English-language podcasts

Podcasts

Oral Arguments, with Context

An episode can be the start of a conversation. Explore recent releases, share your thoughts, and meet through a ThinkMatch Roundtable.

Ask friends about this

Episodes to discuss

Oral Arguments, with Context

Amanda Beyer v. Michels Corporation — 7th Cir. (Nov 3, 2026)

32 min

The Seventh Circuit considers an employee's wage-and-hour lawsuit. The employee alleges that her employer's payroll calculations left her and other workers unpaid for some of the time they worked. One dispute concerns employees who clocked in on a company computer: she says payroll used a later time adjusted by a supervisor, rather than the original clock-in, before rounding the time. Another challenges rounding that allegedly cut paid work time, including calculations for short meal breaks. Those are allegations, not findings that the company owes wages. The immediate question is whether the claims were stated clearly enough to proceed. The district court dismissed three sets of claims after several amended complaints, saying their overlapping and inconsistent descriptions did not give the company fair notice of what it had to defend. A separate individual claim for interrupted meal breaks survived; the parties later reached a settlement on that claim. The employee's lawyer will argue

Discuss this episode

Oral Arguments, with Context

Stevenson v. Lavespere — 5th Cir. (Nov 4, 2026)

37 min

The Fifth Circuit revisits a prisoner's claim that lifting his work restrictions violated the Eighth Amendment. Bobby Stevenson had a surgically repaired ankle and a medical status that kept him out of agricultural fieldwork at Louisiana State Penitentiary. In 2019, the prison's medical director approved a nurse practitioner's recommendation to lift those restrictions. Corrections officers then assigned Stevenson to field work. Stevenson contends that this exposed him to severe pain and further injury, and that the doctor knew the risk. The doctor disputes that account, relying on the examination, an asserted lack of recent ankle-pain complaints, and later medical care. An earlier appeal allowed Stevenson's allegations to proceed. The case then returned to district court for an evidence-based summary-judgment decision, where the judge found disputes requiring a trial on the claim against this doctor. The doctor is appealing that refusal to grant qualified immunity, not a jury verdict i

Discuss this episode

Oral Arguments, with Context

American Sustainable v. Huffines — 5th Cir. (Nov 5, 2026)

44 min

The Fifth Circuit hears a challenge to Texas Senate Bill thirteen. The law restricts certain public investments and government contracts involving companies that Texas classifies as boycotting energy companies. Funds managed by two members of the American Sustainable Business Council were placed on the state's boycott list. The Council sued state officials, arguing that the law penalizes its members' advocacy against reliance on fossil fuels and makes it unclear how to get off the list. A federal district judge agreed that the law was overbroad and unconstitutionally vague, and issued an injunction against enforcement. Texas is appealing that ruling. The state's lawyer will argue that Texas can choose not to invest public money in companies that discriminate against the fossil-fuel industry, and that the statute regulates commercial decisions rather than speech. The Council's lawyer will answer that the law's language and enforcement reach protected expression. A central dispute is the

Discuss this episode

Oral Arguments, with Context

Subpoena Issued to Pretrial Services Agency — D.C. Cir. (Nov 5, 2026)

57 min

The D.C. Circuit considers a defense request for records held by the Pretrial Services Agency. Kenneth Sanders is defending a criminal case in the District of Columbia's local trial court. He wants medical and toxicology records about the complaining witness, whom the argument describes as the only eyewitness. The request concerns the witness's records, not Sanders's own supervision files. A trial judge authorized a subpoena requiring the agency to produce records for the defense. The agency instead took the subpoena proceeding to federal court, where a district judge set the subpoena aside on sovereign-immunity grounds. Sovereign immunity generally limits a court's power to compel the federal government without its consent. The defense lawyer will argue that the government cannot start a criminal prosecution and then use immunity to avoid the ordinary evidence rules governing that prosecution. The agency will answer that bringing a criminal prosecution does not waive federal immunity

Discuss this episode

Oral Arguments, with Context

United States v. Justin Sigmon, Appellant — 11th Cir. (Nov 5, 2026)

28 min

The Eleventh Circuit hears United States versus Justin Sigmon. A jury convicted Sigmon of abusive sexual contact with a child after an incident in a cruise ship dining room. The prosecution relied on ship surveillance, videos recorded by nearby passengers, and eyewitness testimony. His lawyer will challenge whether that evidence established the required intent. That intent is not limited to sexual gratification: the federal definition also includes an intent to harass or humiliate. The trial judge declined to order a new trial. The appeal separates whether the trial evidence was legally sufficient from whether material improperly reaching the jury requires a new trial. The second issue concerns forfeiture language in an unredacted indictment, wording about property to be surrendered after conviction. Sigmon's lawyer will contend that this language suggested possession of illegal sexual images that the prosecution had not proved, unfairly filling the gap on intent. That is an argument a

