English-language podcasts

Podcasts

Oral Arguments, with Context

An episode can be the start of a conversation. Explore recent releases, share your thoughts, and meet through a ThinkMatch Roundtable.

Ask friends about this

Episodes to discuss

Oral Arguments, with Context

Glenwood Springs v. U.S. Department of the Interior, et al. — 10th Cir. (Nov 16, 2026)

38 min

The Tenth Circuit hears Glenwood Springs Citizens' Alliance versus the Department of the Interior, a dispute over access to federal records concerning an RMI limestone mine. The Alliance asked the Bureau of Land Management for records under the Freedom of Information Act, or FOIA. The agency produced records but withheld some information as confidential business material. The Alliance challenged the agency's handling of its requests and the adequacy of its search. A federal district court ruled for Interior and the Bureau, and the Alliance appealed. This appeal concerns public access to government-held records, rather than whether the mine may operate. One exception, known as Exemption Four, covers trade secrets and qualifying confidential commercial or financial information. Listen for arguments about confidentiality and the extent of the agency's records search. Glenwood Springs v. U.S. Department of the Interior, et al. (No. 25-1347) — U.S. Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit, ar

Discuss this episode

Oral Arguments, with Context

Tartt v. Unified School District No. 475 — 10th Cir. (Nov 16, 2026)

35 min

The Tenth Circuit hears Tartt versus Unified School District Number Four Seventy-Five, a race-discrimination case from Junction City, Kansas. Ms. Tartt, a Black educator, served first as interim principal of Junction City High School and then received a regular principal's contract. After staff complained about her management, the school board voted not to renew her contract in 2022. The district says leadership and workplace problems drove that decision. Tartt contends that delayed evaluations and unequal treatment, along with statements about racial bias on the board, point to discrimination. On an earlier appeal, the Tenth Circuit directed the trial judge to reconsider parts of the human-resources director's affidavit about performance evaluations. The trial court again ruled for the district without a trial. Now Tartt will argue that a jury could find the performance reasons were a pretext: a cover for racial discrimination. The district will defend its reasons and argue that the e

Discuss this episode

Oral Arguments, with Context

Brank Cove Capital, et al. v. CIR — 10th Cir. (Nov 16, 2026)

33 min

The Tenth Circuit hears Brank Cove Capital versus the Commissioner of Internal Revenue over a charitable tax deduction for mountain land near Asheville, North Carolina. The partnership donated a conservation easement, giving up development rights to preserve the land. To value that donation, it treated a planned fifty-cabin vacation resort as the land's highest and best use: its most valuable feasible use. The IRS disputed that development plan, citing steep terrain, building restrictions, and problems with access and utilities. The Tax Court instead adopted a lower-density residential, recreation, and timber use, resulting in a much smaller deduction. A key dispute concerns the partnership's appraisal: its author did not testify, and the Tax Court would not accept the report as proof of its valuation. Brank Cove will argue that the report should have been admitted under the exception for business records and that the court wrongly discounted the property's development potential. The C

Discuss this episode

Oral Arguments, with Context

New York Times Company v. DOD — D.C. Cir. (Nov 16, 2026)

63 min

The D.C. Circuit hears New York Times Company versus the Department of Defense, a challenge to the Pentagon's escort rule for reporters. For decades, credentialed reporters could move unescorted through designated parts of the Pentagon, visiting press offices and talking informally with officials. After a court ordered the reinstatement of Times reporters' credentials in March 2026, the Department announced an interim policy the next business day. Journalists could attend arranged briefings or interviews, but would need an official escort at all times. The Times and one of its reporters brought a separate lawsuit, arguing that this rule punished their reporting and their earlier court victory. They say planned, escorted visits are no substitute for spontaneous conversations with sources. The district judge found their retaliation claim likely to succeed and granted a preliminary injunction, an initial order to block the requirement while the case proceeds. The government will defend th

Discuss this episode

Oral Arguments, with Context

Western First Aid & Safety v. Aramark Uniform & Career Apparel — 10th Cir. (Nov 16, 2026)

38 min

The Tenth Circuit hears Western First Aid and Safety versus Aramark Uniform and Career Apparel, a dispute over additional payments after the sale of a business. In 2017, Western sold its assets to Aramark for an upfront price plus five annual payments tied to revenue from first aid and safety operations. These additional payments, called an earnout, would give Western a share of later revenue growth. When the COVID pandemic drove up demand for masks, gloves, and hand sanitizers, Aramark excluded some of those sales from the earnout calculation. Western sued, contending that the excluded revenue should increase what it was paid. After a trial without a jury, the federal district court in Kansas ruled for Aramark: the contract covered specified business operations, not every sale of safety products across the company. Western will argue that the contract includes qualifying revenue from Aramark's existing operations, not just the business acquired from Western. Aramark will respond that

