The District of Columbia Circuit hears a dispute over the planned transfer of transgender women from women's federal facilities to men's facilities. In January 2025, a new executive order directed that people the administration classifies as male not be housed in women's prisons. The Bureau of Prisons moved to apply that policy to transgender women it had previously placed in women's facilities. The plaintiffs say the transfers would expose them to serious violence and severe psychological harm. Their suit invokes the Eighth Amendment's ban on cruel and unusual punishment. A district judge blocked their transfers. An earlier appeal required the judge to examine each plaintiff's circumstances, and the judge then issued a new preliminary injunction. The temporary orders protect the named plaintiffs during litigation, rather than finally deciding the policy's lawfulness. The government will argue that a no-exceptions rule based on biological sex is constitutionally reasonable, and that se
The D.C. Circuit hears a dispute between the Postal Service and its regulator over government contracts. During the COVID pandemic, the Postal Service worked with the Department of Health and Human Services to get test kits to households. The work included preparing test-kit packages as well as delivering them. That familiar operation exposes a less familiar question: when the Postal Service serves another federal agency, which regulatory rules apply? In an accounting proceeding, the Postal Regulatory Commission applied a framework for hybrid agreements: contracts combining postal and nonpostal services. It required separate accounting and, for certain negotiated delivery arrangements, approval before implementation. The Postal Service sought reconsideration, but the Commission refused to remove those conditions. The Postal Service will argue that Congress authorized it to supply services to federal agencies on agreed terms, without this extra approval step. It will also challenge how
The Second Circuit hears an investor lawsuit against Coupang, the South Korean online retailer. New York City pension funds say the company misled investors about how it ran its business around its 2021 public offering and afterward. One disputed practice is easy to picture: a shopper searches for a product, and Coupang's own-brand goods rise to the top. The funds allege Coupang used its search system and coordinated positive employee reviews to favor those products, while presenting its marketplace as fair and customer-driven. Other allegations involve worker safety and pressure on suppliers. The trial judge dismissed the complaint, finding the challenged statements were not materially misleading. He also refused another amendment, saying the investors had not explained how they would fix the defects. That left the suit dismissed with prejudice. The funds will ask for another chance, pointing to later Korean regulatory materials they submitted before dismissal. Coupang will argue that
The Eleventh Circuit hears Vazquez's appeal over the removal of his chosen defense lawyer. The prosecution began with allegations of cocaine sent by mail from Puerto Rico to Florida, and money laundering. The defense team obtained affidavits from two witnesses. One affidavit was used to challenge government evidence. Prosecutors alleged that Vazquez had arranged for false statements and added obstruction-related charges. Before trial, the government also asked to remove his lawyer, arguing that his involvement with the affidavits could place his own interests in tension with his client's. The trial judge removed him. The Sixth Amendment protects a defendant's choice of lawyer, but that right is not absolute. A serious potential conflict can justify a judge's intervention, even without a proven actual conflict. Vazquez's lawyer will argue that the removal went too far. The government will defend the judge's conflict assessment. Listen for whether the concern here was a serious conflict,
The Ninth Circuit hears Blackwell's appeal over a wrongful-death lawsuit and her bankruptcy discharge. In twenty twenty, her car struck the back of a stopped vehicle in Washington, pushing it into oncoming traffic. A passenger died. His mother later sued Blackwell, another driver, and Washington state. But Blackwell had obtained a bankruptcy discharge, protecting her from personal collection on the discharged debt. The mother wants to continue the suit to reach insurance and to establish possible liability of the other defendants. A bankruptcy judge barred the litigation against Blackwell, but an intermediate bankruptcy appeals panel reversed. Keeping Blackwell in the case matters to the estate's theory of joint and several liability. Under that theory, other defendants could have to pay damages attributable to Blackwell. Whether the lawsuit can proceed without violating her discharge is the dispute you will hear. Blackwell's lawyer will argue that entering a money judgment against her
The Ninth Circuit hears the consolidated criminal appeals of Zachary Holt and a co-defendant. The case grew out of a series of robberies and shootings in Idaho and eastern Washington. During an attempted robbery on the Colville Reservation in twenty twenty-two, two people were killed. Holt later shot at pursuing police. A jury convicted him and his co-defendant of multiple crimes; both received life sentences. The main legal question you will hear concerns a voluntary-intoxication instruction: whether jurors should have been told how alcohol or drug use could bear on the intent required for particular charges. Intoxication is not a blanket excuse for crime. In a specific-intent prosecution, though, evidence of intoxication may bear on whether the government has proved the necessary state of mind. Listen for the difference between evidence that someone consumed drugs or alcohol and evidence relevant to their ability to form that intent. A separate dispute concerns a robbery committed in
