English-language podcasts

Podcasts

Oral Arguments, with Context

An episode can be the start of a conversation. Explore recent releases, share your thoughts, and meet through a ThinkMatch Roundtable.

Ask friends about this

Episodes to discuss

Oral Arguments, with Context

Sonos, Inc. v. Google LLC — Fed. Cir. (Nov 5, 2026)

34 min

The Federal Circuit hears Sonos versus Google. Sonos challenged Google's patent on using one wireless device to help another join a wireless network. Claim six adds a message sent over that network indicating that the new device has successfully joined. The Board rejected Sonos's obviousness challenge to that claim, and Sonos appealed. Sonos will contend that older network-setup technology made the message obvious to a skilled person, and that the Board overlooked or misread its evidence. Google will defend the Board's distinction between obtaining network credentials and actually joining the network, as well as the need to explain the challenge in the original petition. Listen for what the older technology taught, and whether Sonos's petition gave a good reason to add the message. This is a patentability review, not a trial over product infringement. Sonos, Inc. v. Google LLC (No. 25-1338) — U.S. Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit, argued November 5, 2026. Sources: Argument audi

Discuss this episode

Oral Arguments, with Context

O'Neill v. NYU Langone Hospitals — 2d Cir. (Nov 5, 2026)

14 min

The Second Circuit hears O'Neill's appeal in a lawsuit against three New York hospitals. O'Neill says the hospitals mishandled her care and medical records after she reported sexual assaults. She alleges that records were falsified and information was disclosed without her consent to conceal wrongdoing. These are her allegations, not established findings. The district court dismissed her claims and refused another amended complaint, concluding that the proposed allegations still did not state legally sufficient claims. Representing herself, she will argue that she lacked important information and should be allowed to revise her complaint again. The hospitals will defend the requirements for pleading a claim. This is an argument about whether her lawsuit can proceed, not a trial to determine whether the alleged assaults occurred. O'Neill v. NYU Langone Hospitals (No. 25-2978) — U.S. Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit, argued November 5, 2026. Sources: Argument audio — official Seco

Discuss this episode

Oral Arguments, with Context

Kevin Harrell v. City of West Palm Beach — 11th Cir. (Nov 5, 2026)

30 min

The Eleventh Circuit hears Harrell versus the City of West Palm Beach. Harrell was a police officer who became the subject of a criminal investigation into suspected disclosures of police information. Investigators obtained a warrant to search his cell phone, and potential workplace violations were later referred to internal affairs. The city says he disclosed confidential information and was untruthful during the internal inquiry. It dismissed him after a disciplinary hearing. Harrell disputes the city's explanation for his dismissal. This is a civil employment appeal, not a criminal trial. You will hear about federal criminal Rule forty-one G, which provides a procedure for seeking the return of seized property. Keep two questions separate: what justified the employment decision, and what legal procedure can be used to challenge the use of search material in a civil case. Kevin Harrell v. City of West Palm Beach (No. 24-12814) — U.S. Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit, argued

Discuss this episode

Oral Arguments, with Context

The Green Pet Shop Enterprises, LLC v. Comfort Revolution — Fed. Cir. (Nov 5, 2026)

33 min

The Federal Circuit hears The Green Pet Shop versus Comfort Revolution. This dispute concerns a patent for a cooling pad intended to work without first being frozen. The patent describes a design in which pressure activates the cooling effect. Its named inventor obtained a gel and its formula from a factory, then designed the pad's casing. That history raised a question: had the factory contributed to the invention, or merely supplied a material that the inventor put to a new use? The district court ruled against Green Pet Shop before trial on inventorship, concluding that the named inventor had not conceived the pressure-activated feature. Green Pet Shop will argue that the invention is the combination of gel and pad structure, and that disputed facts should have prevented summary judgment. Comfort Revolution will rely on the inventor's testimony and the parties' agreed facts about the factory's role. Listen for the difference between discovering a material's property, developing the

