The Ninth Circuit considers whether a Medicare supplier had a fair chance to challenge an audit that produced a repayment demand exceeding a million dollars. Ashli Healthcare supplies medical equipment to Medicare patients. A contractor reviewed a sample of ninety claims, found overpayments, and projected those findings across a larger group of claims. Ashli successfully challenged some payment denials during administrative appeals, reducing the demand. But it sued the health secretary, saying it still lacked the information needed to check the audit and the government’s recovery of the money. The district court ruled for the government, and Ashli appealed. Both sides agree Ashli received the list of claims remaining after certain claims were filtered out. The dispute concerns the earlier data showing what was excluded, support for later recalculations, and an accounting of repayments and interest. Ashli’s lawyer will argue that without these materials, the company cannot reproduce the
The Tenth Circuit considers a student employee’s firing after a news interview about university housing. Anthony Alvarez was both a University of Kansas student and a residence-hall proctor, a position similar to a resident assistant. He criticized planned housing changes that he said would harm LGBTQ residents. After the interview, the university fired him. A staff policy directed media inquiries to supervisors. He sued a housing official for First Amendment retaliation. A federal judge allowed that claim to proceed and denied the official qualified immunity; she appealed. That early ruling is not a final finding that the firing was unlawful. Qualified immunity can shield officials from personal money-damages claims unless their conduct violated clearly established law. Her lawyer will argue that the referral policy defined part of Alvarez’s job, and that no sufficiently similar precedent clearly barred the firing. Alvarez’s lawyer will argue that he spoke as a private citizen, and th
The Ninth Circuit hears xAI’s challenge to California’s training-data disclosure law. Assembly Bill 2013 requires developers of generative AI systems available to Californians to post high-level summaries of the datasets used to train them. Those summaries cover such matters as where the data came from, whether it includes copyrighted material or personal information, and how it was processed. xAI sued and published a limited disclosure, but says fuller compliance would reveal valuable secrets about its data selection and preparation. It asked a federal judge to stop California from enforcing the law against it. The judge refused that preliminary injunction because the early record did not show that xAI was likely to win its constitutional claims. This appeal concerns that early refusal, not a final trial judgment or an appeal from an enforcement penalty. The company’s lawyer will argue that consumer curiosity cannot justify forcing out sensitive information, and that the disclosure ru
The Eleventh Circuit hears Janet Morris’s challenge to prerecorded calls from Lincare, a medical-equipment supplier. Morris had bought supplies for a prescribed breathing device from American HomePatient and agreed to receive calls by that company or on its behalf. After the companies became affiliated, Lincare took over responsibility for her supplies and later left recorded messages asking her to call about them. She sued on behalf of a class under the federal robocall law, saying her permission to American HomePatient did not authorize Lincare’s calls. The trial court entered judgment for Lincare on the federal claim, concluding that the calls were health-care messages and covered by her existing consent. The appeal focuses on the meaning of acting on behalf of another company. Morris’s lawyer will argue that sharing a corporate parent does not make one company the other’s agent, and that Lincare was promoting its own business. Lincare’s lawyer will argue that taking over the origin
The Tenth Circuit considers a medical student’s suspension over statements made to a mental-health crisis line. The student attended the University of Oklahoma. During crisis-line contacts in the spring of 2024, she made statements that the university interpreted as threats of harm to herself and administrators. Crisis-line personnel alerted the university, which treated the statements as threats and imposed a one-year suspension after a disciplinary hearing. She sued, saying the university punished protected speech made while she sought help. The trial court allowed her First Amendment claims against individual administrators to proceed, and those officials appealed. The immediate issue is qualified immunity: whether the officials can avoid personal liability for money damages because the law was not clearly established when they acted. Their lawyer will argue that the Supreme Court’s criminal true-threat ruling did not clearly establish the rules for university discipline. The studen
The Ninth Circuit considers an Eritrean citizen's challenge to the denial of asylum and related protection. An immigration judge rejected his testimony as not credible, and the immigration appeals board upheld that decision. A government investigation report was part of the basis for disbelieving him. The report said investigators found no record matching his account of arriving in Brazil during his journey. He asked to subpoena the two investigators, but the judge denied that request. His lawyer will argue that he could not meaningfully test the report's reliability without questioning the people who prepared it. Listen for the difference between weighing a witness's credibility and ensuring a fair opportunity to challenge the evidence used against him. Eyob-Hagos v. Blanche (No. 24-7675) — U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit, argued November 18, 2026. Sources: Official Ninth Circuit oral argument: Official recording archive: Filed habeas petition: prior asylum procedure, page