The Seventh Circuit hears Erika Cox's appeal over the termination of her Social Security disability benefits. A judge approved her claim in twenty twenty. Her medical history included recurring joint problems and other impairments. After a continuing disability review, the agency found medical improvement and concluded that she could perform a restricted range of sedentary work. It ended her benefits. A federal district judge upheld that decision. This is not a first application. In reviewing an existing award on medical-improvement grounds, the agency must compare the person's current condition with the condition underlying the last favorable disability decision. The question is whether there has been improvement related to the ability to work. You will also hear residual functional capacity, or RFC. That means the most someone can still do in a work setting despite their limitations. Cox's lawyer will argue that the agency's work-capacity assessment lacks an adequate medical foundati
The Ninth Circuit hears a challenge by seven former Shriners Hospital employees to the loss of their jobs. They worked at the hospital's Northern California location. When they did not get COVID vaccinations, their employment was terminated. They sued, but the hospital won summary judgment. The employees are appealing that ruling. Summary judgment means the judge resolves the case without a trial because no genuine dispute over an important fact prevents judgment as a matter of law. It does not let the judge simply choose which side's witnesses to believe. You will hear the term undue hardship. In workplace religious-accommodation law, that means a substantial burden in the overall context of the employer's particular business, not just a minor inconvenience. Keep the evidence questions separate from the safety arguments. Which expert opinions may the court consider? And does the admissible evidence leave a real factual dispute for a trial? Listen for how the judges connect those quest
The Ninth Circuit hears the government's appeal over ICE arrests at people's homes. In the Los Angeles area, officers used visits called knock and talks to reach residents at home. Some residents were asked to step outside and were immediately arrested. Officers typically lacked a judge-issued warrant, often carrying an arrest warrant issued by immigration officials instead. Two immigrant-rights organizations challenged this practice in a class action. A federal judge ruled in twenty twenty-four that entering protected home property to make these arrests, without a judicial warrant, valid consent, or another legal basis, violated the Fourth Amendment and immigration regulations. The judge set aside the policy in the Los Angeles enforcement area. Curtilage means the area immediately surrounding a home, such as a porch or enclosed yard. The dispute is whether the ordinary visitor's permission to approach a front door extends to a planned arrest. The government will argue that these conta
The Tenth Circuit hears a sentencing appeal. At federal sentencing, the district court treated the defendant's earlier Illinois conviction for aggravated battery as a crime of violence under the Sentencing Guidelines. That classification matters because qualifying prior convictions can raise the recommended sentencing range. This appeal is not a new trial about what happened during that earlier offense. The dispute concerns the legal reach of the Illinois offense, including its rules for holding one person responsible for another person's conduct. His lawyer will argue that Illinois's common-design rule reaches too broadly to fit the federal definition of a violent crime. The government will defend the classification and dispute that claimed mismatch. There is another obstacle: he did not raise this objection at sentencing. Under plain-error review, showing that a ruling was wrong is not enough; the claimed error must also be clear or obvious. Listen for how the judges distinguish a pe
The Seventh Circuit hears United States versus Clyde. Clyde was serving a sentence for an earlier murder when he stabbed his cellmate to death at the federal prison in Thomson, Illinois, in November twenty twenty. He pleaded guilty to second-degree murder, and the sentencing judge imposed life in prison. Second-degree murder permits a term of years or life; it does not automatically require life. This appeal concerns the punishment, not a retrial of the admitted killing. His lawyer will argue that the judge did not adequately address mental-health treatment and prison conditions as reasons for a lesser sentence. He will also contend that life was excessive. The government will argue that the judge addressed those issues and reasonably concluded that protecting others required permanent imprisonment, given Clyde's earlier murder and continuing violence. Listen for two questions: whether the judge properly considered the sentencing arguments and explained the decision, and whether the li
The Seventh Circuit hears Malcorvian versus County of Cook. Raven Malcorvian was offered a forensic technician job at the Cook County Medical Examiner's Office in twenty nineteen. During onboarding, she disclosed a condition that severely limits her exposure to natural light. She requested measures such as covered windows or a windowless workspace. The county proposed protective clothing instead, but she said she could not safely wear it for long periods. The offer was withdrawn, and she sued under the Americans with Disabilities Act. The law protects applicants who can perform a job's essential functions, with or without reasonable accommodation. Here, the dispute is whether the work could be adjusted to let her perform those functions. Her lawyer will argue that her experience, changes to the workspace, and modified schedules could allow her to do the job, and that the county ended the accommodation discussions too soon. The county will argue that outdoor duties, including work at ma
The Court of Appeals for the Armed Forces hears United States versus Lawrence. Airman First Class Lawrence was selected for a random urine test in January twenty twenty-four. It detected a marijuana breakdown product at twenty-two nanograms per milliliter, against a military reporting cutoff of fifteen. He demanded a court-martial instead of accepting nonjudicial punishment. A military judge convicted him of wrongful marijuana use, reduced his rank, and ordered a reprimand. The Air Force appeals court affirmed. The question here is not simply whether marijuana entered his body, but whether the evidence proves he knew it. A permissive inference allows the factfinder to infer knowledge from the drug-test evidence; it is not an automatic conviction. The government still must prove knowing, wrongful use beyond a reasonable doubt. Lawrence's lawyer will argue that the expert could not discount unknowing ingestion, and that changes in marijuana's availability undermine the inference itself.
