English-language podcasts

Podcasts

Oral Arguments, with Context

An episode can be the start of a conversation. Explore recent releases, share your thoughts, and meet through a ThinkMatch Roundtable.

Ask friends about this

Episodes to discuss

Oral Arguments, with Context

Suiza Dairy, Inc. v Gonzalez-Beiro — 1st Cir. (Nov 6, 2026)

35 min

The First Circuit considers a dispute over who can enforce a settlement in Puerto Rico's milk industry. Two milk processors, including Suiza Dairy, challenged the government's milk-pricing system in federal court. The regulations affected both the cost of buying raw milk from farmers and the price processors could charge. A 2013 settlement ended the lawsuit and required changes to that system. The judge kept authority to enforce the agreement, but the judgment referred both to four consecutive years of compliance and to December thirty-first, twenty-seventeen. Years later, Suiza returned to federal court alleging violations and seeking contempt sanctions. The district court denied that request because it read the judgment as ending federal enforcement authority in 2017. Suiza's lawyer will argue that the four-year compliance condition was never satisfied, so that authority remains. The government and an intervening company will argue that the written end date controls. Listen for wheth

Discuss this episode

Oral Arguments, with Context

USA v. Donovan Alexander — 7th Cir. (Nov 6, 2026)

25 min

The Seventh Circuit hears a sentencing appeal in a case about the commercial sexual exploitation of a minor. Prosecutors accused Donovan Alexander of trafficking a minor girl and transporting her for that purpose. This appeal focuses on a separate sentencing adjustment for undue influence. The judge applied a two-level increase. Under the guideline commentary, an age difference of at least ten years creates a presumption of undue influence, but that presumption can be challenged and the court must consider the facts of the case. Alexander's lawyer will argue that the judge did not adequately consider the evidence offered to challenge that presumption. The government will defend the judge's assessment and argue that the adjustment did not change the advisory sentencing range. Listen for how the panel separates the guideline's starting presumption from the individual finding the judge must make. USA v. Donovan Alexander (No. 25-2644) — U.S. Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit, argue

Discuss this episode

Oral Arguments, with Context

US v Almestica-Monge — 1st Cir. (Nov 6, 2026)

36 min

The First Circuit hears an appeal from drug-conspiracy and firearm convictions in Puerto Rico. Prosecutors described a network selling drugs in several municipalities, with members supplying firearms and protecting the operation. A jury found the defendant guilty of participating in the conspiracy and possessing a gun in furtherance of drug trafficking. At trial, the jury also learned about a separate gun conviction from 2018, four years after the charged conspiracy ended. The judge allowed that evidence to show knowledge and intent, with an instruction limiting its use. The defense will contend that this invited the jury to infer guilt from another crime. The government will defend the evidence as relevant to the charged offenses. Listen for the distinction between proving participation in this drug operation and treating other wrongdoing as proof of guilt. US v Almestica-Monge (No. 24-1345) — U.S. Court of Appeals for the First Circuit, argued November 6, 2026. Sources: Argument audi

Discuss this episode

Oral Arguments, with Context

Icon International, Inc. v. Elevation Health LLC — 2d Cir. (Nov 6, 2026)

40 min

The Second Circuit hears Icon International versus Elevation Health, a dispute over COVID-19 test kits. Elevation prepaid for an order that arrived more than a month late. Icon then delivered another shipment and sued for the unpaid price. Elevation said it had not authorized that second order and had rejected both deliveries because of problems including lateness, short expiration dates and missing documentation. It wanted its earlier payment back. A jury ruled against Icon's payment claim and awarded Elevation contract and fraud damages. The trial judge refused to set the verdict aside or order a new trial. Icon will challenge whether the evidence legally permitted that result and whether opposing counsel's trial statements prejudiced the jury. Elevation will defend its verdict and seek to make Icon and another company each responsible for the full contract award, rather than separate shares, along with additional interest. The argument turns on when a buyer's actions count as accept

Discuss this episode

Oral Arguments, with Context

Southern Cross Seafoods, LLC, Appellant v. United States, et al. — 11th Cir. (Nov 6, 2026)