Discuss this episode

Oral Arguments, with Context

Ecolab, Inc. v. IBA, Inc. and Webco Chemical Corp. — 1st Cir. (Jul 30, 2026)

37 min

The First Circuit hears Ecolab versus IBA and Webco, a trade-secrets dispute over whether two related lawsuits can proceed in different courts. The underlying business involved teat dips, disinfectants applied to cows' teats before or after milking. Ecolab licensed IBA to make and sell its products, and IBA used Webco as its manufacturer. After the license expired, Webco made and IBA sold competing products. Ecolab alleges that they used its confidential formulas and manufacturing information to develop those products. Ecolab first sued in Minnesota, where a judge limited discovery about development of the competing products because that claim was outside the complaint as pleaded. Webco was also dismissed from that suit because the Minnesota court lacked personal jurisdiction, the authority to make Webco defend the case there. Ecolab then brought a separate suit against IBA and Webco in Massachusetts. The Massachusetts judge dismissed that second suit without deciding the trade-secret

Discuss this episode

Oral Arguments, with Context

Masis Staffing Solutions, LLC v. OSHA — 11th Cir. (Jul 31, 2026)

32 min

The Eleventh Circuit hears Masis Staffing Solutions versus OSHA, a dispute over a staffing agency's responsibility for workplace safety. Masis supplied workers to Ridgway, which ran the worksite. The case arose when a bundle of trusses left standing upright fell and crushed a Masis worker. An on-site supervisor knew workers had previously stood bundles upright and had warned them about the danger. OSHA cited Masis for violating a materials-storage safety standard. An administrative law judge upheld the citation, finding that the supervisor's knowledge of the dangerous practice counted as knowledge by Masis itself. The judge also rejected Masis's defense that the violation resulted from employee misconduct it could not reasonably prevent. That is the background to two questions you will hear: who actually had authority to correct the danger, and what the company had to know about it. Masis will contend that the supervisor's authority came from Ridgway, not Masis, and that earlier warnin

Discuss this episode

Oral Arguments, with Context

American Electric Power Service Corporation v. FERC — D.C. Cir. (Nov 13, 2026)

45 min

American Electric Power Service Corporation and other transmission owners challenge requirements for agreements governing transmission projects. PJM selects power-line projects and upgrades to meet transmission needs, then identifies the companies responsible for building them. The dispute began when consumer organizations, including American Municipal Power, complained that PJM was not obtaining all the designated entity agreements required by its rules. These project agreements set construction obligations and milestones, and can also require financial security. The Federal Energy Regulatory Commission, known as FERC, found that PJM had not followed its agreement rules. It removed security requirements for certain projects without competing outside developers, but retained the remaining agreement requirements. It also kept full agreements for some competitively selected projects even when their costs would not be shared across the region. The transmission owners sought rehearing and

Discuss this episode

Oral Arguments, with Context

In Re: New York City Board of Education — 2d Cir. (Nov 13, 2026)

37 min

The Second Circuit returns to the teacher-discrimination class action against the New York City Board of Education. The underlying lawsuit challenged a licensing exam used for public-school teachers; failing it could block access to full-time teaching work. After years of litigation, the case reached a phase in which class members sought individual monetary relief. Peter Wilds-Bethea stayed involved for decades and became the sole class representative for that phase. The present appeal concerns his service award, an additional payment for representing the class, separate from compensation for his own employment losses. After he initially requested two point nine million dollars, the district court set that award at three hundred fifty thousand dollars. Two other named plaintiffs were awarded about two hundred seventy-three thousand dollars each. Those two amounts came from agreements with the Board, while his amount had to be decided by the court. Wilds-Bethea will argue that his longe

Discuss this episode

Oral Arguments, with Context

Michelle Murray v. Debbie Shaw — D.C. Cir. (Nov 13, 2026)

