jane Doe went to the Chi Phi fraternity house to spend time with someone she trusted. What followed would become the subject of a sexual assault investigation, university disciplinary proceedings, and a lawsuit naming seven fraternity members. But the story is far more complicated than a single allegation. There are conflicting accounts of consent, messages sent while the night was still unfolding, people who entered and left the room, and questions about who witnessed what—and whether anyone should have intervened. In Part 1, Tyrella and Nikita reconstruct the night through Jane Doe's statements, the men's accounts, text messages, and investigative records. Because this case isn't just about what allegedly happened inside one room. It's about how many people can be present—and how differently they
True Crime Tuesday Presents: The Candy Man Murders: Three Years of Terror in Houston with Podcaster/ Author Jen Schaffer! In the early 1970s, teenage boys began disappearing across Houston, Texas. One by one, they vanished, leaving behind empty bedrooms, unanswered questions, and a city that chose not to look too closely. Police called them runaways. Parents were told to be patient. Lack of concern caused a pattern to go unnoticed, until a single phone call changed everything. On August 8, 1973, a teenage boy confessed to killing a man and exposed a horror hidden in plain sight. What followed was one of the most disturbing discoveries in American criminal history: a network of abduction, torture, and murder that had operated undetected for years. In The "Candy Man" Murders (https://wbp.bz/candymanmurders) (opens in new tab) (https://wbp.bz/candymanmurders), Jen Schaffer delivers a haunting, deeply researched account of the Houston Mass Murders. Through meticulous investigation and grip
Hit subscribe so you don't miss any updates. Supported by True Crime Channel. ------- On the evening of 18 March 2009, Claudia Lawrence, a 35-year-old chef at the University of York, went home to her house on Heworth Road. The next morning she failed to arrive for her early shift, and she has never been seen since. More than seventeen years later, nobody has been charged, her body has never been found, and North Yorkshire Police treat her disappearance as suspected murder. Now, newly upscaled CCTV footage offers a clearer look at that night than ever before. In this special documentary, filmed on location in York, we retrace the streets around Claudia's home: from the Minster to Heworth Road, the alleyway behind her house and the corner where a CCTV camera was recording that night. We're also among the first to be allowed to film inside the Nags Head, Claudia's local pub, and we sit down with Tom McDermott to go through what happened in the hours before she vanished. At the centre of t
In 1995, Mark Winger claimed he heroically shot an intruder he found beating his wife Donnah with a hammer. Police initially accepted his account, labelling driver Roger Harrington a deranged killer. Years later, new evidence revealed Mark had orchestrated both murders to escape his marriage whilst framing an innocent man.
Betsy Faria was brutally murdered in December 2011, and police arrested her husband Russ despite his solid alibi. Friend Pam Hupp, who inherited Betsy's life insurance and was last seen with her, escaped scrutiny. After Russ's wrongful conviction was overturned, Hupp killed again, finally exposing her as the true culprit.
Faith Hedgepeth, a nineteen-year-old University of North Carolina student, was sexually assaulted and bludgeoned to death in her Durham apartment in September 2012. Despite extensive DNA evidence, the case remained unsolved for nine years until genealogy testing identified Miguel Salguerro-Olivares. In 2026, he was convicted and sentenced to life imprisonment.
Environmental marketing claims should require independent verification.
Share your view, then see how readers voted. No sign-in required. This poll is shared across stories.
Do you agree or disagree?
Common Quandary
A Common Quandary to discuss
Another conversation to explore, separate from this news story.
Your host demands shoes off, but their floor is filthy. Must you obey?
A host has a strict shoes-off rule and points to a neat row by the door. Inside, the floor is visibly sticky and covered with pet hair. You are wearing clean shoes, no socks, and would rather not spend the evening barefoot.
When does respect for a host's home yield to a guest's comfort?