Discuss this episode

Oral Arguments, with Context

Xu Lun v. Milwaukee Electric Tool Corporation — 7th Cir. (Nov 4, 2026)

42 min

The Seventh Circuit hears Xu Lun versus Milwaukee Electric Tool Corporation. Xu Lun is the court-used pseudonym of a former prisoner in China who says he was forced to manufacture work gloves bearing Milwaukee Tool's logo. He describes compulsory work for very little pay. His lawsuit alleges that the gloves were sold to American customers and that Milwaukee Tool knowingly benefited from forced labor. Milwaukee Tool disputes the allegations. This is a civil damages case, not a criminal prosecution. The district court dismissed the claim because it concluded that the federal anti-trafficking law's civil remedy did not reach the alleged conduct in China. That ruling addressed the statute's geographic reach, not whether forced labor was proved at a trial. Xu Lun's lawyer will offer two paths to reversal: first, that the company's alleged American sales and benefiting make this a domestic case; second, that Congress authorized civil recovery for overseas forced labor. The company will conte

Discuss this episode

Oral Arguments, with Context

Zongzong Tao v. Simplex Investments LLC — 7th Cir. (Nov 5, 2026)

22 min

The Seventh Circuit hears Nicole Tao's discrimination case against Simplex Investments, her former employer. The dispute centers on a coding error in an automated trading program. It treated trading fees as one hundred times their proper size, causing it to pass up potentially profitable trades. Simplex blamed Tao for not detecting the problem while monitoring the strategy. After reviewing other aspects of her work, the firm fired her. Tao, a Chinese-American woman, will argue that comparable errors by male, non-Chinese traders brought less severe treatment. Simplex will respond that the relevant employees, mistakes, supervisors and knowledge of those mistakes were not comparable. The district court entered summary judgment for Simplex, ending the discrimination claims without a trial. It also excluded her expert's opinion that the coding error wasn't her fault, finding that opinion irrelevant to whether the firm honestly believed its stated reason. The appeal asks whether the evidence

Discuss this episode

Oral Arguments, with Context

USA v. Demario Flemming — 7th Cir. (Nov 5, 2026)

20 min

The Seventh Circuit hears United States v. Demario Flemming. Start with the incident behind the sentencing questions. Officers responding to reports of gunshots encountered Flemming driving away. The police account describes a vehicle chase, a crash at an exit ramp, and flight on foot before his arrest. A handgun was recovered. That account is not a finding that every initial accusation was proved. Now listen for how particular sentencing rules fit the conduct established in the record. A federal firearm guideline can increase the calculation when a gun is used or possessed in connection with another felony. A separate conviction for that other felony is not required. When you hear acceptance of responsibility, think of a possible sentencing reduction, not an automatic reward for pleading guilty. The guidelines also distinguish reckless endangerment during flight from willfully obstructing justice. Their interaction matters, not just how dangerous the chase was. Finally, listen for har

Discuss this episode

Oral Arguments, with Context

Curling v. Worley — 11th Cir. (Nov 4, 2026)

33 min

The Eleventh Circuit hears a challenge to Georgia's electronic in-person voting system. The lawsuit began in 2017 over older electronic voting equipment and continued after Georgia adopted a different system. Under the system challenged here, voters make choices on a touchscreen. It prints a paper ballot showing those choices in readable text and a QR code. The scanner counts the code, not the printed names. Voters can inspect the names, but the plaintiffs say that doesn't let them personally verify the coded record that is counted. They sought to stop use of this system and replace it with hand-marked paper ballots. After a trial in 2024, the district court dismissed the case in 2025 for lack of standing. Standing asks whether they face a concrete, personal injury linked to the defendants' conduct that the requested court order is likely to remedy. The voters and an advocacy organization will argue that these are individual and organizational harms, not merely policy objections. The s

Discuss this episode

Oral Arguments, with Context

Rodriguez-Rivera v. Allscripts Healthcare, LLC — 1st Cir. (Nov 5, 2026)

