The Ninth Circuit considers a shareholder's challenge to disclosures used to sell UserTesting. During negotiations, Thoma Bravo reduced a proposed ten-dollar-a-share offer to seven dollars and fifty cents. The board initially rejected that lower price, but later recommended a deal at that price to shareholders. The shareholder alleges that the merger's proxy statement wrongly made the company's revenue performance look worse than it was. The disputed sentence grouped revenue with calculated billings and said both had fallen short of expectations. Her theory is that this depressed picture helped persuade shareholders to accept too little for their stock. That is an allegation, not a finding that the deal was unfair. The district court dismissed the revised complaint. Although it had treated the disputed sentence as false or misleading, it said the allegations still sounded in fraud and failed the stricter requirements for pleading the executive's responsibility. The shareholder will arg
The Second Circuit considers a plan to help homebuyers who need mortgages compete with cash offers. Canandaigua National Corporation, a New York financial holding company, wanted to guarantee purchases arranged through its mortgage subsidiary. If a preapproved customer failed to obtain final mortgage approval, the company would buy the home itself and later resell it. The proposal capped the value of homes held at any one time at five million dollars and promised resale within two years. Canandaigua says those safeguards make the risk small. The Federal Reserve Board rejected the plan on safety-and-soundness grounds, looking beyond the risk to this particular company. It did not finally decide the remaining statutory factors. Canandaigua will argue that the Board ignored the limits in its actual application. The Board will defend considering what could happen if financial holding companies generally began buying property under such guarantees. This is a dispute over permission for a pr
The Ninth Circuit hears a dispute over a proposed waste-processing project in California. Nortech already operated the Western Placer Waste Management Authority's facility. It worked with EcoHub on a proposal for the facility's future, first seeking a contract extension and then preparing for competitive bidding. The collaboration broke down. Nortech ended discussions after EcoHub failed to produce a requested financing commitment. EcoHub says the financing demand was a pretext, and that Recology pushed Nortech to abandon their joint effort. EcoHub and Nortech eventually submitted separate bids. Neither won. EcoHub nevertheless says their work together had already created a legal partnership, with duties Nortech could not simply walk away from. The district court ruled against EcoHub before trial, finding insufficient evidence of shared control. It also found EcoHub's interference claims against Recology were brought too late. EcoHub will argue that the companies' conduct and board dis
The Ninth Circuit considers how JPMorgan uses money left in its employees' retirement plan. These are unvested employer contributions: money departing workers had not yet earned the right to keep. They are not the employees' own salary contributions. The forfeited money stays inside the plan. Wright says JPMorgan used it to offset future employer contributions rather than reduce administrative fees charged to participants. His claim is that the company repeatedly saved itself money while employees continued paying fees. The district court dismissed his lawsuit before trial. It read the plan as not allowing forfeitures to cover participants' share of expenses, and rejected his claims under ERISA, the federal retirement-plan law. The argument will separate two decisions: who pays the plan's expenses, and how money already in the plan is allocated. Wright will argue that the plan's provisions work together and that the choices were subject to duties owed to participants. JPMorgan and the
The Ninth Circuit hears a water-pollution dispute involving Yellowstone Mountain Club's golf course. Cottonwood Environmental Law Center alleges that pollution from the property reaches the Gallatin River. The part at issue here concerns a pond at the fourth hole, used as a water hazard. Cottonwood investigated the property and relied on scientific testing and expert analysis to support its case. But before trial, the district judge rejected its Hole Four claim under the Clean Water Act because he concluded that claim was not pleaded in the complaint. Cottonwood now wants it sent back for trial. One complication is that an earlier request to change the complaint concerned a public-nuisance claim, distinct from the federal water-pollution claim. Cottonwood will argue that the club had fair notice and that the court's earlier discussion of expert disputes contemplated a trial. The club will argue that Cottonwood is advancing a different water-flow theory that it never properly added to t
The Second Circuit considers whether a commercial tenant lost its lease before it filed for bankruptcy. Rock Fifty-One fell behind on rent. Its landlord sent a default notice demanding payment by a deadline. The tenant paid part of the debt, but did not cure the default in full. The landlord then sent a separate notice terminating the lease. Rock Fifty-One later sought to keep the lease through bankruptcy. The bankruptcy court held that the lease had already ended, and the district court affirmed. That is why this appeal turns on a letter rather than on whether rent was owed. The tenant will argue that the first notice did not clearly warn that failing to pay could end the lease. The landlord will defend the notice's references to the lease's default provisions and available remedies. Listen for the difference between a notice demanding that a default be cured and a later notice ending the lease. Must the first letter expressly mention termination, or was its reference to the lease eno