The Tenth Circuit hears the Muscogee Creek Nation's challenge to Tulsa County's criminal jurisdiction. Officials in Tulsa County asserted authority to bring state criminal cases against Indians who are not citizens of the Creek Nation, for conduct on the Creek Reservation. The Nation sued, saying the sheriff's policy sends those defendants into state rather than tribal court and undermines its own criminal justice system. Here, nonmember means an Indian who is not a Creek citizen, not a non-Indian. The dispute concerns crimes outside the federal Major Crimes Act. The trial court refused to stop the prosecutions and entered judgment for the district attorney. It also dismissed the sheriff, reasoning that he does not decide whom to prosecute. The Nation's lawyer will argue that federal law protects tribal authority over all Indians, and that state prosecutions interfere with its charging and sentencing decisions. The district attorney's lawyer will argue that state and tribal jurisdictio
The Tenth Circuit hears Skinner versus Berry Petroleum Company. Oil truck driver Cody Skinner says he was injured when he opened a hatch on Berry's oil storage tank and condensate sprayed into his face. His theory was that damaged seals and waxy oil buildup trapped pressure that was released when he opened the hatch. A jury found in his favor, and the trial judge refused to set the verdict aside. Berry will argue that knowing a seal was damaged did not mean it knew about this particular pressure hazard. The company will also challenge whether the expert's explanation, together with the other evidence, was enough to prove what caused the incident. Skinner's lawyer will argue that the maintenance evidence, photographs, and witness testimony allowed the jury to find both notice and causation. Notice here means that Berry knew or should have known about the dangerous condition. Berry also wants a new trial, arguing that a government safety alert about oil-field hazards unfairly influenced
The Tenth Circuit hears Utah versus Express Scripts. Utah sued Express Scripts, Optum, and related companies in state court over their alleged role in the opioid crisis. These pharmacy benefit managers help health plans decide which prescription drugs are covered and on what terms. Utah alleges they favored opioids in exchange for payments from manufacturers, while failing to curb dangerous prescribing. The companies also serve military, veterans', and federal-employee health plans. They moved the lawsuit to federal court under the federal-officer removal law. Utah says its complaint expressly excludes their federal work. The district judge accepted that limitation and sent the case back to state court. The companies' lawyer will argue that joint rebate negotiations and shared drug lists cannot be divided neatly between federal and private business. Utah's lawyer will argue that the claims target non-federal conduct and can remain in state court. There is also a second question: must t
The Ninth Circuit hears Kluwe versus the Huntington Beach Union High School District. Christopher Kluwe coached football at Edison High School. In February 2025, he protested a proposed library plaque that he viewed as promoting the Make America Great Again movement. His coaching job ended days later. He alleges retaliation for political speech. The district pointed to a social media post it said suggested violence; Kluwe says he was calling for complaints, not violence. He sued the district and school officials over his constitutional rights. The trial court dismissed the claims against the district on sovereign-immunity grounds. This appeal therefore begins with who can be sued, not whether the firing violated free-speech protections. The lawyers will debate whether the district is legally part of California itself or a separate public body. Kluwe's lawyer will seek a fresh assessment under recent Supreme Court guidance; the district will argue that older Ninth Circuit decisions stil
The Ninth Circuit hears Keene versus the City and County of San Francisco. Two city employees sought religious exemptions from the city's COVID-19 vaccination requirement. After their requests were denied, they retired rather than face termination. They sued, saying the city should have accommodated their beliefs through measures such as remote work or protective equipment. After two appeals over preliminary relief, the Ninth Circuit directed the trial court to grant an injunction. The employees now seek lost pay and related employment benefits as part of that temporary relief, not just an order restoring their jobs. Their lawyer will argue that putting them back where they were before the dispute requires that fuller remedy. The city will argue that the earlier ruling did not award back pay and that further relief can still be sought in the trial court. Listen for whether the requested relief was properly presented and supported, and why a temporary order does not finally decide the l
The Tenth Circuit hears United States versus Ballage. Officers investigated a report that a man had struck a child with a water bottle. They stopped Ballage, used handcuffs, and searched his jacket. The distinction between two pockets matters: the officer first reached into the right pocket, while the gun was found in the left. Ballage says the first intrusion exceeded a protective weapons frisk and led to the discovery of the gun. He also challenges whether the officers had grounds for the frisk and whether their use of force turned the stop into an arrest. The lawyers will debate whether the gun should be excluded because of what happened in the other pocket. Listen for the difference between saying the officer could lawfully ask about weapons and deciding whether this particular discovery resulted from an unlawful search. United States v. Ballage (No. 25-1438) — U.S. Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit, argued November 18, 2026. Sources: Official Tenth Circuit oral argument: Offi