31 min

The First Circuit hears a dispute that began with a doctor's lost patient records. Dr. Rodriguez-Rivera used Allscripts' MyWay software in his Puerto Rico practice. He says the destruction of his patients' electronic records caused losses for which Allscripts should pay. But this argument concerns a threshold question: did he agree to have that dispute decided in private arbitration rather than court? The particular signed license agreement said to bind him has not been produced. After an earlier appeal, the district court held a trial, found an agreement to arbitrate, and sent the case to arbitration. Rodriguez-Rivera will challenge both the strength of that proof and the use of a reseller's deposition testimony. A deposition is sworn testimony taken before trial; here, the dispute is whether enough was shown to justify using it without the witness appearing in person. Allscripts will defend the trial judge's assessment and argue that the software terms and the doctor's use of the pro

Discuss this episode

Oral Arguments, with Context

Petite v. Lowe — 5th Cir. (Nov 3, 2026)

42 min

The Fifth Circuit hears Sydney Petite's appeal in a malpractice suit against lawyers who handled her divorce and child-custody case. She alleges that her former husband abused her, and that these lawyers knew about the abuse but never told her she could bring a separate civil claim for damages. She says the filing deadline passed while they represented her, costing her that opportunity. She then sued the lawyers and their firms. The district judge dismissed her case on summary judgment, finding that she had not supplied the expert evidence needed to establish professional negligence. Such experts help explain what a reasonably careful lawyer should do in the circumstances. Louisiana law recognizes an exception for mistakes so obvious that a lay jury can recognize them without expert help. Petite's lawyer will argue that failing to mention the separate abuse claim fits that exception. The defense will answer that they were hired to handle divorce and custody work, not every possible law

Discuss this episode

Oral Arguments, with Context

Michael Fitzgerald et al. v. Ronda McNae — 11th Cir. (Nov 4, 2026)

17 min

The Eleventh Circuit hears Ronda McNae's challenge to a judgment enforcing a confidential settlement with Michael Fitzgerald. The settlement addressed allegations of sexual assault, not an established criminal conviction. Fitzgerald paid money, and the parties exchanged releases and promises restricting disclosure and disparagement. He later sued McNae for breaching the agreement, including by contacting employers. The district judge found her liable without a trial on liability and rejected her duress defense. After a separate damages trial, the judge awarded more than two point seven million dollars. This is a contract appeal, not a criminal prosecution. McNae's lawyer will ask for a trial on whether she signed under duress: improper coercion that made the agreement involuntary. The panel will press him on the negotiations, the involvement of her own lawyer, and the record supporting that defense. Summary judgment is proper only when there is no genuine dispute over facts that matter

Discuss this episode

Oral Arguments, with Context

Rebecca M. Pereida v. Douglas A. Collins — CAVC (Nov 5, 2026)

95 min

The Court of Appeals for Veterans Claims hears a Vietnam veteran's daughter's challenge to a birth-defects benefits law. Rebecca Pereida sought benefits for her own disabilities based on her father's Vietnam service. VA denied the claim, and the Board of Veterans' Appeals agreed. For the program at issue, the law limits eligibility to children of women who served in Vietnam; Pereida's mother did not. A separate spina bifida program covers children of either male or female Vietnam veterans, but the record did not establish that diagnosis for her. The Veterans Court initially upheld the denial without explaining why it rejected her constitutional challenge. In 2025, the Federal Circuit set that decision aside and sent the case back for further consideration. It did not award benefits or decide the discrimination question. Pereida's lawyers will contend that excluding children because their veteran parent is male violates equal protection. The government will defend the statute and questi

Discuss this episode

Oral Arguments, with Context

FASORP v. Northwestern University — 7th Cir. (Nov 5, 2026)

38 min

The Seventh Circuit hears Faculty, Alumni, and Students Opposed to Racial Preferences challenge Northwestern University over law-school hiring and law-review selection. The group alleges that race and sex preferences disadvantage its white male members when competing for faculty appointments and publication. Its complaint relies on three unnamed law professors. According to the complaint, two had told Northwestern faculty contacts that they wanted lateral appointments, and all three intended to submit scholarship to the law review. The group seeks court orders changing future hiring and journal-selection practices, rather than damages for a particular past job rejection. The appeal concerns whether those claims can go forward. Article Three standing concerns a plaintiff's personal stake: a concrete injury linked to the defendant that the requested court order can redress. That is separate from whether the complaint states a legally valid discrimination claim. Listen for whether the des

Discuss this episode

Oral Arguments, with Context

United States v. Charbonier-Laureano, et al. — 1st Cir. (Nov 5, 2026)