The Ninth Circuit examines the restrictions placed on Scott Smeltzer after prison. His original federal case involved child sexual abuse material. After he began supervised release, he admitted violations that included using and possessing an unauthorized cell phone. His release was revoked, and the new judgment provided for ten years of supervision. This appeal focuses on two conditions. One requires prior approval before he can use or possess a broad range of electronic devices. The other gives his probation officer discretion over location monitoring during supervision. The dispute is about those future restrictions, not a new trial over whether he committed the admitted violations. Listen for two separate questions: what limits can be justified by his history, and how much explanation the judge must give for imposing them. Then keep the judge's role in setting conditions distinct from the probation officer's role in carrying them out. The argument will test how these restrictions f
The Ninth Circuit considers an attempt to revive a securities-fraud lawsuit. Valor Systems and another plaintiff sued TransX Systems and other defendants, but the case ended before a trial on those allegations. The immediate problem was a missing joint case-planning report. The district judge had ordered it filed before a scheduling conference. After the first deadline was missed, he moved the conference and set another deadline. The report still was not filed. In January twenty twenty-five, the judge dismissed the lawsuit for failure to prosecute and follow his orders. His written decision said the parties had neither requested more time nor explained their failures to comply. As you listen, keep two questions separate: whether dismissing the suit was justified, and whether a judgment should be reopened afterward. A request to reopen is a distinct procedural step, not simply a repetition of the original dispute. Listen closely to what information the district judge actually had when h
The Ninth Circuit considers Parker White's appeal in a child-exploitation case. The court discussion includes descriptions of abuse involving children. The investigation concerned White's online contacts with minors. Investigators found child sexual abuse material on his phone and material he had received through social media. After a federal jury trial, he was convicted of producing, receiving, and possessing that material. The district judge sentenced him to twenty-two years in prison. Those are different offenses. Keep the production conviction separate from the receipt and possession convictions as you listen. The argument turns to what the government had to prove about purpose, and what the trial evidence could establish. Listen for the distinction between evidence about a defendant's broader conduct and proof concerning a particular charged act, rather than treating every piece of evidence as answering the same question. USA v. White (No. 25-1085) — U.S. Court of Appeals for the
The Ninth Circuit considers Pedro Hernandez's lawsuit over an alleged failure to protect him from other inmates. Hernandez sued San Bernardino County and jail deputies after he was injured during a second outbreak of violence following an earlier fight. He claimed that the first disturbance and signs of racial tension warned deputies that more violence could follow, yet they failed to take protective measures. The district judge granted summary judgment for the defendants, ending the case without a jury trial. Hernandez now asks the appeals court to let his claim go forward. The county will defend the judgment it won below. Hernandez's lawyer will argue that the evidence was enough to send his failure-to-protect claim to a jury. Listen for what the record actually shows about the warnings before the second outbreak of violence. The argument will turn to the deputies' response as well as the risk of another attack. Hernandez v. County of San Bernardino, et al. (No. 25-3923) — U.S. Court
The Ninth Circuit considers Michael Ho's contract dispute with Marathon, a Bitcoin-mining company. Ho claimed that he brought Marathon an opportunity involving an energy supplier, shared commercially sensitive information under a nondisclosure agreement, and then was cut out of the deal without compensation. Marathon denied improperly using his information. A jury found for Ho on a breach-of-contract claim, and the company is challenging the judgment. The business context matters: Marathon's mining project needed a source of electricity. So this is not just a dispute about keeping a secret. It is about whether their agreement protected Ho's opportunity to earn a fee when Marathon dealt with a contact he supplied. Marathon's lawyer will argue that information the company already knew, or rightfully obtained elsewhere, was outside the agreement's restrictions. Ho's lawyer will defend protection against deliberately cutting him out. Listen also for a separate question about damages: when
The Ninth Circuit hears Siren Retail, doing business as Starbucks, versus the National Labor Relations Board. The dispute grew out of a union organizing campaign. Managers met with employees to discuss what union representation would mean. Statements about losing benefits, access to temporary assignments, and obligations to join a union or participate in a strike led to unfair labor practice charges. The Board found several statements unlawful threats, not merely protected opinions. Separately, it overruled a precedent called Tri-Cast, which concerned statements about how unionization changes employees' relationship with management. That new standard applied only to future conduct; the Board did not use it to find those relationship statements unlawful in this case. Starbucks will challenge the threat findings and argue that federal labor law and the First Amendment protect its speech. It will also argue that the prospective rule chills what it can say in future organizing campaigns. T
