The Supreme Court considers who must pay a landowner's legal costs when a private pipeline company uses federal power to take property rights. W B I Energy Transmission went to federal court to obtain a right of way across North Dakota land for a natural-gas pipeline. After years of litigation, the company and landowners settled the value of that right of way, but left the owners' legal fees unresolved. A federal district judge awarded the owners those fees under North Dakota law; the Eighth Circuit set that award aside, applying the federal compensation standard instead. The landowners will argue that giving a private company power to take property does not erase state-law protections governing what owners are paid. The company, supported here by the federal government, will argue that it received the federal taking power together with the federal compensation rule, which ordinarily excludes legal fees. Listen for the difference between the constitutional minimum paid for property and
The Seventh Circuit hears Mason's appeal from federal gun and drug convictions arising from a search of a Madison bedroom. Police were investigating a violent incident and went to an address linked to Mason, who was on supervision. In the bedroom, they found a gun and drugs; a laboratory later detected his DNA on the gun and drug packaging. The dispute brings together two questions: what allowed police to enter and search that room, and whether the items they found proved that he possessed them. USA v. Jeramie J. Mason (No. 25-2701) — U.S. Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit, argued November 9, 2026. Sources: Argument audio — official Seventh Circuit recording, November 9, 2026; original court audio, with ordinary final normalization and peak protection only: Independent case account — U.S. Attorney’s Office, Western District of Wisconsin, September 24, 2025:
The Federal Circuit hears a patent battle between Natera and Care D X over blood tests used to monitor organ transplants. Natera accused Care D X of using its patented methods for measuring small amounts of one person's DNA mixed with another's. A jury found one Natera patent infringed and awarded about ninety-six million dollars in damages. The judge later invalidated the asserted claims in both patents at trial because their written descriptions did not adequately disclose the claimed inventions. Natera will argue that the jury had enough evidence to find the inventions disclosed; Care D X will argue that listing separate pieces does not describe the combined method. Two different questions will recur: whether the patent described the claimed combination, and whether DNA-analysis methods qualify for patent protection at all. Natera, Inc. v. CareDx, Inc. (No. 24-1894) — U.S. Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit, argued November 9, 2026. Sources: Argument audio — official Federal C
The Federal Circuit hears a patent dispute between Never-Search and Google, Apple, and Microsoft over interactive digital maps. Never-Search sued the companies, claiming that their mapping products infringed its patents. The patents describe features such as updating information about places, moving icons on a map, and displaying information about selected locations. The appeal follows a district judge's decision to dismiss the patent claims as ineligible for protection. Never-Search will argue that these are concrete improvements to digital mapping, while the companies will defend the ruling that the claims merely computerize familiar information-handling tasks. Listen also for whether the judge could treat a few patent claims as representative of others with additional features. Never-Search, Inc. v. Google LLC (No. 25-1585) — U.S. Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit, argued November 9, 2026. Sources: Argument audio — official Federal Circuit recording, November 9, 2026; complet
The Second Circuit considers a father's effort to avoid removal to El Salvador because of the hardship to his children. An immigration judge denied his request, concluding that the hardship did not meet the demanding legal threshold. During his agency appeal, he submitted new evidence about his children's mental health and asked for the case to return to the judge. The immigration appeals board declined, saying he had not shown that his children would be unable to obtain treatment in El Salvador. He will argue that the board improperly assessed that new evidence instead of sending the case back for another hearing. Listen for the difference between care being limited and care being unavailable, and for the limits on what federal judges can review. Diaz v. Blanche (No. 25-2880) — U.S. Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit, argued October 19, 2026. Sources: Argument audio — official Second Circuit recording, October 19, 2026; complete source with slow volume balancing and peak headroom
The Court of Appeals for the Armed Forces hears United States versus Askins, a case involving stolen military explosives and domestic violence. Askins was an Army explosives-disposal technician in Alaska who admitted taking military C-four. Prosecutors brought charges years later, and he pleaded guilty to the theft as part of a broader court-martial. He contested separate charges involving an attack on his wife after she asked for a separation. Trial testimony described him assaulting her by a dog kennel, then attacking her again near the back door as she tried to leave. The Army appeals court upheld the theft conviction but combined two of the domestic-violence convictions into one. Askins will argue that the theft prosecution exceeded the ordinary five-year deadline, and that he never knowingly gave up the right to invoke it. The government will rely on a wartime exception that suspends that deadline, pointing to American operations in Afghanistan. It will also seek to restore the se