81 min

The First Circuit hears the consolidated appeals of a Puerto Rico House member and her husband from federal corruption convictions. Prosecutors accused the House member of inflating an assistant's publicly paid salary in exchange for the assistant returning some of the money to her and her family. A jury found both defendants guilty, and they are challenging those convictions here. The charges include Section six sixty six, a federal theft and bribery statute covering certain organizations or governments that receive federal benefits. It has separate requirements for those benefits and the value of the property or transactions involved. Listen for which government entity counts, how the relevant one-year period is defined, and whether the jury instructions matched the indictment. The hearing will also turn to hearsay: statements made outside the trial and offered to prove what they assert. For statements against a speaker's penal interest, Rule eight oh four requires unavailability and

Discuss this episode

Oral Arguments, with Context

Hughes River FM, LLC v. Ximalaya, Inc. — 7th Cir. (Nov 5, 2026)

41 min

The Seventh Circuit hears Hughes River's challenge to a merger involving a Chinese audio platform. Hughes River owned shares in the platform and says it was forced to sell on unfair terms when the platform agreed to merge with a music entertainment company. It sued the platform, its chief executive, and the buyer in federal court in Illinois. The investor points to merger-related messages received by its manager in Illinois. The district court dismissed the case for lack of personal jurisdiction, meaning authority over the defendants, not a ruling that the merger was fair. The investor's lawyer will argue that the messages and the defendants' Illinois business activities justify proceeding, or at least require an evidentiary hearing. The defendants will answer that contacts with a shareholder do not necessarily establish contacts with the state, and that unrelated business does not supply the missing link. The panel will also press questions about foreign companies' citizenship, the re

Discuss this episode

Oral Arguments, with Context

Paul Guertin v. United States of America — D.C. Cir. (Nov 5, 2026)

30 min

The D.C. Circuit considers a former State Department officer's damages suit after criminal charges were dismissed. The investigation concerned alleged omissions about foreign contacts and financial matters during security-clearance reviews. Prosecutors charged him with wire fraud on the theory that he hid information to keep his job and salary. Courts dismissed that charge, and the appeals court upheld the dismissal in 2023 because the alleged scheme did not satisfy the statute. He then sued the United States, alleging that an investigator used false statements and omissions to obtain searches and bring about the prosecution. The district court dismissed the civil case, relying in part on an earlier ruling that the search warrants had probable cause. His lawyer will argue that justification for a search is not the same as justification for a prosecution, and that the complaint should proceed to discovery. The government will answer that prosecutors and the grand jury independently had

Discuss this episode

Oral Arguments, with Context

Wallace v. State of Mississippi — 5th Cir. (Nov 5, 2026)

30 min

The Fifth Circuit hears Reginald Wallace's challenge to a Mississippi conviction arising from a robbery. He pleaded guilty and received a thirty-year prison sentence. He says his lawyer failed to tell him about a later offer to plead to the lesser offense of robbery, which carried at most fifteen years. An earlier written offer was different and had expired. In 2016, Mississippi's appeals court ordered an evidentiary hearing on whether the later offer had been conveyed. A federal district court later dismissed his petition, but permitted an appeal on specific factual questions about that offer. The dispute involves more than what the lawyer said: would Wallace have accepted the offer on its actual terms? His lawyer will argue that the state courts assumed a cooperation requirement without adequate evidence. Mississippi will point to the other defendants' agreements and Wallace's unwillingness to implicate his brother. Listen for the difference between a better possible sentence and pro

Discuss this episode

Oral Arguments, with Context

Niagara Mohawk Power Corporation v. FERC — D.C. Cir. (Nov 5, 2026)

43 min

The D.C. Circuit hears a dispute over who bears the financial risk of developing transmission projects in New York. Niagara Mohawk asked FERC, the federal energy regulator, for permission to recover all prudently incurred costs if those projects were later cancelled for reasons outside its control. FERC conditionally granted the incentive, but made full-cost protection begin no earlier than state approval of each project, rather than the earlier date the utility requested. Niagara Mohawk will argue that this exposes costly preliminary work and unfairly penalizes reliance on a streamlined state-approval process that avoids duplicate studies. FERC will respond that consumer benefits must first be demonstrated before electricity customers bear the full risk. The dispute concerns the start of possible future cost protection, not an immediate payout. Listen for the difference between an acceptable policy change and treating similar utilities inconsistently. Niagara Mohawk Power Corporation

Discuss this episode

Oral Arguments, with Context

United States of America v. Saunders — 2d Cir. (Nov 6, 2026)