The Ninth Circuit considers Cottonwood versus the Big Sky Water and Sewer District, a Clean Water Act dispute over wastewater reaching a Montana river. Cottonwood alleged pollution from the district's storage ponds and irrigation at a nearby golf course. A key dispute was how much water leaked from the ponds, rather than being pumped out for irrigation elsewhere. After a jury ruled for the district, Cottonwood asked the judge to reopen the judgment. It alleged that important water-export data had been concealed in hidden Excel tabs. The judge rejected that claim, finding the data had been disclosed and was not falsified. The judge also imposed attorneys' fees and a restriction on further motions. Cottonwood's lawyer will argue that the way the spreadsheets were produced prevented a fair challenge to the data, and that the judge mishandled the later EPA investigation. The district's lawyer will defend the court's findings. There is also a separate golf-course claim involving Boyne. List
The Ninth Circuit considers Cirkunovs versus Zuffa, an arbitration dispute arising from a UFC fighter's antitrust lawsuit. Cirkunovs alleges that the companies behind the UFC restricted competition for fighters' services and kept their pay below competitive levels. He brought a proposed class action for fighters whose contracts included arbitration clauses or waivers of class-action rights. Zuffa asked the district court to enforce the arbitration agreement. Cirkunovs challenged the provisions as unfair and unenforceable. Before deciding that request, the judge allowed discovery, the exchange of information and documents. The parties dispute whether inquiries into the UFC's market power are needed to assess the contract, or improperly advance the antitrust case before arbitration is resolved. Listen for the distinction between evidence about bargaining power and objections to the contract terms themselves. Even before those questions, the judges will ask whether they have authority to
The Ninth Circuit considers Hanible versus the County of Solano, a civil lawsuit over force used against a woman in jail. After her arrest, Hanible was taken to the Solano County jail for booking. She alleges that officers beat her in a detoxification cell and again while forcibly changing her into jail clothes. The defendants dispute that unreasonable force was used. The district judge dismissed some claims but found factual disputes about the cell and changing-room incidents, and denied qualified immunity. That ruling did not decide who was liable; it let those claims continue. The officials are now challenging the denial of immunity on appeal. Their lawyer will argue that the judge failed to connect each named defendant to a particular use of force and should have granted immunity. Hanible, speaking for herself, will argue that her rights were violated and the case should go forward. Listen for two related questions: what evidence ties an individual officer to each incident, and how
The Tenth Circuit hears United States versus Adegboruwa, an appeal arising from an oxycodone-selling operation on the dark web. A federal jury convicted Adegboruwa of drug crimes, including running a continuing criminal enterprise. Prosecutors said he sold pills online and directed others to package and mail them to customers. But before that trial, he spent nearly five years in custody. Just as a trial was approaching, the government arrested a co-defendant who had been at large. The district judge refused to separate their cases and delayed trial so they could be tried together. His lawyer will argue that the government waited too long to arrest the co-defendant and that the case should be dismissed for violating his speedy-trial rights. The government will defend the delay and the joint trial. The judges will also examine what the jury had to agree on to convict him of running a continuing criminal enterprise: in particular, whether jurors had to agree on the identities of at least
The Tenth Circuit hears United States versus Salazar, a case about the choices offered to a jury in a drug trial. Police arrested Salazar outside a hotel room, and a search uncovered methamphetamine in the room. A federal jury convicted him of possessing methamphetamine with intent to distribute it. The defense asked for an additional instruction: if the jury found possession but not intent to distribute, it could convict on the lesser offense of simple possession. The judge refused, giving rise to a central issue in this appeal. Salazar's lawyer will argue that the evidence left a real question about what he intended to do with the particular drugs seized. The government will argue that the record did not provide a rational basis for the lesser offense. Listen for how the parties distinguish past drug dealing from intent to distribute this particular bag, and how they discuss the interview recording, the quantity of the drugs, and the other evidence. The question is not simply whether
The Seventh Circuit hears a challenge to a police shooting on a Chicago street. Officers encountered Michael Arquero firing a handgun into an occupied car. Within seconds, they shot and wounded him. He then sued the officers and the city over the use of force. The central dispute concerns roughly three seconds after he turned toward the police. Arquero says he dropped the gun and was surrendering before the officers fired. Parts of the encounter are hidden behind a parked car in a video that both sides rely on. The district judge ruled for the officers without a trial, concluding their response was reasonable and they were protected by qualified immunity. Arquero's lawyer will argue that testimony and the video leave a factual dispute that a jury should resolve. The defense lawyer will argue that the officers faced an immediate threat and had no clearly established legal duty to respond differently in those few seconds. Listen for the distinction between whether the gun was dropped and