The Ninth Circuit hears Javier Vasquez-Velasco's challenge to two murder convictions. The case began with the killing of two tourists at a restaurant in Guadalajara, Mexico, in 1985. Prosecutors said cartel members mistook them for DEA agents and attacked them in retaliation for drug-enforcement operations. Vasquez-Velasco was convicted in 1990 of aiding and abetting those murders in furtherance of racketeering. His trial also included defendants accused in the separate killing of a DEA agent; he was not charged with that killing. The government has since conceded that FBI agent Michael Malone gave false hair-analysis testimony at that trial. The district judge denied relief, finding that Malone's testimony about the other killing was not material to Vasquez-Velasco's convictions. The defense will argue that the false science bolstered witnesses whose credibility tied the whole prosecution together. The government will argue that the jury could separate the cases and that other evidenc
The Eleventh Circuit hears Pablo Arthur-Rodger's dispute with Northern Trust and Bank of America. The background is a mortgage loan and repeated attempts to foreclose. Arthur-Rodger alleges that earlier foreclosure papers described a lost note, while later versions carried endorsements absent from the earlier copy. He contends that the documents were fraudulently altered, and has sought damages over their use. Those are allegations, not findings that the banks committed fraud. The dispute reached federal court and then this appeal. The lawyers will debate when Florida's litigation privilege prevents a separate damages suit over litigation-related conduct. Florida law protects some conduct in judicial proceedings, but does not give every related act outside court automatic absolute immunity. Listen for the distinction between allegedly creating false documents before suit and submitting them in court. You will also hear whether challenging a lender's authority to foreclose is the same a
The Ninth Circuit hears United States versus Hamalowa. A single fatal shooting led to five federal convictions against Clifton Hamalowa, including first-degree murder and two assaults. This argument focuses on whether those assault convictions can stand alongside the murder conviction. The defense will argue that the assaults were the killing itself, so keeping all three convictions punishes the same offense twice. The government will argue that murder and assault have distinct legal requirements and permit separate convictions. The judges will press both sides on whether to compare the facts of this shooting or the elements legally required for each crime. They will also consider plain-error review: the rule allowing certain errors affecting substantial rights to be considered even when they were not raised below. Listen for the difference between offering a jury alternative charges and keeping multiple convictions after the verdict. United States v. Hamalowa (No. 25-3488) — U.S. Cour
The Tenth Circuit hears Devon Energy's royalty dispute with the Interior Department. Devon paid an outside company a bundled fee to move and treat natural gas. The government required it to separate deductible transportation costs from the costs of making that gas marketable. Devon objected that the contractor's confidential cost data was unavailable. In 2019, a Wyoming federal judge set aside the challenged transportation-deduction decisions and sent the 2005-through-2007 dispute back to the agency for more fact-finding. The judge directed Devon to try alternative cost estimates and left a due-process objection for possible later court review. That promised later review raises today's question: did the original lawsuit stay open during the remand, or did Devon need to go through agency appeals before returning to court? The lawyers will debate what the earlier court order preserved and how the royalty statute's filing deadlines affect that route. Listen for the difference between winn
The Tenth Circuit hears Lyman versus Henderson. In 2024, Utah voter Phil Lyman asked the lieutenant governor's office for the state's full voter registration database. His request included birth years and records classified as private or withheld under state law. The office directed him to the public version, but declined unrestricted access, citing Utah's disclosure restrictions. Lyman sued under the National Voter Registration Act, arguing that federal disclosure requirements override those limits. He says he needs the records to check voter-list accuracy and propose improvements. The district court dismissed the case in January 2026 for lack of standing: it found no concrete personal harm beyond being denied the information. That ruling did not decide whether federal law actually requires disclosure of these records. Now Lyman is appealing. His lawyer will argue that denial of records required to be public is itself an injury, and that the refusal obstructs his election oversight. T
The Tenth Circuit hears an excessive-force appeal involving the city of Cheyenne and one of its police officers. The plaintiff says a trip to the movies with her family ended in a minor parking-lot collision, which she reported to police. She says she had trouble following the officer's instructions and objected to questioning of her son-in-law. She alleges the officer pulled her from the vehicle and used a takedown that broke her ankle. She sued the officer and the city, alleging excessive force and inadequate police training. The trial judge granted judgment to both defendants without a trial, and she appealed. Her lawyer will argue that she was trying to comply, posed no immediate threat, and deserves a jury's assessment of the encounter. The officer's lawyer will argue that repeated noncompliance and resistance to handcuffing justified the force. The city's lawyer will defend the judgment and challenge the grounds for holding the city itself responsible. Listen for whether the judg