Discuss this episode

Oral Arguments, with Context

Carine Balenda Mbizi, et al. v. Blanche — 1st Cir. (Nov 4, 2026)

23 min

The First Circuit hears Mbizi versus Blanche. This recording includes discussion of sexual violence. Mbizi and her family sought asylum in the United States after leaving the Democratic Republic of the Congo. She says that guards detained and assaulted her after she witnessed violence at a military general's home, where she worked. An immigration judge did not find her account credible and denied asylum. The Board of Immigration Appeals upheld that ruling, and the family sought review in the First Circuit. The argument will focus on how the agency assessed a medical record she offered to support her account, and whether its doubts were adequately grounded in the evidence. This is judicial review of the agency's decision, not a new asylum hearing. Listen for the distinction between legitimate credibility concerns and assumptions about what a hospital record should contain. Sending the case back would require further agency consideration, not automatically grant asylum. Carine Balenda Mb

Discuss this episode

Oral Arguments, with Context

Matthew Donahue v. Village of Elm Grove Fire Department — 7th Cir. (Nov 3, 2026)

23 min

The Seventh Circuit hears Donahue versus the Village of Elm Grove Fire Department. Matthew Donahue was a firefighter in the Wisconsin village. A personal dispute with his church led to police questioning. Donahue complained that officers had lied to him and mishandled his efforts to make complaints. The village manager referred the matter to the fire department for an investigation of Donahue's conduct. Donahue ultimately lost his position. In his federal lawsuit, he alleges that officials retaliated against him for speaking out. Those allegations are disputed. This appeal focuses on the First Amendment protection for a public employee's speech. Donahue will argue that complaints about police misconduct can raise a matter of public concern even when the speaker is personally involved. The defendants will characterize his complaints as a private grievance growing out of the church dispute. Listen for where the judges draw that line: when is a complaint about how police treated one perso

Discuss this episode

Oral Arguments, with Context

Garrett Mixon v. City of Galesburg — 7th Cir. (Nov 4, 2026)

24 min

The Seventh Circuit hears Mixon versus the City of Galesburg, a civil case over a gun-related arrest. Mixon was shot in the leg, and other people picked him up in a car. Police followed that car. A gun later found along its route was matched to a shell casing from the shooting scene. A detective treated those connections as grounds to suspect that Mixon had possessed the gun. Mixon disputes that inference. He sued the detective and city, alleging an arrest without probable cause. The district court ruled for the defendants: it relied on the arrest warrant's presumption of validity and also found probable cause from the surrounding facts. Probable cause concerns a reasonable basis to believe someone committed an offense; it is not proof of guilt at a criminal trial. On appeal, Mixon will emphasize that no eyewitness, video, or forensic evidence directly linked him to possessing the gun. The defendants will argue that circumstantial evidence can be enough. Another key issue is the warran

Discuss this episode

Oral Arguments, with Context

Quintez Cephus v. Rebecca Blank — 7th Cir. (Nov 4, 2026)

33 min

The Seventh Circuit hears Cephus versus Blank, a dispute over a university's handling of sexual-assault allegations against a football player. Two fellow students accused Cephus of sexual assault. The University of Wisconsin-Madison investigated, held a disciplinary hearing, and expelled him. A jury later acquitted him in the separate criminal case. After reviewing additional information, the university lifted the expulsion and let him return, although some misconduct findings remained. Cephus then sued, claiming that the university's earlier process discriminated against him because he is a man. The district court entered summary judgment for the defendants, finding insufficient evidence for a jury to infer sex discrimination. That ended this civil case without a trial. On appeal, Cephus will argue that the evidence must be considered together: the university's messaging about sexual assault, its scheduling choices, and gaps in the investigative record. The university will respond tha

Discuss this episode

Oral Arguments, with Context

United States v. Anderson and Warnock — 5th Cir. (Nov 4, 2026)