The Ninth Circuit hears Sundaram versus Freshworks. Freshworks offered shares to the public at thirty-six dollars. Sundaram bought in the market afterward for forty-six dollars, and eventually sold for about fifteen. His lawsuit alleges defects in the company's offering disclosures. When earnings information became public, the stock fell sharply but stayed above the thirty-six-dollar offering price. It dropped below that price only later. The trial judge ruled for Freshworks, finding that the later, below-offering-price losses were not caused by the alleged omissions. This appeal focuses on how the Securities Act's damages formula fits with that causation defense. Sundaram's lawyer will argue that the formula limits the amount recoverable, without excluding an earlier, disclosure-related decline merely because it occurred above the offering price. Freshworks will argue that the formula defines which loss can be recovered, and that the company proved no recoverable loss was caused by th
The Tenth Circuit hears United States versus Smith. Smith was convicted of voluntary manslaughter after a man died from injuries sustained in a fight. Another participant, Gilbert, pleaded guilty before Smith's trial, admitting that she aided him in causing the death. Smith wanted the jury to hear her account of the fight, but the judge kept that part of her plea hearing out. This appeal asks whether that exclusion wrongly prevented Smith from presenting his defense. The lawyers will discuss statements against interest: a hearsay exception that can admit statements genuinely exposing their speaker to criminal liability. It requires an unavailable witness and corroborating circumstances clearly indicating the statement's trustworthiness. A guilty plea does not automatically make every part of the person's story admissible. A key question is whether the particular passage actually incriminated Gilbert or instead described justified conduct. Her having pleaded guilty does not automaticall
The Tenth Circuit hears United States versus Bray. Bray pleaded guilty to possessing a handgun after a felony conviction. But the day before his arrest, deputies had found other firearms in an unoccupied truck. Those additional weapons were counted when his sentence was calculated. The argument you will hear focuses on that sentencing decision: was there enough evidence connecting Bray to the guns in the truck? A central term is constructive possession. It means that a person who does not physically hold an object knowingly has both the power and the intent to control it. His lawyer will argue that the evidence did not sufficiently connect him to those additional weapons. The government will ask the court to uphold the sentencing judge's conclusion that he possessed them. Listen for the distinction between evidence connecting someone to a truck and evidence connecting that person to the guns inside it. The judges will also examine whether any error would require a new sentencing hearin
The Ninth Circuit hears Fujishige versus Amazon. Amy Fujishige worked with tall storage shelves in an Amazon warehouse. She says safety rules required a ladder or assistance when items were out of reach. But those extra steps took time, while workers were scored on items processed per hour and time off task. She argues that this combination put women at a disadvantage and exposed them to discipline for low productivity. Her theory is disparate impact: the effects of an apparently neutral policy, not proof that Amazon deliberately targeted women. The appeal is at the pleading stage, not a trial deciding whether discrimination actually occurred. The question is whether her complaint contains enough facts to move forward. Her lawyer will argue that the ladder rule and the connection between reach and time make the claim plausible, even without Amazon's internal data. Amazon will argue that she has not identified a sufficiently specific practice or facts connecting it to a significant diff
The Tenth Circuit hears Neal versus Neal, a family dispute over a home in Aspen. Cynthia Neal says she and her brothers contributed family trust money toward a house they were supposed to own together. Instead, Jeffrey took control of the property, and she says she lost the benefit of her contribution. This was part of a wider fight over the family's real estate and trusts. A Virginia court paused the Aspen-related claims because the Colorado lawsuit was already underway. Cynthia is now seeking a new trial in Colorado. A central question is whether Jeffrey had duties as a trustee even though the planned trust never received the house. Cynthia will argue that obligations arose when the family entrusted him with the arrangement, and did not simply disappear when the ownership plan changed. Jeffrey will argue that the trust never came into effect and therefore could not impose those duties on him. The judges will also examine how much of the Virginia family dispute could be put before the