46 min

The D.C. Circuit hears Michelle Murray versus Debbie Shaw. Murray worked as a lawyer in the Social Security Administration’s inspector-general office and served as its whistleblower-protection coordinator. The underlying dispute began after agency lawyers raised concerns about Social Security’s financial-penalty program. Shaw, another agency lawyer, challenged personnel actions as whistleblower retaliation and won corrective relief from an administrative judge. News coverage later described Murray as one of the officials the judge had found retaliated against Shaw. Murray says that description misstated the decision and wrongly portrayed her as responsible for continuing retaliation. She sued Shaw, other federal employees, and news organizations for defamation and related claims. The district court dismissed the lawsuit, finding that some reporting fairly described the administrative proceeding and that other claims were inadequately pleaded. Murray will argue that the reporting attrib

Discuss this episode

Oral Arguments, with Context

West v. City of Hartford — 2d Cir. (Nov 13, 2026)

31 min

The Second Circuit hears Paul West versus the City of Hartford. West was a Hartford police lieutenant on medical leave when he applied for promotion to captain. After receiving his exam scores, he asked human resources for information about the assessment panel, including its racial makeup. He also asked who was responsible for complying with a Connecticut law on promoting minority police officers. West was not promoted, and his paid-leave status was later temporarily withdrawn. He sued the city, alleging discrimination and retaliation. The district court entered judgment for the city without a trial. It held that his information requests did not qualify for anti-retaliation protection, and found insufficient evidence of retaliation. The focus here is Title Seven, the federal employment-discrimination law, and its protection against retaliation. West will argue that seeking information about suspected bias can itself be protected. The city will argue that the email did not clearly comp

Discuss this episode

Oral Arguments, with Context

Michael Leach v. District of Columbia — D.C. Cir. (Nov 13, 2026)

35 min

The D.C. Circuit hears Michael Leach versus the District of Columbia. Police responding to a reported shooting encountered Leach standing in an apartment doorway with a gun. One officer shot him five times. After he fell, other officers moved in to retrieve the gun and handcuff him; another officer repeatedly struck him in the face. Leach brought a civil excessive-force case against the District and the officers. The district court rejected his claims on summary judgment. Leach will ask for the case to go back for further proceedings, arguing that the judge wrongly resolved important factual disputes against him. The District and the officers will argue that the force was reasonable and that Leach has not shown a violation of clearly established law. Qualified immunity adds a separate requirement: existing law at the time must have clearly established that the particular conduct was unlawful. The appeal concerns both the shooting and the later blows, and what the body-camera evidence p

Discuss this episode

Oral Arguments, with Context

The Central Orthopedic Group, LLP v. Aetna Life Insurance Company — 2d Cir. (Nov 12, 2026)

31 min

The Second Circuit hears two related appeals between the Central Orthopedic Group and Aetna. The medical practice says it provided care outside Aetna's network to patients covered by Aetna plans, but was not properly reimbursed. To sue for plan benefits under the federal law known as ERISA, the practice relies on patients' assignments of their benefit rights: claimed transfers of the right to pursue payment. But the plans contain anti-assignment clauses, and Aetna says those restrictions prevent the practice from bringing the patients' claims. The practice responds that Aetna gave up that defense by dealing directly with it, processing claims and appeals, and paying part of some bills. This is a waiver argument: intentionally giving up a contractual right. The district court dismissed the federal benefits claims, finding that ordinary claims handling did not show a waiver, and denied permission to amend the complaints. The practice will argue that the plan clauses needed further examin

Discuss this episode

Oral Arguments, with Context

United States v. Daniel Kingery — D.C. Cir. (Nov 12, 2026)

48 min

The D.C. Circuit hears United States versus Daniel Kingery. Kingery was living in an encampment in Washington's McPherson Square when authorities cleared the park in 2023. He opposed the clearance and said he would not leave voluntarily; that dispute eventually led to federal park-regulation charges. During a later remote proceeding scheduled for trial on those tickets, he appeared by telephone and represented himself. He insisted on a jury trial and disconnected rather than proceed before the magistrate judge alone. That disconnection became the basis of a separate criminal contempt charge, not just the fact that he had criticized the judge. The same magistrate later convicted him of both the park offenses and contempt, with time-served sentences after nineteen days in custody. Kingery will challenge the absence of a jury, while acknowledging Supreme Court precedent that denies jury trials for petty offenses. A central question is whether participating by telephone puts him in the pre

Discuss this episode

Oral Arguments, with Context

Norfolk Southern Railway Company v. Soo Line Railroad Company — 7th Cir. (Nov 12, 2026)