The Court of Appeals for the Armed Forces examines a Navy sailor's sexual-assault conviction. Trial testimony described a friend finding him with an apparently unconscious woman on a barracks-elevator floor after an evening of drinking. Prosecutors charged the same encounter in two ways: a sexual act without consent, and a sexual act with someone too intoxicated to consent. A court-martial panel found him guilty under both theories. The trial judge conditionally set aside the intoxication-based finding, and the panel sentenced him only on the other. The Navy-Marine Corps appeals court later set aside that remaining conviction, reinstated the dismissed one, and reassessed the sentence. This argument asks whether the trial instructions improperly blurred the two theories, and whether appellate judges could determine punishment for a charge that had never received a sentence. United States v. Anthony D. Grafton (No. 26-0039/NA) — United States Court of Appeals for the Armed Forces, argued
The Fifth Circuit considers a gun-possession conviction involving a man with prior drunk-driving convictions. The case began with his own call to police: he said he was hearing voices urging violence at schools. Deputies removed guns from his home. His earlier drunk-driving record included a felony conviction. He later pleaded guilty in federal court and is now appealing his firearm conviction under the Second Amendment. Federal law generally prohibits gun possession by someone convicted of a crime punishable by more than a year in prison. The question here is whether applying that restriction to this defendant is constitutional. Drunk driving can plainly put lives at risk. But an older Supreme Court case the lawyers will discuss distinguished that danger from purposeful violence under a different sentencing law. Listen for whether that distinction carries over to gun rights, how the judges assess the historical laws each side offers, and which facts about this man's record they may co
The Federal Circuit hears a dispute about the right to bring a touchscreen patent lawsuit. UUSI, doing business as Nartron, sued Samsung, alleging that certain Samsung tablets infringed its patent on electronic switching circuitry used in touchscreens. The complaint asserted that UUSI owned all rights in the patent and could recover damages for infringement. But Samsung challenged whether UUSI had acquired the patent interest needed to sue. The district court dismissed the case because it found that UUSI had no interest in the patent when the lawsuit began. That is the ruling behind this argument. The dispute therefore concerns who held the patent rights, rather than simply whether the accused tablets used the claimed technology. You will hear UUSI seek to overturn that dismissal and Samsung defend it. Keep the original infringement allegation separate from the ownership question: claiming that a product uses patented technology does not, by itself, resolve whether the person bringing
The Eleventh Circuit hears a civil-rights case arising from Justin Tolston's arrest at the Atlanta Pride Festival in Piedmont Park. Tolston says he was walking with an electric scooter and a beer when he accidentally bumped into a police officer and apologized. He says that officer poured out his drink, and another officer, Keith Wadsworth, then took him to the ground. Tolston describes himself as calm and not resisting; the officers gave a different account of an intoxicated, disorderly encounter. He sued the city and police officials over the arrest and use of force. The district court allowed false-arrest and excessive-force claims against Wadsworth to proceed because important facts were disputed. That ruling did not decide whose account was true or finally determine that the officer was liable. Wadsworth's lawyer will press a cross-appeal seeking qualified immunity, arguing that a reasonable officer could have viewed the circumstances as justifying the arrest and force even under
The Second Circuit hears Curt Herrera's challenge to the refusal to reconsider his sentence after one of his firearm convictions was vacated. Herrera was convicted for his role in a racketeering organization involved in robbery, kidnapping, murder and drug trafficking. His punishment included multiple life terms, plus additional prison terms for using firearms in connection with crimes of violence. He later challenged five firearm convictions under Supreme Court decisions about what qualifies as a crime of violence. The district court vacated one count with the government's agreement, but did not conduct a new sentencing hearing or decide the remaining four challenges on their merits. Its reasoning was that separate life sentences would keep Herrera in prison regardless, without meaningful additional consequences from the disputed convictions. This is an application of the concurrent sentence doctrine, even though these firearm terms were to run after his life terms. Herrera's lawyer w
The Federal Circuit hears a patent dispute about when treatment with colchicine begins after a heart attack, and whether it starts without a larger initial dose. The Montreal Heart Institute owns a patent covering early low-dose treatment, including claims that specify starting within about three days without that initial loading dose. Murray and Poole challenged the patent at the Patent Trial and Appeal Board. The Board found the challenged claims unpatentable, relying on earlier patent and clinical-trial materials. The institute is now appealing. One important reference is an earlier patent known as Nidorf; another is a summary of the COLCOT trial protocol. The parties disagree over whether those documents actually disclose treatment without a loading dose, or merely fail to discuss the subject. The institute's lawyer will argue that the Board treated silence as disclosure and wrongly required the patent owner to prove that the earlier treatment included a loading dose. Murray and Po