The Ninth Circuit hears a consumer class action against Sazerac over Fireball. The buyers say the small bottles of Fireball Malt looked so much like Fireball Whisky that they thought they were buying whisky, rather than a lower-alcohol malt beverage. Their claim is that the packaging misled them into paying more than the product was worth. The district court certified a class, allowing buyers to pursue their claims together. Sazerac now challenges that decision, focusing on how the consumers propose to estimate their losses. You will hear about conjoint analysis: a survey that asks people to choose among products with different features and prices, to measure what they value. The difficult question is how those preferences translate into a market price, where sellers as well as buyers affect what a product costs. Sazerac will argue that the proposed model does not reliably account for how sellers would respond if buyers knew exactly what the drink contained. The consumers will counter
The Ninth Circuit hears Melton versus the County of Maricopa. Kayla Melton's husband was shot and killed by sheriff's deputies. She brought a civil-rights lawsuit alleging that the county failed to train its deputies to de-escalate a suicidal crisis, and that this failure deprived her family of their relationship with him. The appeal concerns the county's own training responsibilities, not an individual damages claim against each deputy. You will hear the term Monell. It means the county is not liable merely because it employs an officer who violates someone's rights. The injury must be connected to the county's own policy or custom. A failure to train can qualify, but it must amount to deliberate indifference, not just negligence, and must actually cause the constitutional harm. The family will rely on the narrow possibility of proving an obvious training need without a pattern of earlier incidents. Listen for the difference between evidence of inadequate training and disagreement abo
The Eleventh Circuit hears United States versus Lewis Scott. The case grew out of a car stop in Florida. Deputies found suspected drugs, a digital scale, and a handgun. Scott faced drug and firearm charges, including possession of a gun in furtherance of drug trafficking. After a guilty plea and a trial, the appeal focuses on that connection: not simply whether a gun was present, but what role it played in the drug offense. Listen for the distinction between an expert describing common drug-trafficking practices and an expert supplying a conclusion about the defendant’s own state of mind. The lawyers will debate Diaz, a Supreme Court decision that allowed testimony about what most drug couriers know. The Court reasoned that the jury still had to decide what that particular defendant knew. Pay attention to the words most, all, and always, and to the full context of the testimony, rather than treating any one word as an automatic answer. The judges will also consider whether the objectio
The Ninth Circuit hears Campbell’s employment-discrimination appeal. Campbell spent decades as an IRS lawyer. After a new supervisor arrived, disputes developed over her work, scheduling flexibility, and how closely her correspondence was reviewed. She also sought changes to accommodate a disability that made typing difficult. The parties discussed work hours, reviewing documents on paper, and voice-recognition software. Campbell says she faced discrimination based on age and disability, and retaliation for complaining. She retired in 2020, but says conditions effectively forced her out. The Treasury Department describes a performance-management dispute, not unlawful bias, and says it worked with her to find reasonable accommodations. The district court rejected some claims as late, then entered summary judgment on the remaining claims, finding insufficient evidence to send them to trial. Campbell’s lawyer will urge the panel to view the workplace changes and comparisons with other law
The Ninth Circuit hears King versus Cavic Aviation Leasing. Zetta Jet arranged to acquire an aircraft from Bombardier. Cavic paid a thirty-million-dollar advance to the manufacturer, using money Cavic borrowed from another lender. Zetta’s purchase rights had been assigned to Cavic. But Zetta went bankrupt before the aircraft was delivered, and the transaction left a thirty-million-dollar refund in dispute. Jonathan King, the bankruptcy trustee, sued to recover that money for Zetta’s estate. His theory is that the assignment was collateral for financing, not a genuine sale of the purchase rights. He says Cavic did not properly protect that security interest against other creditors, leaving the refund available to the estate. Cavic disputes that starting point. Its lawyer will argue that Cavic became the buyer, paid the money itself, and never made the supposed loan to Zetta. She will also point to a contract directing any refund to the lender that financed Cavic. The bankruptcy court di
The Tenth Circuit hears Payment Brokers Group versus Agentra. The dispute arose from a bargain over payment-processing fees. The companies would receive a discounted rate. In return, they promised to keep a specified share of their payment volume in the arrangement for three years. They received the lower rate, but later stopped using that processor. Payment Brokers Group sued for breach of contract. After a trial without a jury, the judge found in its favor and awarded damages for lost profits. The companies will argue that the wrong business was credited with performance: a separate processor, not Payment Brokers Group, actually handled the services. Payment Brokers Group will argue that it secured and delivered the promised discount, so the companies received what they bargained for. There is also a damages dispute. The judges will examine which businesses’ transactions belong in the calculation, how processing costs affect lost profits, and how the award should be divided among the