New Zealand Edition (4 November 2026)

Listen through the publisher, then discuss the episode here or arrange an in-person Roundtable. Your city determines where to meet.
Roundtables are designed for groups of four, with a shared subject and room for everyone to speak. Come for discussion, with no dating expectation.
The Petal's New Zealand edition for Wednesday 4 November 2026 carries 8 decisions newly reported from the Supreme Court and the High Court. Seven are aired, as six items. The thread is the gap between a wish and a promise: matching wills that carried a hope rather than a binding agreement, an equal share that met a parent's duty whatever one child hoped for, a settlor's wish read as care, and counter-intuitive evidence that explains how children respond without proving what happened. Commercial Law Desk (lead). Perpetual Guardian Trustee Holdings Ltd v Meersma [2026] NZHC 3009 - wills made before 1 November 2007 fall under the equitable doctrine of mutual wills, not s 30 of the Wills Act 2007; a constructive trust needs corresponding wills and an agreement, intended to bind each testator, not to revoke, proved on the balance of probabilities with very great care; an honourable understanding or mutual expectation is not enough, and the absence of any written agreement despite legal advice, with a later inconsistent will through the same solicitor, told against one. On capacity, the propounder bears the onus once it is a tenable issue; a retrospective expert opinion weighs less than a contemporaneous assessment; recall of earlier wills is not a standalone requirement; capacity is task-specific; the third Banks v Goodfellow limb asks whether the will-maker could appreciate claims, not whether she gave effect to them. Claim dismissed (Gardiner J, 2 October 2026). JADE (https://jade.io/article/1294351) Lewis v Lewis [2026] NZHC 2854 - under s 4(1) of the Family Protection Act 1955, half of two substantial estates was adequate provision for an adult child, and the equal division could not be impugned; the lack of a mechanism to buy the family property at registered valuation was not a failure of proper support; properly understood the claim challenged the testators' inferred intention, for which the Act is not the vehicle. Obiter, the jurisdiction is not solely financial and a right of first refusal may suit a future case. Claim dismissed (Harland J, 17 September 2026). JADE (https://jade.io/article/1294350) Practice and Procedure Desk. Stockman Family Trustee Limited v Stockman [2026] NZHC 3182 - the Court may bless a trustee's momentous decision under s 133 of the Trusts Act 2019 on full disclosure, asking whether the trustee could properly form its view, not substituting its own; a beneficiary's preferred agent's higher figure did not show a breach of s 26(a); unsupported allegations of conflict and an uninvoked duress claim did not warrant withholding approval; termination of both trusts approved under s 124 for future and unascertained beneficiaries (Tantrum J, 15 October 2026). JADE (https://jade.io/article/1294352) Affco New Zealand Ltd v Meat Masters Ltd [2026] NZHC 3297 - leave to appeal an interlocutory decision under s 56(3) of the Senior Courts Act 2016 is a high-threshold filter, granted only where the significance of an arguable error warrants delaying the case; applications dismissed; the liquidation proceeding continues (Jagose J, 23 October 2026). JADE (https://jade.io/article/1294353) Criminal Law Desk. R v M [2026] NZHC 3425 and R v M [2026] NZHC 3426 - reported as legal doctrine only; suppression orders apply. Two sentencings for manslaughter by omission: mental health may in rare cases reduce the starting point itself where it alters the character of the offending; there is no presumption for or against home detention, which calls for a considered and principled choice of the least restrictive sentence; special conditions under s 80D(2) of the Sentencing Act 2002 need a significant risk of further offending; halving the term is common but not required; extreme hardship needs more than the ordinary consequences of conviction, and suppression may be needed under s 200(2)(f) of the Criminal Procedure Act 2011 to protect a co-defendant's order. Home detention in both (Heine J, 23 October 2026). JADE (NZHC 3425) (https://jade.io/article/1294354) JADE (NZHC 3426) (https://jade.io/article/1294355) Tovey v The King [2026] NZSC 167 - reported as legal doctrine only. Probabilistic references in a s 9 statement of admitted facts on counter-intuitive evidence did not create an appearance of miscarriage where the statement set out the limits of the research; a closing that could be taken as suggesting complainants were more likely truthful because they behaved as described was cured by directions that the evidence was educative only; the omitted DH v R caution was not material. Leave dismissed (Ellen France, Williams and Kós JJ, 4 November 2026). JADE (https://jade.io/article/1294248) R v M and Tovey are reported as legal doctrine only, with no one identified. The liquidation proceeding in Affco and the remaining steps in Stockman continue. Nothing in this episode predicts any outcome. Also in the edition, not aired: Hu v Xu [2026] NZHC 2756, an unopposed summary judgment against a guarantor on the settled test (Associate Judge Wild). JADE (https://jade.io/article/1294349) Theme music by Michael Green SC.
Episode information is provided by the publisher. Listening takes place on the publisher’s service.
Listen at the source ↗










