The Ninth Circuit hears Longworth versus Trump. The dispute began with protests outside the federal building in Eugene, Oregon. Longworth and Lardner used megaphones on public sidewalks. One protester received a federal citation, and the plaintiffs describe warnings that continued noise could lead to arrest. The government says the amplified protests disrupted people working inside. They sued over a federal rule against loud or unusual noise that can apply beyond federal property. The district judge temporarily blocked enforcement on the sidewalks surrounding this building, concluding the plaintiffs were likely to succeed on their argument that the rule was unconstitutionally vague. That was preliminary protection, not a final judgment invalidating the rule everywhere. The government is appealing. Its lawyer will argue that the rule can be read to target interference with government operations. The protesters’ lawyer will argue that people on a public sidewalk cannot know where lawful
The Tenth Circuit hears United States versus Vaughn. The case grows out of a traffic stop involving Vaughn as the driver. During the stop, officers checked the passengers’ criminal histories and frisked Vaughn. The justification for searching him depended in part on concern that a passenger might be armed and dangerous. Those are different people, and that distinction is central to this appeal. Vaughn challenges both actions. He says the passenger-record checks improperly extended the stop, and that suspicion about a passenger did not justify a patdown of the driver. His lawyer will ask the judges to keep those questions separate. The government will defend the officers’ safety-related actions. A traffic stop does not give police unlimited time for unrelated investigation. At the same time, officers can take precautions tied to safely completing the stop. A weapons frisk has its own requirement: reasonable suspicion that the person being frisked is armed and dangerous. As you listen, a
The Second Circuit hears Richards versus Mount Sinai South Nassau. Richards, representing himself, is challenging the dismissal of an employment lawsuit against the hospital. He lost his job after workplace disputes that the hospital describes as performance problems. Richards disputes that account and says he faced discrimination and retaliation for complaining to management. Before this appeal, the district judge gave him an opportunity to explain how his allegations supported federal discrimination claims. She ultimately dismissed those claims, finding no adequate factual connection to a protected characteristic or protected activity. She declined to decide the remaining state-law claims. That procedural setting matters. The appellate court is reviewing the dismissal of a lawsuit, not conducting a trial about who was right in every workplace disagreement. Listen for whether the alleged facts support a plausible inference of discrimination, rather than treating the hospital’s explana
The Ninth Circuit hears Valencia Project versus the Commissioner of Internal Revenue. The dispute grew out of an IRS examination of Discovery Gateway Spectrum’s partnership tax returns. Ownership changes and later tax filings led to disagreement about which entity could represent the partnership. During the examination, John Wilson signed five agreements giving the IRS more time to make tax adjustments. He signed for Hyannis Port Capital, but also managed Valencia Project. An earlier Tax Court order upheld his apparent authority to extend the deadline for one of the disputed periods. Valencia now challenges the extensions as unauthorized. It says that without a valid extension, the IRS acted too late. Tax matters partner is a representative role under the older partnership audit rules involved here. Listen for the difference between powers Wilson actually had and authority the IRS could reasonably believe he had. Valencia’s lawyer will argue that signing for the wrong entity is not jus
The Tenth Circuit hears United States versus Shafe. A federal jury convicted Shafe of second-degree murder after she fatally shot her husband at home. The dispute in this recording concerns how the jury decided her criminal state of mind, rather than a claim that someone else fired the shot. Causing a death does not by itself settle whether a killing is murder, manslaughter, or legally justified. That makes the evidence used to assess intent important. The evidence rules distinguish a proper use of earlier acts, such as showing motive or intent, from the forbidden inference that a person has a bad character and therefore acted that way again. Listen for that distinction as the lawyers discuss the couple’s earlier text exchanges. Other questions concern technical opinions and differing accounts of what a witness said. Listen also for whether a mistake in admitting evidence, if there was one, could have changed the verdict. United States v. Shafe (No. 25-3177) — U.S. Court of Appeals for
The Eleventh Circuit hears United States versus Oyando and other defendants convicted in a cocaine-smuggling case. The Coast Guard intercepted a vessel carrying seven men and seven hundred sixty kilograms of cocaine as bales were being thrown overboard. Some defendants said they had been tricked into what they thought was a fishing trip. A man who had pleaded guilty testified for the defense that he had misled his companions because his family had been kidnapped. Prosecutors disputed his story, pointing to cellphone and navigation evidence. The jury also heard evidence about an alleged plan for one participant to plead guilty and falsely clear the others. A limiting instruction tells jurors which uses of evidence are allowed and which are not. Here, listen for the distinction between explaining an investigator’s decisions and treating a reported plan as proof that the defendants were lying. Listen also for whether the prosecutor’s closing argument stayed within those limits, and whethe
