Listen through the publisher, then discuss the episode here or arrange an in-person Roundtable. Your city determines where to meet.
Roundtables are designed for groups of four, with a shared subject and room for everyone to speak. Come for discussion, with no dating expectation.
In this week's Proof Over Precedent episode, Shay Cleary of the National Center for State Courts talks about the risks facing state and local courts in balancing openness and transparency amid cybersecurity threats. Legacy systems, open-records requirements, limited funding, and reliance on outside vendors all contribute to a vulnerable security system. Cleary and HLS J.D. candidate Ashil Jhaveri share security that may support both access to justice and secure, trustworthy courts.
Episode information is provided by the publisher. Listening takes place on the publisher’s service.
The Ninth Circuit hears a physician's challenge to the way Arizona disciplined his medical license. Charles Kelly practiced medicine in Arizona. During disciplinary proceedings, the Medical Board imposed an interim agreement setting conditions on his practice, including monitoring and record-keeping requirements. Disputes over compliance led to a suspension and, later, probation. Kelly contends that the Board and its staff discriminated against him because of race and disability; they dispute his account. Instead of obtaining state-court review of those disciplinary decisions, Kelly brought a federal civil-rights suit. The district court dismissed it under claim preclusion, also called res judicata: the principle that a matter cannot be litigated again after a binding final decision. That sets up the central disagreement. Does Arizona law bar a later suit only when it relies on the same evidence as the earlier proceeding, or more broadly when it grows out of the same underlying events?
For review: 1. Iraq has reached a compromise with the powerful Iran-backed militia Kataeb Hezbollah, three senior security officials said, after Prime Minister Ali al-Zaidi readied security forces to move against the group. Reflecting the gravity of the situation, Iraqi Shiite political sources said Esmail Qaani, commander of Iran’s elite Revolutionary Guards’ Quds Force, arrived in Baghdad late on Monday to help defuse tensions with Kataeb Hezbollah, Tehran’s most powerful militia ally in Iraq. 2. Lebanese President Joseph Aoun launched a lengthy rebuke of Iran in an Independence Day address, arguing that the Islamic Republic does not have the right to interfere in Lebanon’s internal affairs, as it long has via support for its local terror proxy, Hezbollah. 3. Yemen’s Houthis launched strikes on the Saudi capital Riyadh on Saturday, after vowing reprisals for a “special operation” by the Saudi-led coalition fighting them. The coalition later said it had “intercepted and destroyed” thr
2014 GANYMEDE CONTENTS JOHN BATCHELOR SHOW 11-20-2026 California Storms Train Robberies City Politics — Part One Jeff Bliss reports that severe Pacific storms are dumping heavy snow across Lake Tahoe while driving massive coastal surges against the sand berms protecting beaches. Meanwhile, Los Angeles Mayor-elect Nithya Raman faces mounting criticism over thousands of missed votes, and police have apprehended a gang that stole twenty million dollars in goods from moving freight trains. (1) Beatles Vegas Historic Atomic Tests Formula — Part Two Jeff Bliss recalls how, in August 1964, the Beatles transformed Las Vegas entertainment by moving from the small Congo Room to the Convention Center for sixteen thousand fans. Archival footage from 1957 shows unwitting spectators on Fremont Street watching atmospheric nuclear tests, while today's Las Vegas hosts thrilling Formula Oneraces. (2) Iranian Conflict Regime Change War Powers — Part One Richard Epstein analyzes the military clashes betwe
Megyn Kelly is joined by Mark Geragos, co-host of In The Well, Ashleigh Merchant, co-host of The MK True Crime Show, and Viva Frei, Rumble creator and former litigator, to discuss exactly how Russell Brand was railroaded by the UK legal system, the effort by politicians to censor and silence him, Meghan Markle’s father Thomas ruled competent to stand trial, why he still may not make it to trial on the alarming CSAM charges against him, why prosecutors are attempting to try the 15-year-old son of Kim Zolciak and Kroy Biermann as an adult, the inside story about the disturbing charges he previously faced in juvenile court, how one top MIT scientist won his defamation case against his female colleague who he had a relationship with, the way she tried to spin the consensual relationship into a "MeToo" type situation, the shocking deposition video and text messages released showing what was really going on, the looksmaxxing influencer Clavicular being charged with r*pe, additional context a
In a historic ruling this week, the International Court of Justice determined that Myanmar committed genocide against the Rohingya people. At least 10,000 people were killed, and a million more were forced to flee their communities when Myanmar's security forces and local militias launched attacks in 2017. But how much power does the court have to enforce its ruling? And what implications does the decision have for South Africa's pending case against Israel?
Iowa State football suffers a disappointing 48-17 loss to UCF in Orlando, and the Cyclones have plenty to figure out before Farmageddon. Emery Songer, Ben Bruns, and Chris Williams break down what went wrong, including four turnovers, defensive struggles against a mobile quarterback, and missed opportunities that kept Iowa State from staying competitive. The guys discuss the importance of playing with a lead, Iowa State's struggles on the road, the overturned Aiden Flora first-down call, and the lack of transparency surrounding Big 12 officiating. Chris Williams also puts the loss into perspective, explaining why he still views Jimmy Rogers' first season as a success despite the frustrating result. Plus, Aiden Flora's All-American and Heisman potential, the improvement of Iowa State's offensive line, and why next week's matchup with Kansas State is such an important opportunity for the Cyclones to become bowl-eligible. Presented by Fareway Meat & Grocery.
Doing business may mean doing risky business when it comes to sharing data. But consumers may not realize or notice the cost of paying for practices like price discrimination with their data. In this week's episode of Proof Over Precedent, NYU Law Professor Oren Bar-Gill discusses how consumer misperceptions and inattention support the status quo of complexity amid consumer contracts. He also shares the surprising role AI could play in supporting consumers, though not without backlash.
How to lose public trust in a few easy steps: Take a trusted branch of government, give it the heady authority to maintain independence apart from public oversight, and limit access to records that would offer accountability. The lack of transparency would crack the foundation of any well-intentioned agency. This week's Proof Over Precedent episode addresses the state of the judiciary that has led to a decline in public trust and a call for stronger transparency requirements.
Workers should retain the right to strike even when a dispute inconveniences the public.
Share your view, then see how readers voted. No sign-in required. This poll is shared across stories.
Do you agree or disagree?
Common Quandary
A Common Quandary to discuss
Another conversation to explore, separate from this news story.
Your ex's streaming password still works. When does borrowing become stealing?
Months after a friendly breakup, your television remains logged into your ex's streaming account. They have never mentioned it, the service allows several screens, and your viewing does not increase their monthly bill.
Can silence count as permission when asking might end the benefit?