13 min

The Second Circuit hears a renewed sentencing appeal arising from a conviction for possessing a firearm despite earlier felony convictions. The defendant's record included three prior violent felonies, and the original judge applied the Armed Career Criminal Act's fifteen-year minimum. A new district-court judgment in 2025 brought the case back to the appeals court. Against that history, listen for two different questions: did the judge consider the defendant's personal circumstances, and did the judge give those circumstances enough weight? A sentencing judge must also consider the seriousness of the offense, deterrence, and public safety. Does changing the sentencing framework require a proportionately larger reduction, or can the judge weigh the same circumstances differently? Listen for the explanation and balance behind the sentence, rather than simply a mathematical discount. United States of America v. Saunders (No. 25-2477) — U.S. Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit, argued

Discuss this episode

Oral Arguments, with Context

Bancredito Holding Corporation v. Driven Administrative Services, LLC — 1st Cir. (Nov 5, 2026)

37 min

The First Circuit hears a dispute over the liquidation of a Puerto Rico bank. With the bank's license revoked, a receiver took charge of its liquidation. The bank's sole shareholder later sued the receiver, alleging negligence, breaches of duty, and unnecessary artwork sales that harmed the bank. An earlier settlement, however, assigned disputes connected with the receivership to Puerto Rico's banking regulator, with exclusive jurisdiction as allowed by law. The district court enforced that clause and dismissed these claims without deciding whether the receiver had acted wrongfully. The shareholder will argue that ordinary negligence and corporate-law claims fall outside the regulator's legal powers, leaving it without an adequate remedy. The receiver will respond that these claims concern the agreed liquidation arrangements and that other relief is available. Listen for the difference between what the agreement covers and what the agency can legally decide, and for whether a forum-sel

Discuss this episode

Oral Arguments, with Context

United States of America v. Carter — 2d Cir. (Nov 5, 2026)

70 min

The Second Circuit hears United States versus Carter, an appeal arising from fraudulent pandemic-relief applications. People supplied their personal and banking information for applications to the Small Business Administration. The applications falsely claimed that they owned businesses with employees. The agency paid advances into their accounts, and part of the money went back to the scheme's organizers. A jury convicted the defendants of fraud and aggravated identity theft. That separate identity-theft offense carries a mandatory two-year consecutive sentence. But using someone's name during a fraud is not automatically aggravated identity theft: the Supreme Court requires the misuse of identity to be central to what makes the conduct criminal. Here, listen for the distinction between lying about a person's business eligibility and misusing that person's identity, and for whether supplying information authorized its use this way. The argument also examines whether counting the peopl

Discuss this episode

Oral Arguments, with Context

Figueroa-Rodriguez v. Puerto Rico Department of Education — 1st Cir. (Nov 5, 2026)

41 min

The First Circuit hears a Puerto Rico teacher's employment dispute. He was fired in 2023 and later won reinstatement and backpay through an administrative appeal. That background matters, but another legal framework is also in play: Puerto Rico's debt restructuring under the federal law PROMESA. A discharge injunction can prevent lawsuits seeking payment on claims covered by that restructuring. The plan became effective in March 2022, before the firing. As you listen, keep separate the events offered as background and the particular conduct for which a plaintiff seeks relief. The dispute over a debt discharge is not the same as deciding whether employment discrimination occurred. Listen closely to how the lawyers describe what the complaint actually claims, and whether the earlier history changes the treatment of later events. Figueroa-Rodriguez v. Puerto Rico Department of Education (No. 25-1318) — U.S. Court of Appeals for the First Circuit, argued November 5, 2026. Sources: Argument

Discuss this episode

Oral Arguments, with Context

Terracino v. Trimaco, Inc. — Fed. Cir. (Nov 5, 2026)

31 min

The Federal Circuit hears a patent dispute over a painter's non-skid drop cloth. The patent describes an absorbent upper layer over a lower layer with downward-projecting bumps. The inventors sued a company over a competing drop cloth, claiming it infringed their patent. The district court ruled for the company after reading the patent to require every smaller-circumference bump to be taller than the larger ones. The inventors could not show that its product met that reading. On appeal, they will argue that this interpretation is too narrow: language inside the claim leaves room for other bump arrangements, even though another phrase limits the cloth's layers. The company will defend the court's reading using the claim language and the patent's examination history. Listen for the difference between comprising and consisting of, and for whether alternative reasons to uphold the judgment were properly raised. Terracino v. Trimaco, Inc. (No. 25-1808) — U.S. Court of Appeals for the Federa

Discuss this episode
Older episodes