33 min

The Seventh Circuit hears Norfolk Southern versus Soo Line, which operates as Canadian Pacific. This case concerns a rail connection used to move freight between Detroit and Chicago. In 2005, Norfolk Southern gave Canadian Pacific long-term rights to run trains over part of its network. A separate interchange agreement allowed those trains to connect to Gibson Yard through tracks controlled by Norfolk Southern and Conrail, with Indiana Harbor Belt handling the interchange. Norfolk Southern signed that second agreement as a consenting party, rather than as the railroad performing the interchange service. It later sued to end its obligations, arguing that the second agreement sets no fixed end date for it and can be terminated on reasonable notice. The practical dispute is whether a connection needed to make the longer-term route work can be withdrawn separately. After a bench trial, the district court treated the two agreements as linked and ruled that Norfolk Southern could not termina

Discuss this episode

Oral Arguments, with Context

SEC v. Laura and Sichenzio — 2d Cir. (Nov 12, 2026)

25 min

The Second Circuit considers how much two defendants must pay back in a Securities and Exchange Commission enforcement case. The underlying venture raised money for companies promoting crude-oil processing technology. Investors were offered revenue-sharing agreements, shares and convertible loans. The SEC alleged they were misled about the technology, expected returns and how their money would be used. It said investor money went to personal spending and repayment of personal debts rather than the promised business purposes. Partial consent judgments left the amounts of monetary relief for the judge to decide. For that calculation, the defendants agreed the complaint's allegations would be treated as true. The dispute now concerns disgorgement: giving up profits from wrongdoing. Their lawyer will argue that money they put into the venture and legitimate business expenses must be accounted for, so the award does not exceed what they actually gained. The SEC will argue that its calculati

Discuss this episode

Oral Arguments, with Context

Sierra Club v. EPA — D.C. Cir. (Nov 12, 2026)

58 min

The D.C. Circuit hears Sierra Club versus the Environmental Protection Agency. The dispute concerns federal air-pollution standards for facilities that burn solid waste. These rules cover very small municipal garbage burners and institutional waste incinerators. The underlying standards date to 2005, and an earlier court challenge led the agency to reconsider them. In 2025, EPA revised the standards and definitions, but continued to leave other kinds of burners outside this rule. Examples include crematories and units used to destroy confiscated contraband. EPA also excluded rudimentary combustion devices, saying the standards and controls developed for other incinerators were not appropriate for those devices. The central question is whether the Clean Air Act requires standards for every incinerator within its definition, or gives EPA discretion to choose which additional categories to regulate. EPA will argue that it lawfully reviewed the standards for the categories already regulate

Discuss this episode

Oral Arguments, with Context

Roshani Sheth v. National Association of Realtors — 7th Cir. (Nov 12, 2026)

33 min

The Seventh Circuit hears a former employee's appeal against the National Association of Realtors, or NAR. The former employee had complained about workplace discrimination. After her employment ended, she signed a settlement releasing claims from her time at the association. That agreement included a promise of neutral employment references. She later struggled to find work and says the association failed to respond to employment checks. She also says she received harassing texts while her discrimination charge was under investigation. She treats those events as retaliation for pursuing a discrimination complaint, but the connection to the employer is disputed. She is appealing the dismissal of her retaliation and race-discrimination claims. Her lawyer will argue that the allegations, viewed together, justify letting her seek evidence through discovery. The association's lawyer will argue that the complaint does not plausibly link the texts or the unanswered reference requests to reta

Discuss this episode

Oral Arguments, with Context

Central American Bank for Economic Integration v. Dante Mossi — D.C. Cir. (Nov 12, 2026)

45 min

The D.C. Circuit hears the Central American Bank for Economic Integration versus Dante Mossi. At the heart of this lawsuit is a falling-out between the bank and its former president. The bank says Mossi steered an electric-vehicle relationship toward his own future business while still working for the bank. It points to a bank-funded Washington conference and purchases of two electric vehicles. After leaving, Mossi formed a vehicle-distribution business, and the bank accuses him of attacking its reputation with credit-rating agencies and business partners. It sued him under RICO, the federal racketeering law, alleging fraud and extortion. Those claims are disputed. The district judge found jurisdiction over Mossi but dismissed the racketeering claim, finding the alleged enterprise, underlying crimes, and pattern inadequately pleaded. The bank will argue that those requirements were read too narrowly, and that Washington was the starting point of the alleged scheme. Mossi's lawyer will

Discuss this episode

Oral Arguments, with Context

United States of America v. Genaro Garcia Luna — 2d Cir. (Nov 12, 2026)