The Tenth Circuit hears United States versus Harper, a dispute about a memory expert excluded from a criminal trial. A woman assaulted in her Tulsa home identified Harper, a man she had hired for odd jobs and known for about a year. Harper denied attacking her. His account was that he arrived afterward and found her already injured and bound. The defense wanted a psychologist to explain its theory that seeing Harper after the attack could have become mixed into her memory of who attacked her. That is the defense’s theory, not a finding that her identification was mistaken. Harper’s first convictions were reversed because of a separate evidence error. A new jury convicted him again, after the trial judge again excluded the memory expert. The expert’s qualifications were not disputed. The judge found that the defense had not adequately connected the research to this case, where the witness knew Harper, and that the proposed testimony would not help the jury. Harper’s lawyer will argue th
The Second Circuit considers an appeal by Nagi involving supervised release. Nagi had already received seventeen and a half years in prison in a separate case involving a violent assault. That long sentence is important context for the debate over additional imprisonment when supervision breaks down. Supervised release is a period of court supervision after prison. Its conditions include not committing another crime, and a violation can lead to a separate prison term. But what may that additional time be for: preventing future wrongdoing, or paying back a breach of the court’s trust? The Supreme Court’s decision in Esteras versus United States limits retribution for the original crime that led to supervision. It expressly leaves open a different question: punishment for violating supervision’s conditions. Listen for that distinction, and for the difference between a judge discussing the law and explaining the actual sentence. Imprisonment can serve preventive purposes too. The dispute
A soccer club’s statement about a hand gesture becomes a defamation case. Reade Whitney was an athletic trainer for D.C. United. A photograph posted online showed him making a hand gesture that some viewers associated with white power. Whitney says he was playing the Circle Game, not expressing racism. The club fired him and issued a statement describing the gesture as discriminatory. He sued, claiming that statement falsely damaged his reputation. The district court dismissed his complaint, treating the disputed statement as protected opinion rather than a provably false factual assertion. Whitney now asks the D.C. Circuit to let his case proceed. This appeal is not a trial over whether he is racist, nor a ruling on whether the club made a fair employment decision. The question is whether the challenged words can support a defamation claim. A statement may be hurtful without being legally actionable. But calling something an opinion does not automatically protect it if it implies prov
The Tenth Circuit examines how an unlawful police search affects a drug-and-gun prosecution. Officers contacted a woman in a hotel room during an investigation. The encounter led to searches and Johnson’s arrest. Fentanyl was found on him, and firearms were later recovered from a storage unit. Johnson sought to exclude evidence from his case. The district court found that a protective sweep violated the Fourth Amendment, but still refused to suppress the evidence. That distinction drives this appeal. An unlawful search does not automatically invalidate everything police discover afterward. Under the independent-source doctrine, later evidence can remain usable if it was obtained independently of the unlawful entry. That requires more than simply getting a warrant afterward. Listen for two questions: would officers have sought the warrant without the unlawful sweep, and would the remaining lawful information have justified issuing it? Johnson’s lawyer will ask the court to exclude the e
The Seventh Circuit examines the prison sentence in a federal gun case. The defendant had a domestic-battery conviction that prohibited him from possessing a firearm. He was convicted of unlawful possession and sentenced to thirty-three months in prison. The appeal focuses on the punishment imposed. It helps to keep two questions separate: whether the judge adequately explained the sentence, and whether the sentence itself is unreasonable. The first concerns the sentencing process; the second concerns the resulting punishment. The federal sentencing guidelines are advisory, but the judge must consider the individual case and explain the chosen term. A sentence outside the guideline range is not automatically invalid. And appellate review is not simply a chance for the appeals court to substitute the prison term it would prefer. Listen for whether counsel is challenging the explanation, the length of the sentence, or both, and how those arguments connect to what the sentencing judge act
The Ninth Circuit considers whether an old federal gun conviction should be set aside after later decisions changed how state convictions qualify under federal gun law. The earlier federal conviction rested on three Washington state convictions. Years later, a new federal gun prosecution relied on that older federal judgment. The defendant asked the original trial court to undo the old conviction through a petition called coram nobis. The district court denied that request because he had waited too long. His lawyer will argue that the delay resulted from mistaken legal advice, and that the state convictions no longer provide the necessary foundation for the older federal case. The government will ask the court to leave the judgment intact, disputing the excuse for delay and emphasizing the legal effect of a conviction that has not been vacated. That distinction matters: questioning the basis of an old conviction is not the same as having a court actually set it aside. Listen for when t