34 min

The Fifth Circuit hears United States versus Anderson and Warnock, an appeal from a public-corruption trial in Mississippi. Warnock was a private contractor, and Cleveland Anderson served on the Canton Municipal Utilities board. Prosecutors alleged that Warnock provided officials money and other benefits to secure contracts, including work on sewer problems. The government also said that payments reached Anderson through a purported campaign-manager job for which no actual work was done. Warnock will dispute that there was a corrupt bargain and point to legitimate business reasons for the contracts. A jury convicted both men, who now challenge their convictions. One key distinction is between a bribe and a gratuity. Under Snyder, Section six sixty-six punishes bribery involving state or local officials, not merely an unpromised thank-you gift after an official act. Payment after the act can still be a bribe if it was promised as part of a corrupt agreement beforehand. Agreement timing

Discuss this episode

Oral Arguments, with Context

Doe v. University of Texas — 5th Cir. (Nov 4, 2026)

27 min

The Fifth Circuit takes up Jane Doe's challenge to her dismissal from the University of Texas at San Antonio's orthodontics residency. Faculty members had raised concerns about her clinical performance and professional conduct. She was placed on a remediation plan, then probation, and later removed from the program. A July dismissal notice and an August meeting are central to the dispute. Doe will acknowledge that she knew of earlier clinical concerns. But she will contend that the July letter added an accusation of inconsistent statements without explaining the conduct well enough for her to answer. School officials will answer that prior feedback, evaluations, and counseling already gave her meaningful notice and opportunities to respond. Doe sued for reinstatement, alleging that the process violated her constitutional rights. The district court rejected her procedural due process claim, concluding that the alleged facts showed constitutionally sufficient notice and academic review.

Discuss this episode

Oral Arguments, with Context

Wild Type v. Garcia — 5th Cir. (Nov 4, 2026)

38 min

The Fifth Circuit hears Wildtype and UPSIDE Foods challenge Texas's ban on selling cultivated meat. These foods are grown from animal cells in controlled facilities. Wildtype produces cultivated salmon; UPSIDE produces cultivated chicken. Before the ban took effect, Wildtype supplied an Austin sushi restaurant, and UPSIDE had made a sale to a Texas resident. The companies say they were also working to expand their Texas business. Senate Bill two sixty-one bars sales for human consumption, regardless of where the product was made. Its sales prohibition is scheduled to expire in September twenty twenty-seven unless changed. The companies sued Texas officials and sought a preliminary injunction: temporary relief that would allow sales while their lawsuit proceeded. The district court denied that request. It relied on the companies' limited existing Texas business and the ban's temporary duration, finding insufficient irreparable harm and concluding that the balance of harms did not favor

Discuss this episode

Oral Arguments, with Context

United States v. Stephanie Hockridge — 5th Cir. (Nov 3, 2026)

41 min

The Fifth Circuit hears United States versus Stephanie Hockridge, an appeal from a pandemic-loan fraud prosecution. Hockridge helped found Blueacorn, which assisted borrowers seeking government-backed loans under the Paycheck Protection Program, or PPP. Prosecutors said she and others submitted false applications, including fabricated income and payroll information, to obtain relief money. Hockridge disputes that she knowingly agreed to commit fraud. A jury convicted her of conspiracy to commit wire fraud but acquitted her of four separate wire-fraud counts. The appeal concerns the fairness of that trial and the validity of its result. Two distinctions will help you follow the argument. First, venue means the proper geographic district for a trial. Keep that question separate from whether the defendant knowingly joined a fraudulent agreement. Listen for what must connect a conspiracy to the trial district, and what jurors must be told about that connection. Second, the defense challeng

Discuss this episode

Oral Arguments, with Context

Robinhood Derivatives, LLC v. Campbell — 1st Cir. (Nov 4, 2026)

