English-language podcasts

Oral Arguments, with Context

Smith v. Smith — 5th Cir. (Nov 3, 2026)

36 min

Listen through the publisher, then discuss the episode here or arrange an in-person Roundtable. Your city determines where to meet.

Roundtables are designed for groups of four, with a shared subject and room for everyone to speak. Come for discussion, with no dating expectation.

The Fifth Circuit hears Smith versus Smith, a dispute about medical care for a prisoner with severe chronic pain. Before entering prison, the patient had a spinal cord stimulator implanted to ease his pain, but the device stopped working properly. Doctors recommended repair or replacement, and he says prison officials repeatedly refused under a blanket policy against servicing those devices. The device was later removed, but he maintains that his pain has not been adequately treated. This appeal concerns a medical supervisor, Doctor Smith. The district judge declined to dismiss the claim against him, accepting the pleaded allegations that he either participated in denying care or helped create or implement the policy. That was a pleading decision, not a finding after trial that those allegations are true. The Eighth Amendment prohibits deliberate indifference to serious medical needs, but a mistake, negligence, or disagreement about the best treatment is not automatically a constitutional violation. Qualified immunity is an additional protection against damages liability unless an official violates a federal right that was already clearly established in the circumstances. Doctor Smith will argue that the complaint gives no specific facts connecting him to the patient's treatment decisions or the disputed policy, and does not show that he had fair notice of unlawful conduct. The prisoner will argue that the continuing denial of effective care reflects a policy, not an individualized medical judgment, and that the supervisor is responsible for implementing it. A supervisory title alone does not make someone liable for every act of the doctors below him. Listen for the distinction between a genuine medical choice among treatments, and a categorical refusal to consider care that a patient needs. The panel must also separate earlier events involving other officials from the allegations against this particular doctor. This hearing is about whether the claim can proceed against him, not a trial deciding what happened or prescribing a particular course of treatment. Smith v. Smith (No. 25-20090) — U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit, argued November 3, 2026. Sources: Argument audio — official Fifth Circuit recording: Case and argument date — official Fifth Circuit index: Challenged pleading-stage decision for Dr. Smith — Doc 91, Feb 14, 2025; allegations not trial findings: Earlier dispute involving other officials — unpublished Fifth Circuit opinion, Oct 12, 2022; not this appeal's outcome:

Episode information is provided by the publisher. Listening takes place on the publisher’s service.

Listen at the source ↗

Featured places to meet in Palo Alto, CA

Explore these places and arrange a conversation through ThinkMatch.

City guide for Palo Alto, CA

More from Oral Arguments, with Context

Oral Arguments, with Context

Dickerson v. Macmillan, et al. — 9th Cir. (Nov 20, 2026)

41 min

The Ninth Circuit considers a shareholder's challenge to disclosures used to sell UserTesting. During negotiations, Thoma Bravo reduced a proposed ten-dollar-a-share offer to seven dollars and fifty cents. The board initially rejected that lower price, but later recommended a deal at that price to shareholders. The shareholder alleges that the merger's proxy statement wrongly made the company's revenue performance look worse than it was. The disputed sentence grouped revenue with calculated billings and said both had fallen short of expectations. Her theory is that this depressed picture helped persuade shareholders to accept too little for their stock. That is an allegation, not a finding that the deal was unfair. The district court dismissed the revised complaint. Although it had treated the disputed sentence as false or misleading, it said the allegations still sounded in fraud and failed the stricter requirements for pleading the executive's responsibility. The shareholder will arg

Discuss this episode

Oral Arguments, with Context

Canandaigua National Corporation v. Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System — 2d Cir. (Nov 20, 2026)

42 min

The Second Circuit considers a plan to help homebuyers who need mortgages compete with cash offers. Canandaigua National Corporation, a New York financial holding company, wanted to guarantee purchases arranged through its mortgage subsidiary. If a preapproved customer failed to obtain final mortgage approval, the company would buy the home itself and later resell it. The proposal capped the value of homes held at any one time at five million dollars and promised resale within two years. Canandaigua says those safeguards make the risk small. The Federal Reserve Board rejected the plan on safety-and-soundness grounds, looking beyond the risk to this particular company. It did not finally decide the remaining statutory factors. Canandaigua will argue that the Board ignored the limits in its actual application. The Board will defend considering what could happen if financial holding companies generally began buying property under such guarantees. This is a dispute over permission for a pr

Discuss this episode

Oral Arguments, with Context

EcoHub, LLC v. Recology, Inc., et al. — 9th Cir. (Nov 20, 2026)

38 min

The Ninth Circuit hears a dispute over a proposed waste-processing project in California. Nortech already operated the Western Placer Waste Management Authority's facility. It worked with EcoHub on a proposal for the facility's future, first seeking a contract extension and then preparing for competitive bidding. The collaboration broke down. Nortech ended discussions after EcoHub failed to produce a requested financing commitment. EcoHub says the financing demand was a pretext, and that Recology pushed Nortech to abandon their joint effort. EcoHub and Nortech eventually submitted separate bids. Neither won. EcoHub nevertheless says their work together had already created a legal partnership, with duties Nortech could not simply walk away from. The district court ruled against EcoHub before trial, finding insufficient evidence of shared control. It also found EcoHub's interference claims against Recology were brought too late. EcoHub will argue that the companies' conduct and board dis

Discuss this episode

Community Poll

Researchers should publish important limitations alongside the main findings.

Share your view, then see how readers voted. No sign-in required. This poll is shared across stories.

Do you agree or disagree?

Choose one answer

Common Quandary

A Common Quandary to discuss

Another conversation to explore, separate from this news story.

Would you want a doctor to give you a fake pill if the lie might make you feel better?

A patient has persistent symptoms that have not responded to standard treatments. A harmless placebo may help, but its effect could weaken if the clinician fully explains that it contains no active medicine.

Can a beneficial deception respect the person it helps?

Explore this quandary