36 min

The Eleventh Circuit hears Southern Cross Seafoods versus the United States, a dispute over a shipment of Chilean sea bass. In 2022, the importer sought federal approval to bring in fish caught around South Georgia. An international commission normally set seasonal catch limits there by consensus. But Russia blocked agreement on the limit for that season. The National Marine Fisheries Service rejected the import application, treating the absence of an agreed limit as making the harvest unauthorized. Southern Cross challenged that refusal, but the district court ruled for the government. The company will argue that no applicable conservation measure actually prohibited the catch, so the missing limit cannot justify rejecting its import. The government will argue that the existing rules required an agreed limit and must be read in light of the treaty's conservation purpose. The question is what happens when that consensus system breaks down: does the lack of a limit leave fishing permitt

Discuss this episode

Oral Arguments, with Context

Brendan Wagner, Appellant v. U.S. Attorney General — 11th Cir. (Nov 5, 2026)

36 min

The Eleventh Circuit considers how Brendan Wagner can seek an end to his federal sex-offender registration requirement. His conviction came before Congress enacted SORNA, the federal registration law, so his original sentence did not assign him one of its registration tiers. Those tiers determine how long registration lasts. Wagner says he belongs in the lowest tier and has maintained the clean record needed for an earlier end to registration. He first asked the court that sentenced him for relief, but it said it lacked jurisdiction in his closed criminal case. He then sued the Attorney General, arguing that no administrative process had been provided to determine his tier and apply the reduction. The district court dismissed that civil suit without deciding his tier. This appeal concerns whether the Administrative Procedure Act lets a court compel the Attorney General to provide such a process. It is important to separate access to a process from the ultimate question of whether Wagne

Discuss this episode

Oral Arguments, with Context

Children of the Court v. Abbey Fishman Romanek — 7th Cir. (Nov 6, 2026)

30 min

The Seventh Circuit considers a lawsuit over access to a state family-court hearing. Conor Paris and the nonprofit Children of the Court say a judge barred him from a Zoom hearing involving his parents' post-divorce case, even though other members of the public were allowed to attend. They say the organization's director was later excluded as well. They sued in federal court, claiming a violation of the First Amendment right of access. The district court dismissed their claims, relying in part on judicial immunity, which generally protects judges from damages suits for their judicial acts. It also found too little alleged personal involvement by the chief judge. The appeal asks whether excluding a spectator was a protected judicial decision or an administrative act. It also raises a separate question: should the federal courts step back from intervening in how state courts run their proceedings? That issue is called abstention. Listen for the distinction between whether the exclusion w

Discuss this episode

Oral Arguments, with Context

United States v. Renardo Turner, Appellant — 11th Cir. (Nov 5, 2026)

38 min

The Eleventh Circuit hears Renardo Turner's challenge to a prison sentence imposed after his supervised release was revoked. Supervised release is a period of community supervision under court-ordered conditions. The district court found that Turner violated those conditions, revoked his supervision, and ordered him back to prison. This is not a retrial of his original criminal charge. The dispute concerns what a judge may seek to accomplish when choosing the prison term for a supervision violation. The Supreme Court has ruled that revocation cannot be used to impose more punishment for the original crime. But it left open a related question about sanctions for breaching the court's trust. Listen for the distinction between punishing the original crime, sanctioning a supervision violation, and using a sentence to deter future misconduct or protect the public. United States v. Renardo Turner, Appellant (No. 25-13867) — U.S. Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit, argued November 5, 2

Discuss this episode

Oral Arguments, with Context

Dines v. OCWR — Fed. Cir. (Nov 6, 2026)

28 min

The Federal Circuit hears a former Library of Congress employee's challenge to the rejection of his retaliation claim. The Library fired him, and he alleges that the dismissal was illegal reprisal. After a hearing, the Office of Congressional Workplace Rights ruled for the Library, and its board left that ruling in place. The board concluded that he had not shown the Library's stated non-retaliatory reasons were a cover for reprisal. It also acknowledged that close timing can help an employee make an initial retaliation case, but held that a possible error on that point did not change the result. His lawyer will challenge how the retaliation evidence and hearing procedures were treated. The agency will defend the ruling and argue that some objections were not raised at the proper stage. Listen for the difference between showing that an error occurred and showing that it affected the outcome. Dines v. OCWR (No. 25-1657) — U.S. Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit, argued November 6,

Discuss this episode

Oral Arguments, with Context

United States v. Jose Rivera, Appellant — 11th Cir. (Nov 4, 2026)

