Honda and Tesla challenge a Patent Office decision concerning Neo Wireless's patent for organizing wireless transmissions. Think of the available transmission capacity as a grid with time on one axis and frequency on the other. The patent describes arranging data streams into resource segments, aiming to reduce the control information needed to tell devices where their data begins. After automakers challenged the patent, the Patent Trial and Appeal Board found they had not proved the challenged claims unpatentable. A central issue is the meaning of starting time-frequency coordinate: whether separate time and frequency values can satisfy that language. The board relied partly on arguments Neo had made in an earlier Patent Office challenge brought by Dell. You'll hear prosecution disclaimer, the rule that a patent owner's clear and unmistakable statements to the Patent Office can narrow the scope of its claims. This is claim construction, interpreting the words that define patent protec
The Fifth Circuit considers Charles Ray Keys' challenge to drug and firearm convictions arising from a New Orleans house search. Investigators were looking into a child's fentanyl death connected to the property. A later search uncovered cocaine, fentanyl and guns. A jury convicted Keys of possessing drugs with intent to distribute and possessing a firearm as a convicted felon. The central dispute concerns the sworn statement used to obtain the search warrant. A local detective signed it, but an FBI agent supplied much of the underlying investigation. Several statements incorrectly credited the detective with investigative steps. The trial judge allowed the evidence, finding no intent to mislead or reckless disregard for the truth. Keys' lawyer will argue that the misstatements undermined the warrant; the government will defend the ruling and argue that sufficient grounds for the search remained. Under Franks, deliberate or reckless falsehoods can invalidate a warrant if the remaining
The Federal Circuit reviews Jefferson Street Holdings' patent for a protective phone case. The patent describes higher corners and lower side sections, intended to protect the screen while leaving it easier to reach. After reexamining the issued patent against earlier case designs, the Patent Office's appeal board upheld rejections of its claims. A patent claim defines the features the patent seeks to protect. Here, much turns on whether a height that continuously spans a side must stay constant, as the company contends, or can vary while remaining above zero, as the board concluded. The lawyers will also dispute whether curved edges satisfy requirements about extending perpendicular, or at right angles, to the back panel. You'll hear two different patentability tests. Anticipation asks whether one earlier reference already disclosed every claimed feature in the required arrangement. Obviousness asks whether the claimed design, as a whole, would have been obvious to someone with ordina
The D.C. Circuit reviews a defamation verdict over a confidential report. Businessman Christopher Chandler sued a private investigator and his company over a 2003 report accusing Chandler of money laundering. Chandler denied the allegations, and said he first saw the report when British journalists showed it to him in 2018. The report had originally gone to a client; years later, its contents appeared in the British press. An earlier appeal allowed the claim over the investigator's original publication to proceed, but barred damages for the later British-media republication. A jury later awarded Chandler about eight million dollars. In defamation law, publication means communicating a statement to someone else, not necessarily printing it in a newspaper. The damages dispute concerns which harm came from the original circulation rather than the excluded media coverage. You'll also hear about presumed damages: compensation for reputational injury without proving a specific financial loss
The First Circuit considers whether a murder defendant was denied a fair opportunity to present his defense. A 1994 Massachusetts shooting killed one man and injured another. Jermaine Celester was convicted of second-degree murder at a retrial. His defense was that someone in a passing car fired the shots. Jurors heard evidence about the car and two occupants fleeing police. But the judge excluded the occupants' identities, their relationships with the victims, and conflicting accounts of their whereabouts. Celester says those details would have supported his claim that someone else was responsible. After state courts upheld his conviction, a federal judge denied his habeas petition, a challenge to the legality of his imprisonment. He now appeals that denial. His lawyer will argue that excluding the evidence undermined his only defense. The state will defend the ruling as a reasonable response to speculation. Federal habeas review is not an ordinary appeal of an evidence ruling; it giv