The Tenth Circuit hears Vitamins Online versus HeartWise. This began as a false-advertising suit between two companies selling vitamins and supplements online. Vitamins Online won a money judgment, and HeartWise then entered bankruptcy. About fourteen and a half million dollars was deposited with the bankruptcy court to pay that judgment. But Vitamins Online and its former law firm, MCG, each claimed the right to collect it. Their fee agreement called for payments to go through the firm, which would deduct its fees and pass the balance to the client. In 2024, the Utah district court ruled that Vitamins Online had the collection right. The firm appealed, but that same judge later vacated the challenged orders. Now the threshold question is whether this court can hear the appeal at all. The firm's lawyer will seek dismissal, arguing that later developments leave no effective relief to grant. Vitamins Online's lawyer will argue that the appeal transferred authority to this court, preventi
The Tenth Circuit hears Osage Nation versus Taylor. The dispute began with Oklahoma's effort to collect state income taxes from Osage citizens living and working within the Nation's claimed reservation boundaries. In 2010, the Tenth Circuit upheld a judgment that the reservation had been disestablished. The Nation now seeks relief from that old judgment after McGirt, the Supreme Court decision recognizing the continued existence of the Muscogee Creek reservation. The district court denied the reopening request without deciding the Osage reservation question anew. That brings the Nation here under Rule sixty, which allows limited relief from final civil judgments. Its lawyer will argue that the old ruling continues to constrain tribal jurisdiction, and that sovereignty makes this more than an ordinary change in law. The tax commissioners' lawyer will argue that a later decision involving a different tribe does not justify reopening this final judgment. Listen for the difference between
The Ninth Circuit considers who can join an Oakland rent-control lawsuit. Renters with mobility disabilities sued the city because the accessible apartments they need generally fall outside its rent-control protections. The program covers older housing, while most accessible units were built later. The renters want those protections extended to qualifying newer housing as a disability accommodation. That proposal runs into California's Costa-Hawkins law, which protects certain newer housing from local rent control. The California Apartment Association asked to join as a defendant to defend that law and its members' financial interests. The district court refused, finding the request too late and the existing parties adequate to represent those interests. The association will argue that the need to intervene only became clear later, and that its interests differ from the city's. The renters will argue it waited too long and the existing defendants can protect those interests. Listen for
The Ninth Circuit hears Vicas versus Blanche. Vicas, a citizen of Romania, had been granted asylum in the United States. Years later, immigration officials alleged fraud in his original application. An immigration judge terminated his asylum status, found him removable, and denied further protection. Vicas is challenging the basis for taking away that protection. The hearing covers two connected petitions: the challenge to the underlying agency decision, and a challenge to its later refusal to reopen the proceedings. The first dispute turns on proof: what does the record actually establish about the application, as distinct from what immigration officials alleged? The second concerns whether the agency properly considered reopening the case. Listen for the judges separating evidence of fraud from suspicion, and asking how the two petitions depend on each other. Vicas v. Blanche (No. 25-6879) — U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit, argued November 18, 2026. Sources: Official Nint
The Tenth Circuit hears United States versus Peach. Dana Peach was convicted of conspiring to commit forced labor within the United Nation of Islam. Prosecutors said the organization used threats and punishment to obtain unpaid work, including labor by children, in its businesses and members' homes. This argument focuses on what witnesses could tell the jury about statements made by other alleged participants. Peach challenges whether the judge made the necessary findings before allowing those statements to be used against her. Her lawyer will argue that general categories were not enough: the court had to tie the actual statements to the conspiracy. Listen for the difference between challenging the judge's overall method and showing that a particular piece of evidence should have been kept out. United States v. Peach (No. 25-3145) — U.S. Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit, argued November 18, 2026. Sources: Official Tenth Circuit oral argument: Official argument listing: Federal P
The Tenth Circuit hears United States versus Mejia. Mejia had pawned his own gun. When he returned to make a loan payment, he completed a federal firearms form. His answer about pending criminal charges led to a false-statement conviction. He challenges whether the evidence showed he knew his charging status. His lawyer says he was paying down the loan, not trying to take the gun home. Mejia also challenges an instruction given after jurors reported a deadlock. Known as an Allen charge, it urged them to keep deliberating. Mejia's lawyer will argue that the instruction improperly pressured jurors to reach a verdict. Another question becomes central: was making a loan payment actually acquiring, or attempting to acquire, a firearm? United States v. Mejia (No. 25-1295) — U.S. Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit, argued November 18, 2026. Sources: Official Tenth Circuit oral argument: Official argument listing: Federal Public Defender: pending Mejia issues (Oct. 2026, questions not ruli