27 min

The Eleventh Circuit hears Jose Rivera's challenge to a federal firearms sentence. Rivera ran from a police officer, turned and fired at him during the pursuit. He pleaded guilty to two firearms offenses, but the sentencing dispute centers on whether that shooting should be treated as premeditated attempted murder. A sentencing cross-reference can direct the judge from the firearms guideline to the guideline for another offense connected to the gun. Here, the focus is on the difference between an intent to kill and premeditation. The judges also examine what the sentencing judge actually found, rather than simply what the evidence could have supported. Listen for the distinction between an alleged legal mistake and a challenge to the judge's factual findings. United States v. Jose Rivera, Appellant (No. 24-13106) — U.S. Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit, argued November 4, 2026. Sources: Argument audio — official Eleventh Circuit recording, November 4, 2026; fixed-gain calibrat

Discuss this episode

Oral Arguments, with Context

Todd Smith v. David Shinn — 9th Cir. (Nov 5, 2026)

55 min

The Ninth Circuit hears a death-penalty challenge arising from the robbery and killing of an elderly couple at an Arizona campground. Todd Smith was convicted of two murders and sentenced to death. The sentencing judge considered mental-health evidence but did not find enough mitigation for a life sentence. Smith later claimed his lawyers had failed to investigate and present important evidence of brain damage and prenatal alcohol exposure. The federal district court rejected that sentencing claim, treating the additional evidence as largely cumulative. Much of today's argument concerns whether the federal proceedings should now pause so Smith can present the claim in an Arizona court. That procedure is called stay and abeyance: the federal case remains open while state remedies are pursued. Listen for the distinction between a claim being strong enough for that procedural step and strong enough to overturn a death sentence. Todd Smith v. David Shinn (No. 10-99002) — U.S. Court of Appe

Discuss this episode

Oral Arguments, with Context

US v Och — 1st Cir. (Nov 4, 2026)

23 min

The First Circuit hears the appeal of a Massachusetts psychiatrist convicted of illegally prescribing controlled drugs. The case grew out of prescriptions for Adderall and Xanax issued to undercover officers. The jury convicted him of three drug-distribution counts while acquitting him of other charges. The question running through this argument is where authorized medical care ends and criminal prescribing begins. Federal rules permit registered doctors to prescribe controlled substances for legitimate medical purposes in the usual course of professional practice. Once a doctor produces evidence of authorization, prosecutors must prove beyond a reasonable doubt that he knowingly or intentionally acted outside it. That is more than simply showing that his care fell below professional standards. As you listen, distinguish the medical standard that defines an authorized prescription from what the government must prove about the doctor's state of mind. US v Och (No. 25-1741) — U.S. Court

Discuss this episode

Oral Arguments, with Context

Massapequa Union Free School District v. New York State Board of Regents — 2d Cir. (Nov 6, 2026)

40 min

The Second Circuit hears two linked appeals over New York's restriction on Native American school names, logos, and mascots. Massapequa's school district wants to keep its Chiefs name and logo. It signed an agreement with the Native American Guardian's Association, a private advocacy group, linking support for those symbols to teaching about Native American history and culture. The group also sued. The lower court refused to let the district revive its claims and dismissed the group's lawsuit, largely because of limits on who may sue. Capacity asks whether a public school district may sue the state that created it. Standing asks whether these particular challengers have a concrete injury that a court can remedy. The district will contend that federal-law claims overcome the barrier to its suit. The group will rely on its agreement as a source of injury. The state will argue that neither route works. The central distinction is between opposing the mascot policy and having a legal right

Discuss this episode

Oral Arguments, with Context

Jacob Baxter v. Danny Cheadle — 7th Cir. (Nov 5, 2026)

20 min

The Seventh Circuit considers the firing of an Illinois village police officer who says he was denied a chance to be heard. His department's policy manual referred to state-law dismissal protections, and he claims those protections gave him a legal right to keep his job unless fired for cause. He sued the police chief under federal due-process law. The district court accepted that he had plausibly alleged a protected job interest, but dismissed the damages claim because he had not shown that the chief violated clearly established law. That protection for government officials is called qualified immunity. The officer will argue that his job was protected and the constitutional hearing requirement was already clear. The defense will argue that those protections did not automatically apply to this small village, and the chief should remain shielded from damages. Listen for the difference between the established constitutional rule and whether this village actually adopted the state law th

Discuss this episode

Oral Arguments, with Context

Liberty Mutual Fire Insurance Company v. Ategrity Specialty Insurance Company — 2d Cir. (Nov 6, 2026)