A pregnancy-discrimination lawsuit becomes a Supreme Court dispute about a defense raised late. Jasmine Younge served as deputy chief of staff and director of policy and programs for the elected district attorney in Fulton County, Georgia. She says she was fired two weeks after announcing her pregnancy and sued under Title Seven, the federal employment-discrimination law. The office later invoked the personal-staff exception to that law's definition of employee, saying her senior role put her outside its coverage. That defense was missing from the office's answer, its formal response to her complaint. After discovery, the evidence-gathering stage, the office raised it and later sought summary judgment: a ruling without trial. The lower courts allowed the defense, finding that the delay had not unfairly harmed Younge's case, and ruled against her. The Supreme Court is examining that procedural ruling, not deciding whether pregnancy discrimination occurred. An affirmative defense supplie
A fight over a Rhode Island pond has become a fight over which court gets to decide its price. In 2024, Coventry took Johnson's Pond, its dam, and nearby land from private owners through eminent domain: the government's power to acquire private property for public use with just compensation. The town deposited an estimated one hundred fifty-seven thousand dollars in state court. Soscia Holdings and related companies later sued in federal court for compensation and other damages; they no longer seek to undo the taking. A federal judge halted the state-court compensation proceedings, and the town appealed. The owners rely on Knick, a Supreme Court decision allowing federal takings claims without first litigating for compensation in state court. The question here is whether that access to federal court also justifies stopping the state case. A state compensation judgment might bind the federal court, a concern called preclusion. You'll also hear about abstention: circumstances in which a
The First Circuit hears Sandoval versus Mennonite General Hospital, a medical-malpractice appeal from Puerto Rico involving the care of a patient who died. The plaintiffs say doctors failed to obtain follow-up imaging recommended by a radiologist. Their expert would have said that this violated the required standard of medical care. The district judge excluded his testimony, finding that he had not reliably explained the basis for that standard. Without admissible expert evidence, the judge dismissed the claims against the doctors and the treating hospital without a trial. Mennonite General Hospital had already won judgment in an earlier ruling. Much of the appeal concerns whether the expert's report and later affidavit sufficiently explained his opinion. Daubert refers to the judge's screening of expert evidence for relevance and reliability. Sua sponte means acting on the court's own initiative. David Efron will speak for the plaintiffs. Sandoval, et al. v. Mennonite General Hospital
The First Circuit hears United States versus Trung Nguyen. The prosecution arose from cash-to-Bitcoin conversions through a business called National Vending. Nguyen was convicted of operating an unlicensed money-transmitting business and money laundering. At trial, the judge excluded a proposed defense expert. Nguyen sought a new trial, saying that exclusion had undermined his defense; the request was denied. Expert testimony must be relevant and reliable, and the trial judge screens whether it qualifies. Abuse-of-discretion review gives that judge latitude; an appeals court does not simply replace the trial judge's assessment with its own. A vagueness challenge asks whether a law gives ordinary people fair notice of prohibited conduct and adequate standards against arbitrary enforcement. Bradford Keene will speak for Nguyen. United States v. Trung Nguyen (No. 25-1562) — U.S. Court of Appeals for the First Circuit, argued November 2, 2026. Sources: Argument audio — official First Circu
The Federal Circuit hears Orckit's appeal over a patent for moving data through network equipment. The patent describes using one calculation to choose two physical links that a piece of data will travel through. The dispute also involved a federal patent lawsuit between Orckit and Cisco. Cisco asked the Patent Trial and Appeal Board to review the patent. The Board ruled for Cisco and Juniper Networks, finding the challenged claims unpatentable based on an earlier disclosure called Bruckman. Orckit challenges how the Board interpreted its claims: the words defining what the patent protects. Does choosing one link also select a second when the first choice fixes the second? And what must be arranged in parallel? Legal interpretation is reviewed de novo, meaning afresh. Factual findings need substantial evidence: enough relevant evidence for a reasonable mind to accept. George Stamatopoulos of Kobre and Kim will seek reversal for Orckit. Orckit Corp. v. Cisco Systems, Inc. (No. 25-1319)