The Eleventh Circuit hears a dispute over damages after Jesse Anderson's death following treatment at the Atlanta VA Medical Center. The trial court's agreed facts describe a feeding tube, needed after surgery, being inserted into his airway during replacement. He suffered oxygen deprivation and died two days later. His son Webb and his estate pursued claims against the United States, which ultimately admitted liability. After a trial, the judge awarded six million dollars for wrongful death and two point seven million dollars for his pain and suffering before death. The government's appeal is narrower than that tragic history: it is not challenging the pain-and-suffering award or the discovery sanctions imposed against it. It challenges the six-million-dollar wrongful-death award because the family's original administrative claim sought three million dollars for that claim. The Federal Tort Claims Act ordinarily limits recovery to the amount presented to the agency. It allows exceptio
The Federal Circuit hears a dispute over who owns the Vivace brand. A South Korean manufacturer known as Shen B developed the radio-frequency microneedling device and sent branded units to the United States for testing and promotion. Aesthetics Biomedical became its exclusive American distributor in 2016, paid for advertising, marketed the devices, and became a point of contact for customers. It also obtained a federal registration for Vivace. The manufacturer later asked the Trademark Trial and Appeal Board to cancel that registration, asserting that the brand belonged to it, not its distributor. The Board agreed, finding that the manufacturer's earlier American use established ownership and that Aesthetics Biomedical did not own the mark when it applied to register it. Aesthetics Biomedical is now appealing. The central question is how to determine trademark ownership between a manufacturer and its exclusive distributor when their agreement does not expressly settle that question. Th
The Federal Circuit hears Corrigent's patent dispute with Cisco. Corrigent sued Cisco, alleging that Cisco's communications equipment infringed its patents on packet forwarding and hidden-failure detection. An idle connection can fail without disrupting current traffic, leaving the problem unnoticed until that connection is needed. The appeal has three distinct branches. First, the four-hundred patent concerns packet forwarding and address checking. Corrigent will argue that the trial court wrongly required certain steps to happen in a fixed order, excluding checks performed when a packet enters the system. Cisco will argue that the claim language requires the relevant checks on the outgoing side, which its accused products do not perform. Second, the three-sixty-nine patent concerns testing idle connections for hidden faults. The district court held the asserted claims patent-ineligible, treating them as an abstract test-and-report idea implemented with generic components. Corrigent w
The Seventh Circuit hears a dispute over a hotel operating license in Indianapolis. Patel and his company, P M K Corporation, operate the Budget Eight Inn. In February 2023, city officials refused to renew the hotel's license amid public-safety concerns, including emergency-service calls at the property. Patel disputes the city's account. For roughly five weeks, the hotel could not rent rooms to new guests, though it did not stop operating altogether. Permission to accept new guests was later restored while the licensing challenge continued. Patel and the company sued, and a federal court initially kept the hotel open while the case proceeded. The district court later ruled against them, concluding that the hotel license and its renewal were not constitutionally protected property interests. This appeal focuses on procedural due process: before deciding whether the government's procedures were adequate, the judges must decide whether there was a protected property interest to begin wit
The Federal Circuit hears a dispute over a liquid-medicine formulation. Genexa holds a patent covering formulations that combine acetaminophen, agave syrup, and a diluent such as water. The agave provides sweetness, while the claims also specify the viscosity, or thickness, of the finished mixture. KinderFarms challenged the patent before the Patent Trial and Appeal Board. In March 2025, the Board found the challenged claims unpatentable as obvious. It reasoned that earlier references describing sweetened liquid medicines could be combined to produce the claimed formulations. Genexa is now appealing that decision. The question is not simply whether each ingredient was already known, but whether the challenge adequately explained why a skilled formulator would combine the earlier teachings to make the claimed mixture. Genexa's lawyer will argue that KinderFarms pointed to particular recipes but did not explain the modifications needed to reach the claimed thickness, leaving the Board to
The D.C. Circuit considers years-long delays in special immigrant visa applications from Afghan and Iraqi allies. These programs offer a route to resettlement for people whose work supporting the United States exposed them to serious threats. The applicants who brought this lawsuit said they had served the United States, faced danger because of that work, and waited years without final decisions. They sued the State Department and Homeland Security in 2018, seeking decisions for themselves and a larger group of applicants. A district judge found unreasonable delay in 2019 and required a plan to move applications through the process. After further litigation, the judge adopted a revised plan in 2025, retaining processing benchmarks and progress reports. The government is now appealing. Importantly, ordering a decision is not the same as ordering a visa to be approved. Applicants still have to establish eligibility and pass the required screening. Congress set a nine-month processing ben