31 min

The Second Circuit considers which of two insurers must pay nearly half a million dollars in legal bills for a crane company. Liberty Mutual paid to defend U.S. Crane and then asked Ategrity to reimburse it. Ategrity insured a different company, New York Crane, but its policy also covered U.S. Crane as an additional insured. The policy included a three hundred fifty thousand dollar self-insured retention, an initial layer of costs for the named policyholder to cover itself. New York Crane had not paid the full amount, and Ategrity said its obligation had not yet begun. The district court ordered Ategrity to reimburse Liberty, concluding that the retention did not apply to U.S. Crane. Ategrity will argue that the policy's coverage limit applies to all insureds, not just the named policyholder. Liberty will argue that a promise to provide primary coverage without contributions from other insurers overrides that retention requirement for additional insureds. A further question is whether

Discuss this episode

Oral Arguments, with Context

Powell v. Collins — Fed. Cir. (Nov 5, 2026)

24 min

The Federal Circuit considers a veteran's effort to obtain about three additional years of disability compensation. The Department of Veterans Affairs granted her payments at the total-disability rate based on inability to work, starting in 2015. She says that issue had already been raised in a 2012 disability claim and should have been addressed then. In 2019, the Board of Veterans' Appeals rejected an earlier start date and found that the older claim had been implicitly denied. It separately referred an allegation of clear and unmistakable error to a regional office. That is a special way to challenge a final agency decision, not an ordinary chance to weigh the evidence again. The later proceedings rejected her challenge, and the Veterans Court treated the 2019 finding as final because she had not appealed it. The veteran will argue that the separate error claim still allowed review of whether the 2012 claim was ever decided. The government will argue that the unappealed 2019 decisio

Discuss this episode

Oral Arguments, with Context

Harvey v. Lhoist North America — 5th Cir. (Nov 5, 2026)

38 min

The Fifth Circuit considers whether a fired worker's race-discrimination and retaliation claims should go to a jury. He worked as a process operator for a lime company. He says a coworker used a racial slur and that other employees received easier assignments or less discipline. He complained to management and human resources. After a series of workplace disputes, the company gave him a final warning following a report of unsafe driving. Days later, it fired him after another reported driving incident, which he disputes. The company says its decisions reflected safety concerns and progressive discipline, not race or retaliation. The worker says those explanations conceal unequal treatment and punishment for speaking up. A federal district court dismissed both claims without a trial. The worker will argue that his testimony, comparisons with other workers and the timing of complaints and discipline create disputes for a jury to resolve. The company will argue that the proposed compariso

Discuss this episode

Oral Arguments, with Context

Silva-Prentice v Kennedy — 1st Cir. (Nov 4, 2026)

24 min

The First Circuit considers a murder conviction against a man who was not one of the shooters. A man was shot and killed inside a Boston apartment building. The petitioner entered shortly after armed companions and fled with the group. Prosecutors relied on surveillance video, witness accounts, gang associations and his movements around the shooting to argue that he acted as a lookout and stood ready to help. The defense says he was an unarmed bystander, not someone who knowingly joined in the shooting. A jury convicted him of second-degree murder. The state appeals court upheld the conviction, and a federal district court denied his request for habeas relief. He is now appealing that denial. This is not a fresh trial. Federal habeas review adds a layer of deference to both the jury and the state court: disagreement with their view of the evidence is not enough. The petitioner will argue that the case rests on unsupported inferences, especially that he knew the others had guns. The sta

Discuss this episode

Oral Arguments, with Context

USA v. Donofrio — 5th Cir. (Nov 3, 2026)

55 min

The Fifth Circuit considers the financial consequences of a healthcare kickback conviction. The defendant ran a company that marketed genetic laboratory tests. Distributors were paid a share of the money laboratories collected for testing, including Medicare reimbursements. Part of the operation redirected patient samples to a different laboratory by changing test-order paperwork without the ordering doctors' knowledge. In an earlier appeal, the court upheld the conspiracy conviction based on that diversion scheme. But it set aside the sentence and forfeiture calculation because they also counted payments whose illegality had not been established. Now the dispute is how much money can properly be counted. One calculation concerns the value of the bribes for sentencing; another concerns criminal proceeds that must be surrendered through forfeiture. The defense will argue that bank transfers alone do not show how much was paid for illegal diversion, and that legitimate marketing payments

Discuss this episode

Oral Arguments, with Context

North America Photon Infotech, Ltd. v Acquia, Inc. — 1st Cir. (Nov 4, 2026)