The Tenth Circuit considers whether a health plan’s staffing requirement creates an unlawful barrier to mental health coverage. A young beneficiary received residential mental health treatment at two centers, one in New Hampshire and one in Utah. Blue Cross Blue Shield of Illinois, the plan’s claims administrator, denied payment because the centers did not provide around-the-clock onsite nursing. The family challenged those denials internally, then sued to recover benefits and to challenge unequal treatment under the Mental Health Parity Act. The district court ruled for Blue Cross and the employer’s benefit plan. The appeal asks whether the nursing requirement is comparable to the conditions imposed on analogous medical and surgical care, including skilled nursing and inpatient rehabilitation. The family’s lawyer will argue that licensing rules and accepted mental health standards allow other professional staffing arrangements, so this added nursing requirement unfairly restricts cove
The Tenth Circuit considers when involving a romantic partner in drug activity can justify an additional sentencing increase. Latrell Crawford pleaded guilty to distributing methamphetamine in eastern Oklahoma. The sentencing dispute centers on his girlfriend, Kaleigh Ervin, whose home was used for drug activity. The record described drug storage and sales there, and her assistance with money for a drug purchase. The district judge added two offense levels based on Crawford’s use of affection to involve her, and Crawford challenges that increase. This is a dispute about his sentence, not a retrial of the drug charge. For a defendant already receiving an aggravating-role adjustment, the guideline provision at issue addresses using friendship or affection to involve someone who receives little or no compensation and has minimal knowledge of the operation’s scope and structure. Crawford’s lawyer will argue that there must be evidence he actively leveraged the relationship, not simply aske
The Eleventh Circuit considers a civil-rights suit arising from a police encounter that ended in a fatal shooting. On December twenty-ninth, twenty twenty-two, Edward Townsend was visiting his mother in Florida. According to the family’s complaint, he called nine-one-one for help recovering his car keys after a dispute with relatives. Deputy David Burgess tried to handcuff him, and another deputy, Ashlyn Whelchel, joined the encounter. What followed included physical force, a Taser, and gunfire. The family says Townsend posed no deadly threat; the deputies describe resistance and a struggle over a Taser. His estate sued, challenging not just the shooting, but the initial detention and earlier uses of force. The deputies now appeal the district court’s refusal to grant them qualified immunity, a protection that turns on both constitutional rights and whether the law was clearly established. Their lawyer will argue that reported threats involving a gun justified the detention, and that t
The Tenth Circuit asks whether an Oklahoma prisoner received fair notice of the crime he needed to defend against. Prosecutors alleged that Brent Morris repeatedly struck a woman in the head with a frying pan, causing serious injuries. Morris disputes that he was the assailant. The written charge called the offense assault and battery with intent to kill. But at the end of trial, the jury was instructed on assault using force likely to produce death, without requiring proof that Morris specifically intended to kill. The jury convicted him of that offense. The state appeals court upheld the conviction, and a federal judge later denied his petition for habeas corpus, the process for challenging unlawful custody. This appeal focuses on the notice issue, not a new trial about who committed the attack. Morris’s lawyer will argue that the charge and the way the case was tried told the defense to contest intent to kill, and that the theory changed too late for a fair defense. The state’s lawy
The D.C. Circuit considers whether the President can remove members of the National Credit Union Administration’s board at will. The agency supervises credit unions, insures their members’ accounts, and provides emergency liquidity. In April 2025, President Trump removed two board members, Todd Harper and Tanya Otsuka, before their appointed terms had ended. They sued to return to office. The district court held that the law protected them from removal without cause and ordered agency officials to let them carry out their duties. The government challenges that ruling. The unusual feature is that the statute does not expressly say board members may be removed only for cause. But in 1978, Congress replaced a single administrator with a multimember board and deleted language saying the leadership served at the President’s pleasure. The members say those changes were meant to protect the agency’s independence; the government says they do not override the President’s removal authority. The
The Tenth Circuit asks when a judge’s spoken ruling ends a case—and starts the clock for an appeal. The dispute began with a settlement involving property interests and scheduled payments. Mark Beesley sought the last three hundred seventy-seven thousand dollars, which had not been paid. Brinton and the other defendants said Beesley had failed to perform his own obligations first, so they did not owe that final payment. After years of litigation, Judge Jenkins announced a ruling for Beesley at a pretrial conference in June 2023. But he died before entering a separate written judgment. A successor judge invited more briefing on whether Beesley should win without a trial. A later judge concluded that the old oral ruling had already ended the dispute and declined to revisit the contract arguments. That procedural sequence is the focus of this appeal. Brinton’s lawyer will argue that unresolved issues and substantial later proceedings show the original ruling was not final, and that the ca