The Tenth Circuit hears United States versus Butler, an appeal about how a jury was screened for bias in a sexual-assault prosecution. The prosecution arose from an accusation that Butler sexually assaulted another inmate at a federal transfer facility. A jury found him guilty. He now seeks a new trial over how that jury was selected. The defendant and the complainant were of different races. Before trial, the defense requested questions about racial prejudice, but the judge declined. A separate concern involved a prospective juror who disclosed having experienced sexual abuse. The judge refused the defense's request to remove that juror for cause. Butler's lawyer will argue that these decisions denied him an impartial jury. Listen for two questions: whether omitting racial-bias questions requires a new trial, and when a juror's own experiences require removal despite an assurance of fairness. The judges will press both sides on the difference between finding a defect in jury selection
The Ninth Circuit considers where a family's lawsuit over a death following a snorkeling outing should be heard. Frederick Harden died after snorkeling while vacationing with his wife in Mexico. His family sued Amazon in California, alleging that a mask purchased through its marketplace was defective and contributed to his death. Amazon disputes whether the mask caused the death and points to a different medical explanation. The district court dismissed the suit without prejudice under a rule called forum non conveniens. This appeal concerns California versus Mexico as the place to litigate, not a final decision about what caused Harden's death. At the heart of the forum question are witnesses and records in Mexico, including evidence about what happened on the boat and during the response afterward. The family's lawyer will argue that the case's U.S. connections and available evidence do not justify taking away their choice of a California court. Amazon's lawyer will argue that crucia
The D.C. Circuit hears a dispute about who gets room on Colorado's electric grid. Salsa Solar and another renewable-energy developer planned projects to supply CORE Electric Cooperative. To connect to the grid sooner, they sought provisional service from Public Service Company of Colorado, part of Xcel Energy. But the connection studies treated some capacity on the Colorado Power Pathway as reserved for the utility's own future power supplies. The developers complained to the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission, known as FERC. They said the reservation let lower-priority projects jump ahead of them, delaying their access to the grid. The utility said it needed that capacity to keep serving its customers while replacing coal generation under Colorado's clean-energy requirements. FERC rejected the complaint and maintained that result on rehearing. The question is when a utility must identify the particular power plants that will use reserved transmission capacity. The challengers will a
The Ninth Circuit hears a physician's challenge to the way Arizona disciplined his medical license. Charles Kelly practiced medicine in Arizona. During disciplinary proceedings, the Medical Board imposed an interim agreement setting conditions on his practice, including monitoring and record-keeping requirements. Disputes over compliance led to a suspension and, later, probation. Kelly contends that the Board and its staff discriminated against him because of race and disability; they dispute his account. Instead of obtaining state-court review of those disciplinary decisions, Kelly brought a federal civil-rights suit. The district court dismissed it under claim preclusion, also called res judicata: the principle that a matter cannot be litigated again after a binding final decision. That sets up the central disagreement. Does Arizona law bar a later suit only when it relies on the same evidence as the earlier proceeding, or more broadly when it grows out of the same underlying events?
The Sixth Circuit returns to Robert Woodall's challenge to a Kentucky death sentence. The case began with the 1997 rape and murder of a teenage girl. Woodall was sentenced to death after a jury proceeding over punishment. The questions now concern how that jury was selected, and the instructions it received. During jury selection, the prosecution removed the last Black person remaining in the pool. The defense objected. The prosecutor pointed to answers on her questionnaire, including a statement that she did not trust anyone. The trial judge noted the objection and moved on without an express finding about whether that explanation was genuine. Among its rulings, a federal district court granted relief on the jury-selection claim, but rejected a separate challenge to the penalty instructions. Both sides are appealing those parts of the decision. You will hear the state warden's lawyer first. He will argue that the trial judge implicitly rejected the race-discrimination claim, and that
The District of Columbia Circuit hears a dispute over child-support deductions from Phillip Simon's Social Security disability payments. The dispute grew out of a California child-support order. San Diego's child-support agency sent Social Security an instruction to withhold part of Simon's monthly benefit payment. Simon says the underlying support order was invalid, and he went to federal court to stop the deductions. The district judge dismissed his garnishment challenge, relying on a federal statute that protects the government when it follows an order that appears valid on its face. That means looking at the order itself, rather than investigating the whole state-court proceeding. The appeal asks how far that protection extends. The first advocate will argue that an order can look proper yet lack a valid legal foundation, and that Simon should be able to challenge that foundation in federal court. The government will argue that Social Security's protection depends on the face of th