In 1995, Mark Winger claimed he heroically shot an intruder he found beating his wife Donnah with a hammer. Police initially accepted his account, labelling driver Roger Harrington a deranged killer. Years later, new evidence revealed Mark had orchestrated both murders to escape his marriage whilst framing an innocent man.
Betsy Faria was brutally murdered in December 2011, and police arrested her husband Russ despite his solid alibi. Friend Pam Hupp, who inherited Betsy's life insurance and was last seen with her, escaped scrutiny. After Russ's wrongful conviction was overturned, Hupp killed again, finally exposing her as the true culprit.
Faith Hedgepeth, a nineteen-year-old University of North Carolina student, was sexually assaulted and bludgeoned to death in her Durham apartment in September 2012. Despite extensive DNA evidence, the case remained unsolved for nine years until genealogy testing identified Miguel Salguerro-Olivares. In 2026, he was convicted and sentenced to life imprisonment.
Thomas Randolph married six times, with four wives dying suspiciously whilst he collected hefty life insurance payouts. When his sixth wife Sharon was shot dead in 2008, he killed the alleged intruder, his own handyman. Detectives uncovered disturbing patterns spanning decades, eventually securing his conviction for murder after two trials.