34 min

The Second Circuit hears the United States versus Garcia Luna. Garcia Luna is a former senior Mexican security official. Prosecutors said he took bribes from the Sinaloa Cartel to protect drug shipments bound for the United States. A federal jury convicted him of drug-trafficking offenses and making false statements. He sought a new trial, claiming that later-obtained material exposed false testimony and withheld evidence useful to the defense. The trial judge denied that request, finding that much of the claimed new evidence was already known or accessible before trial. The lawyers' references to thirty-five-hundred material mean certain prior statements by prosecution witnesses. His lawyer will argue that the additional material undermines important prosecution witnesses and warrants a new trial. The government will argue that the defense could have investigated facts its client already knew, and that other witnesses independently supported the verdict. Recording note: The official f

Discuss this episode

Oral Arguments, with Context

Matthew Haynam v. City of Chicago — 7th Cir. (Nov 12, 2026)

21 min

The Seventh Circuit hears Matthew Haynam versus the City of Chicago. Haynam was a senior manager at Chicago's Civilian Office of Police Accountability, which investigates alleged police misconduct. He says he reported his agency head's alleged interference with investigations and suppression of an internal audit to outside city oversight bodies, and was fired in retaliation. He sued, claiming that the firing violated his First Amendment free-speech rights. The district court dismissed that federal claim because it treated his reports as part of his job, not speech as a private citizen. His lawyer will argue that reporting his boss to outside oversight bodies was not one of his duties, and that the court drew that conclusion too early, before the case developed beyond the complaint. The city's lawyer will argue that the reports concerned investigations and training he was responsible for supervising, so the dismissal should stand. Listen for whether going outside an agency changes the c

Discuss this episode

Oral Arguments, with Context

ACT Now Coalition v. United States Department of Education — 7th Cir. (Nov 12, 2026)

35 min

The Seventh Circuit hears ACT Now Coalition versus the United States Department of Education. Two federal Full-Service Community Schools grants supported ACT Now's work connecting Illinois schools with academic, social, and health services for students and families. In December 2025, the department refused to continue the funding, pointing to diversity, equity, and inclusion language in the original grant applications. The organizations sued, alleging that the government was penalizing their viewpoints rather than controlling what federal money could buy. The district court denied a preliminary injunction, a temporary order that would have restored funding while the lawsuit proceeded, because it found their First Amendment claims unlikely to succeed. Their lawyer will argue that the cited language described the organizations' values, not plans to spend these grants on the disputed training, and that losing student services warrants temporary relief. The government's lawyer will argue t

Discuss this episode

Oral Arguments, with Context

Yeshiva Ohr Shraga Veretzky v. Town of Highland Zoning Board of Appeals — 2d Cir. (Oct 30, 2026)

26 min

The Second Circuit hears a zoning dispute between a religious school and the Town of Highland in New York. The school wanted to use its property for religious education during the summer. The town's zoning code allows places of worship with a special-use permit, but its zoning board concluded that the school's proposal did not qualify. The school brought religious-liberty claims in federal court without first applying for a use variance, permission to depart from the zoning restrictions. The district court dismissed the suit as unripe: too early for federal review because the school had not sought that variance. The school's lawyer will argue that the board's interpretation was already final, and that seeking a variance would give up the legal status the school says the zoning code already allows. The town's lawyer will argue that the school must first seek a variance so the town can make a final decision about how the property may be used. The appeal concerns that threshold, not wheth

Discuss this episode

Oral Arguments, with Context

Frank Lynn Morrison v. Douglas A. Collins — CAVC (Nov 10, 2026)

58 min

The Veterans Court hears Frank Lynn Morrison's appeal over additional disability compensation for his adult stepdaughter. Morrison married her mother in 2021, when the daughter was already over eighteen. He says she lives with the family and has been unable to support herself since childhood. The Board of Veterans' Appeals denied the dependency claim because VA's regulation requires stepchild status to begin before eighteen. The dispute concerns two different questions: when the disability began, and when the stepchild relationship legally began. Congress's definition of a child includes some unmarried adults who became permanently incapable of self-support before eighteen. Morrison will argue that Congress did not also require the stepchild relationship to begin before that age. The Secretary's lawyer will defend VA's rule as continuing a relationship formed in childhood, not creating eligibility through a later marriage. The judges will also consider whether a victory on that legal i

Discuss this episode
Older episodes