The Tenth Circuit considers a police officer’s immunity after an injured counterprotester was arrested for taking part in a fight. Townley attended a protest in August 2020 and was injured when fighting broke out. When police arrived, Townley had visible facial injuries, and a bystander told Sergeant Brian Mallory that Townley had been fighting. Mallory ordered an arrest for disorderly conduct. Townley says the injuries came from being attacked, not from joining the fight, and later sued over the arrest and prosecution. The district court dismissed several claims but allowed Townley’s false-arrest and malicious-prosecution claims against Mallory to continue. It found factual disputes about what the officer could infer from the injuries and witness accounts, and whether further investigation was practical. Mallory appeals the refusal to grant qualified immunity. His lawyer will argue that the visible injuries and witness statement gave a reasonable officer enough grounds to make the arr
The Ninth Circuit hears a dispute over a prison blanket, an alleged injury, and whether correctional officers can be sued for their response. Nevada prisoner Russell says he covered his cell window while using the toilet. According to his complaint, officers reached through the food slot and grabbed the covering as he was taking it down. He says they pulled harder during the struggle, causing him to fall and injuring his hands and an already injured knee. He also alleges this was retaliation for filing grievances against prison officers. The officers say they needed to see inside the cell for security and that Russell resisted removal of the covering. The district court refused to dismiss his excessive-force and retaliation claims on qualified-immunity grounds. The officers now appeal, arguing that prior cases did not clearly establish that their conduct was unconstitutional in these circumstances. Their lawyer will argue that the complaint describes a legitimate effort to restore visi
The Sixth Circuit hears a sheriff’s lieutenant’s claim that an internal investigation punished him for reporting perceived favoritism. In November 2022, a deputy who was Sheriff Mat King’s brother was arrested for drunk driving. Lieutenant Scott Jones directed that he be taken to a neighboring county’s jail, citing a conflict of interest. The sheriff arranged for his brother to be brought back to Saint Clair County. Details of the arrest appeared on Facebook, and Jones complained to county human resources about the sheriff’s handling of his brother’s case. The sheriff ordered an investigation into the leaks; Jones later retired under an agreement rather than continue through the investigation. Jones sued, alleging that the investigation retaliated against him for speaking to human resources. The district court found his retirement voluntary, rejecting his forced-resignation theory, but allowed the retaliation claim about the investigation to proceed. The sheriff appeals, seeking qualif
The Tenth Circuit considers an Oklahoma City police officer’s role in a man’s death during a medical emergency. In September 2019, an emergency call brought paramedics to help Charles Vanlandingham. Firefighters were already trying to restrain him when Officer Brandon Lee arrived to assist. Lee handcuffed him, then placed his shin across his back while others held him face down. Paramedics administered a sedative; Vanlandingham became unresponsive and died at the scene. His estate sued, claiming the continued force was unlawful after he was already restrained. The district judge allowed excessive-force and conspiracy claims to proceed, and Lee appealed. Lee seeks qualified immunity, which can protect officers against personal liability when their conduct did not violate clearly established law. The dispute centers on continued pressure during the restraint, not the initial use of handcuffs. Lee’s lawyer will argue that he reasonably relied on trained medical personnel who were treating
The Tenth Circuit hears a forced-labor conspiracy appeal involving the United Nation of Islam. The religious organization operated businesses and a school in Kansas City, Kansas, with other locations around the country. Trial testimony described children working without pay in restaurants, businesses, and members’ homes, while threats and beatings enforced obedience. Hadley ran the organization’s biodiesel laboratory and served as a disciplinarian. Prosecutors said his supervision and punishments helped obtain unpaid labor; his defense disputes that he agreed to use coercion for that purpose. A jury convicted him of conspiracy but acquitted him of the separate forced-labor charges. The district court rejected his request for acquittal or a new trial. Hadley challenges an instruction allowing jurors to consider a climate of fear that caused people to work against their will. This argument focuses on his individual case: if that instruction was wrong, did the mistake affect his convictio
The D.C. Circuit considers whether the President could remove members of a federal privacy watchdog without showing cause. The Privacy and Civil Liberties Oversight Board reviews counterterrorism programs and advises Congress and the executive branch about their effects on privacy and civil liberties. Two members refused White House requests to resign and were told that their positions had been terminated in January 2025. They sued, and a federal judge held the removals unlawful and ordered officials other than the President to treat them as still serving. The government appealed. The case turns on a 2007 rewrite of the Board’s statute. Congress made it a separate independent agency and deleted language saying members served at the President’s pleasure, but did not add an express for-cause removal clause. The government’s lawyer will argue that this silence leaves the President free to remove members, and that the Board’s advisory role is still an executive function. The former members