37 min

The First Circuit considers a dispute over commissions for selling software subscriptions. A digital-services firm partnered with a software vendor to refer customers and help close sales. For one customer, the partner received commissions on an initial sale and an additional purchase, but not on later subscription renewals. The partner sued, claiming the contract entitled it to more money. The district court rejected its renewal-fee claims without a trial and accepted a cap on referral fees contained in terms linked from the agreement. That ruling did not reject every disputed commission claim. The partner will argue that the contract's referral provisions cover later purchases by a qualifying customer, including renewals. It will also challenge whether the vendor has established which version of the linked fee terms was incorporated into the deal. The vendor will argue that referral commissions attach to registered sales opportunities, not an indefinite right to a share of a customer

Discuss this episode

Oral Arguments, with Context

Arbutus Biopharma Corporation v. Moderna, Inc. — Fed. Cir. (Nov 5, 2026)

60 min

The Federal Circuit considers a patent dispute over Moderna's COVID vaccine and a government contract for about five hundred million doses. The patents concern tiny lipid particles that carry genetic material into cells. The patentholders sued Moderna, alleging its vaccine infringed those patents. Moderna answered that the Army had ordered the doses and authorized the use of patented inventions to perform the contract. Under section fourteen ninety-eight, some patent claims involving work for the United States must be brought against the government in the Court of Federal Claims rather than against its contractor. The district court applied that shield to direct infringement claims for doses distributed to government employees, but not doses distributed to the public. The parties settled other disputes while preserving this appeal. Moderna and the United States will argue that a valid government procurement with authorization to use patents is enough, regardless of who ultimately recei

Discuss this episode

Oral Arguments, with Context

Ingenus Pharmaceuticals, LLC v. Nexus Pharmaceuticals, Inc. — Fed. Cir. (Nov 5, 2026)

28 min

The Federal Circuit considers a patent dispute over a liquid formulation of cyclophosphamide, a drug used to treat cancer. The patent owner sued a competing manufacturer, alleging that its injectable product infringed the patent. A federal district court in Illinois ruled the patent invalid because its use of the word stable did not define the protected formulation with reasonable certainty. The patent owner is asking the Federal Circuit to reverse that ruling. The practical problem is knowing which test marks the boundary between the patented formulation and something competitors may make. One claim specifies limits on certain impurities after a week at elevated temperature and humidity. Another independent claim does not repeat those limits, and the patent also describes refrigeration. The patent owner will argue that the accelerated test supplies the controlling standard and that references to refrigeration do not create another claim requirement. The competitor will argue that this

Discuss this episode

Oral Arguments, with Context

Arista Networks, Inc. v. Corrigent Corp. — Fed. Cir. (Nov 5, 2026)

25 min

The Federal Circuit reviews a patent challenge involving the way data travels through a communications network. The patent describes choosing a physical network port for a data path and using a label attached to the packets to identify that port. The challenger asked the Patent Trial and Appeal Board to cancel the claims as obvious in light of earlier networking technology. The Board rejected both proposed combinations of earlier technology and left all twenty-six challenged claims standing. That ruling concerns the patent challenges presented, not whether anyone infringed the patent. One dispute on appeal concerns a link aggregation group, called a lag: must it contain several physical links, or can it have just one? The challenger will argue that a technical standard incorporated into the patent allows a single-link group, and that its evidence adequately explained how to combine the earlier technologies. It will also challenge whether the Board considered all of its explanation. The

Discuss this episode

Oral Arguments, with Context

Jose Elpidio Figueroa-Cruz v. U.S. Attorney General — 11th Cir. (Nov 5, 2026)

16 min

The Eleventh Circuit considers the immigration consequences of a Florida child-abuse conviction. Immigration authorities treated the petitioner's conviction as a ground for removal, and he is challenging that legal classification. The conviction was under a Florida provision covering child abuse without great bodily harm. One way to violate that law is to commit an intentional act reasonably expected to cause physical or mental injury, even if the injury never occurs. This is not a retrial of the criminal charge. The court is using the categorical approach: comparing what the state offense requires with the federal categories of child abuse, child neglect, or child abandonment. The petitioner's lawyer will argue that the state offense is too broad because it requires neither actual injury nor a legal duty to care for the child. The government will respond that Congress did not limit this removal ground to parents or guardians, and that an earlier circuit decision supports treating this

Discuss this episode
Older episodes