New Zealand Edition (3 November 2026)

Listen through the publisher, then discuss the episode here or arrange an in-person Roundtable. Your city determines where to meet.
Roundtables are designed for groups of four, with a shared subject and room for everyone to speak. Come for discussion, with no dating expectation.
The Petal's New Zealand edition for Tuesday 3 November 2026 carries 10 decisions newly reported from the Supreme Court and the High Court. Seven are aired at depth and three in the registry. The thread is that what goes on the table stays there: an admission that cannot be unmade while the advice behind it stays privileged, costs a non-party can claim if it shows its working, a loan that buys no seat without security, and a confession that should have been recorded when it counted. Practice and Procedure Desk (lead). Financial Markets Authority (Formerly Commerce Commission) v Second Chance Finance Limited [2026] NZHC 3321 - leave to withdraw an admission under r 15.16(2) of the High Court Rules 2016 is a discretion exercised in the interests of justice and needs a reasoned case, not a change of mind (Bridgecorp applied); where withdrawal rests on allegedly inadequate legal advice, the Court will not accept the applicant's untested account while privilege over that advice is withheld; prejudice to the regulator and borrowers, time-barred abandoned claims and delay weighed against leave, and granting it would undermine regulators' willingness to settle. Application declined; the penalty hearing is to come (Wilkinson-Smith J, 23 October 2026). JADE (https://jade.io/article/1293825) Lun v Kong [2026] NZHC 3294 - a non-party is entitled to its actual reasonable costs, usually in full, of both the application and compliance (rr 8.21, 8.22(3)); an unopposed application still requires reasonable attendances; global invoices without a narrative of steps, hours and disbursements cannot be assessed, so an interim payment, security in a solicitor's trust account on undertakings and a single final determination were ordered (Associate Judge Wild, 21 October 2026). JADE (https://jade.io/article/1293824) Commercial Law Desk. Scott v Bourke [2026] NZHC 3179 - joinder under r 4.56(1)(b) is a two-stage inquiry needing at least a tenable claim to rights directly affected by the orders; a mere creditor's interest is not enough; orders under ss 339 and 343 of the Property Law Act 2007 cannot direct payment to an unsecured creditor; trustees of a bare trust cannot prefer one beneficiary over another. Joinder declined (Associate Judge Wroe, 15 October 2026). JADE (https://jade.io/article/1293820) AE Logistics Ltd v Sylvia Park Business Centre Ltd [2026] NZHC 3257 - where a lease validly excludes the covenants implied by sch 3 of the Property Law Act 2007 (s 279), there is no arguable sch 3 abatement claim; transitory interference does not make premises untenantable; a counterclaim needs evidence of duty, breach and loss; a no set-off clause answered set-off against rent. Application to set aside the statutory demand (s 290(4) Companies Act 1993) dismissed (Associate Judge Wroe, 21 October 2026). JADE (https://jade.io/article/1293823) Criminal Law Desk. R v Tukaokao [2026] NZHC 2740 - police may question a person advised to stay silent if the person knows their rights and there is no bad faith, oppression or overbearing conduct; cognitive impairment does not make questioning unfair where rights are understood and real choices made; the right to a lawyer is waived where an offered call is knowingly declined; isolated appeals to conscience are not improper; an unrecorded admission in breach of r 5 of the Practice Note on police questioning was improperly obtained, but exclusion was disproportionate under s 30 of the Evidence Act 2006. Statements held admissible (MacGillivray J, 9 September 2026). JADE (https://jade.io/article/1293817) B (SC 77/2026) v The King [2026] NZSC 168 - reported as legal doctrine only. Where evidence of a complainant's behaviour is given, the judge should consider directing the jury on its proper use, and it will generally be important to warn against jumping from behavioural change to the conclusion that the offending occurred; the general directions given were sufficient, a further direction may have been counterproductive, and no miscarriage arose. Leave dismissed (Ellen France, Cooke and Campbell JJ, 3 November 2026). JADE (https://jade.io/article/1293518) Chief Executive of the Department of Corrections v Hawkins [2026] NZHC 2842 - reported as legal doctrine only. On an unopposed extended supervision order application the Court must still be satisfied that the criteria in ss 107I and 107IAA of the Parole Act 2002 are met, consent going only to discretion; a proclivity need not be manifest at all times; actuarial tools may form part of the risk assessment. Two-year order made (MacGillivray J, 16 September 2026). JADE (https://jade.io/article/1293818) Registry. Body Corporate 355711 v Wymount Property Services Ltd (In Liquidation) [2026] NZHC 3170 - liquidators' remuneration must be fair and reasonable for the value delivered, whatever the prior disclosure; a rate above that approved on appointment was not approved retrospectively (Associate Judge Malarao). JADE (https://jade.io/article/1293819) Moore v Police [2026] NZHC 3214 - the least restrictive outcome principle does not compel home detention; sentencing reasons are read as a whole; appeal dismissed (Crook J). JADE (https://jade.io/article/1293822) Davey v Cardinali [2026] NZHC 3213 - final judgments are not to be subverted by collateral challenge once appeal rights are exhausted; stay applications struck out (Andrew J). JADE (https://jade.io/article/1293821) B and Hawkins arise from sexual offending and are reported as legal doctrine only, with no one identified. The penalty in Second Chance Finance, the sale and relationship property proceedings in Scott, and the proceeding in Lun continue; Tukaokao is reported as a ruling on evidence. Nothing in this episode predicts any outcome. No decision in the edition was rejected. Theme music by Michael Green SC.
Episode information is provided by the publisher. Listening takes place on the publisher’s service.
Listen at the source ↗












