On this episode of The Daniel Mael Show, an open-minded, in-depth conversation about how Jewish and Israel-related philanthropy actually works, Daniel Mael sits down with Arnie Draiman of Draiman Consulting. Draiman is a philanthropic consultant who, for the past 30 years, has helped donors, philanthropists, and foundations give to nonprofits, mostly in Israel, doing on-the-ground due diligence as a financial consultant in the nonprofit world. He argues that about 99 percent of nonprofits do good work, but that is not enough; they also have to be run like a business. He is skeptical of GuideStar/Candid and Charity Navigator star ratings, warns that some Israeli certification schemes are paid for by the groups being rated, and says professional fundraisers are not supposed to work on commission. When a telemarketer calls, he says the first question should be whether you are speaking to a call center, because those operations can keep 50, 60, even 80 percent of the gift. He grounds that
Daniel Mael speaks with Rabbi Yehoshua Pfeffer, a community rabbi and dayan who heads the Iyun Institute and recently helped shape the rabbinic voice of HaTzibur HaHaredi, a new Haredi party in Israel's Knesset elections. Pfeffer explains how Haredi isolation grew as a defense against modernity, and why it can't hold now that Haredim are about 15 percent of Israel and a fast-growing share of its children. He walks through views of the state, from Satmar and Neturei Karta to a mainstream that objects to Zionism redefining Jewish identity but has drawn closer to Israel over the decades. On the draft, he says full-time Torah scholars should be left to learn and others should serve. He did Haredi army service himself after age 27, and he argues the IDF is far more ready for Haredi soldiers than it was even three years ago. He also calls Israel's general school system abysmal on Jewish knowledge and says living on government subsidies is not dignified and runs against the Torah.