The First Circuit hears a dispute over deposits left behind when two real-estate deals fell apart. Two buyers, Dorado Gardens and Dorado Park, agreed to buy two properties and placed their deposits in escrow, so a third party held the money while the deals were pending. They later terminated the agreements and sued to get their deposits back. Under the contracts, the buyers' wrongful termination would give the sellers the entire deposit. At trial, the judge dismissed the buyers' own claims, and the jury found that they had improperly terminated the agreements. The jury awarded the sellers seventy percent from the deposit. The trial judge later changed that to the full deposit, reasoning that the contracts required one hundred percent once the buyers were found liable. The buyers' lawyer will argue that the jury had been invited to decide the amount and that the judge could not replace its answer. The sellers' lawyer will argue that the judge simply enforced a fixed contractual conseque
The Federal Circuit hears a veteran's challenge to the denial of benefits for claimed ear-drum injuries and hearing loss. Surratt links those problems to injuries during military service. A 2022 physical examination found that his ear drums appeared normal, but hearing testing could not be performed because he was incarcerated. The Board of Veterans' Appeals denied his claim because it found that he had not shown a current ear or hearing-loss disability qualifying for benefits. The Veterans Court upheld that decision, saying the absence of a current disability made the combat presumption unnecessary. That rule eases the proof of injuries or diseases incurred in combat when official records may be missing. Surratt's lawyer will argue that the Board should first consider his own account to decide whether he developed a hearing disability during service, then determine whether it continued to the present. He will ask for the case to be sent back for those findings. The government's lawyer
The Fifth Circuit hears a race-discrimination and retaliation case brought by Tim Gooden, a longtime Black truck driver. Gooden says he proposed additional work that could have meant more hours and experience, but the opportunities went to White employees. He also says he was disciplined and later fired after complaining of discrimination. The company says it disciplined him over unauthorized breaks and later fired him for his conduct during a safety-related confrontation. The district court entered judgment for the company without a trial. On the extra assignments, it viewed the work as additional duties rather than a separate job or promotion, and found no actionable job-related harm. Gooden's lawyer will argue that disputed evidence and the timing of his dismissal should have gone to a jury. The Equal Employment Opportunity Commission will focus on the denied work assignments. It will argue that losing a chance for better duties, hours, or advancement can be job-related harm, even w
The Seventh Circuit hears a prisoner's claim that the warden failed to protect him from other inmates. Blaze Downey reported gang threats and repeatedly asked for protective custody. After an assault, his attorney warned prison staff that other prisoners planned to follow him to a new dormitory and harm him. The prison moved him to another unit, but he was attacked again. Downey sued the warden, who maintains that staff investigated the warnings and that the moves were a reasonable response. The district court entered judgment for the warden without a trial, concluding that the earlier request did not establish knowledge of a specific threat and that the response to the later warning did not show deliberate indifference. That means consciously disregarding a known serious risk, not simply making a poor judgment. Downey's lawyer will argue that the court considered too narrow a record and that a jury should decide what the warden knew and whether he actually responded. The warden's lawy
The Second Circuit hears an appeal by buyers of New York City taxi medallions, the permits needed to operate yellow cabs. The buyers allege that city officials promoted medallions as a sound investment while publishing misleading prices and allowing collusive bidding. They say this induced them to overpay for medallions and caused substantial financial losses. They sued under RICO, the federal racketeering law. These are allegations, not findings that the city committed fraud. The district court initially dismissed the claims as too late. On reconsideration, some claims survived that timing ruling, but the court still rejected the requested monetary relief. The buyers seek three times their losses, or an order requiring the city to surrender money it allegedly gained. Their lawyer will argue that RICO permits monetary relief against a municipality. The city will defend its immunity from the requested damages and argue that the claims are time-barred. Listen for two threshold questions:
The Seventh Circuit hears a tax dispute involving the Presta family's grocery businesses and an insurance company they owned. The businesses paid premiums to that company, CFM, for coverage of business risks and deducted those payments on their tax returns. The arrangement was designed to use tax benefits available to small insurance companies. But the IRS said it did not qualify as insurance for federal tax purposes. The Tax Court agreed, pointing to problems with how policies were issued and claims were handled, even though the company was licensed in Utah. That left the businesses without their deductions, while CFM still had to count the payments it received as taxable income. The taxpayers' lawyer will argue that the court used the wrong test for insurance and failed to give proper weight to Utah's approval. She will also argue that rejecting the insurance treatment should not leave both sides of the transaction taxed this way. The government will defend the distinction between a