A 2026 network meta-analysis ranked collagen ahead of whey protein for muscle and strength. Dr. Jordan Feigenbaum revisits Episode 250 to explain how that ranking was built and why he doesn't buy its 7-pound fat-free mass estimate, which is bigger than what either trial behind it found. Along the way he covers what collagen is missing as a protein, the trials that put collagen and whey head to head, and the tendon and joint pain trials. Then there's the case for why it should work: glycine, and a collagen fragment called Pro-Hyp that shows up in your blood after a dose. On skin, the hydration readings come from a probe that only reads the outermost layer, and a 2026 audit found errors in the skin meta-analyses. The nail evidence goes back to a gelatin paper from the 1950s. Collagen is real protein and it counts toward your daily target. It costs more and does less than whey, and the claims go well past what the evidence shows. Timestamps 00:00 What's new on collagen since Episode 250 0
Andrew Huberman’s new book, Protocols, says each of its routines “can work the first time, and every time,” and says of its lifting program, “I’ve seen it work for everyone I’ve suggested it to.” Wild! Dr. Feigenbaum read the book and pulled the studies it cites for the protocols that crossover with Barbell Medicine: training each muscle once a week to failure, cold plunges, pushing morning cortisol up with licorice root and grapefruit, drinking water on a schedule, an 11-supplement sleep stack, and nicotine pouches for focus. Dr. Baraki guesses what the book recommends before we get to what the cited studies found. In a few places the paper under the sentence says the opposite of the sentence. It should go without saying, nothing here is about Dr. Huberman personally. We’re rating what the book tells you to do. Timestamps 00:00 Huberman’s Protocols and what it promises 01:23 Who this book is for, and how a book like this gets made 07:30 The games, and training each muscle once a week
A 22 year old soccer player with no symptoms walks into a clinic for a routine sports physical and walks out being told to quit his sport. Dr. Baraki takes this mystery case blind and we hand him the pieces one at a time: the EKG, the echocardiogram, the cardiac MRI, the Holter monitor, the treadmill test and the genetic panel. Half of them come back completely normal. Play along and commit to an answer before the reveal, because there is a point in this case where most people would change theirs. Then, the discussion about whether the restriction he was given was the right call, what the evidence on that says today compared with what it said for the previous 40 years, and why two doctors looking at the same numbers can reasonably land in different places. And then screening. Should an EKG should be mandatory for amateur athletes? All this and more, on this episode of the Barbell Medicine Podcast. Timestamps 00:00 A 22-year-old needs a form signed 02:16 The history and exam 05:49 Readi