35 min

The First Circuit hears Robinhood Derivatives versus Campbell, a case that grew out of Massachusetts's effort to regulate contracts tied to sports results. Robinhood lets customers place orders through its platform, with trades executed on Kalshi's exchange. Massachusetts sued Kalshi, alleging unlicensed sports wagering. Robinhood then sued Massachusetts's attorney general and gaming officials in federal court before they brought a case against Robinhood itself. Robinhood claims federal commodities law prevents the state from using gambling laws against this business. But before reaching that question, a federal court must decide whether there is a sufficiently immediate dispute to hear at all. That is ripeness: whether this dispute is ready for a decision, rather than dependent on uncertain future events. The district court dismissed Robinhood's case as unripe, not because it decided whether these contracts were lawful. State officials had offered a conditional promise to hold off on

Discuss this episode

Oral Arguments, with Context

Vázquez-Ramos v. Triple-S Salud, Inc. — 1st Cir. (Nov 4, 2026)

46 min

The First Circuit hears Vázquez-Ramos versus Triple-S Salud, a dispute over access to urology care under a government health plan in western Puerto Rico. Several doctors and their practices say the insurer replaced their network contracts with an exclusive arrangement involving a competing provider. They contend that this not only cost them business, but also restricted patients' choice of doctors and access to care. The insurer and the competing providers will answer that the arrangement resulted from competition for the contract, lowered costs, and did not reduce care. An earlier appeal allowed part of the lawsuit to go forward; it did not establish an antitrust violation. After discovery, the district court granted summary judgment for the defendants, finding the record insufficient to send the claims to trial. The doctors now challenge that ruling. Two distinctions help explain the questions that follow. First, antitrust law protects competition, not simply an individual competitor

Discuss this episode

Oral Arguments, with Context

Slim v. Life Insurance Company of North America, et al. — 1st Cir. (Nov 4, 2026)

30 min

The First Circuit takes up Slim, a dispute over life insurance arranged through his employer, Royal Blue Hospitality. Slim says he selected extra coverage for his wife and paid premiums through payroll deductions. After her death, he sought the additional insurance payment, but the insurer said the required proof of insurability and written approval were missing. Those are requirements for putting the extra coverage into effect, not simply for collecting premiums. His lawsuit involves both the insurer, Life Insurance Company of North America, and his employer. But this argument concerns more than whether benefits were payable under the policy. Slim also alleges a breach of fiduciary duty in the handling of his coverage. The district court rejected that route to relief, and he wants it reconsidered. The governing law is ERISA, the federal employee-benefits statute. One provision allows a beneficiary to enforce benefits due under the plan; another authorizes other appropriate equitable r

Discuss this episode

Oral Arguments, with Context

Mohammed Mahran v. Cook County, Illinois — 7th Cir. (Nov 4, 2026)

22 min

The Seventh Circuit hears Mahran versus Cook County, an employment dispute involving a Muslim pharmacist. Mahran complained about interference with his time for prayer at work. Later disputes involved medical leave, discipline, a transfer from a county hospital to the county jail, and ultimately his dismissal. He also reported concerns about patient safety. Mahran sees retaliation and religious discrimination in this sequence of events. He says the jail assignment was physically more demanding; the county describes a temporary staffing transfer that left his pay and benefits unchanged. The county will defend the dismissal by pointing to alleged falsification of paperwork and misleading statements to investigators, rather than his complaints or leave. The district judge granted summary judgment for the county, ending the remaining claims without a trial. At that stage, the question is whether the evidence presents a genuine factual dispute that a reasonable jury could resolve for the em

Discuss this episode

Oral Arguments, with Context

United States v. Darden — 5th Cir. (Nov 3, 2026)

28 min

The Fifth Circuit hears United States versus Darden, a sentencing appeal following guilty pleas to fentanyl trafficking and a related firearm offense. Darden received a twenty-five-year prison sentence and is seeking resentencing. The issue is how robbery fits the Sentencing Guidelines' definition of a crime of violence, a category that can raise the recommended sentencing range. Under the categorical approach, judges compare the legal elements of offenses instead of retrying what happened during a particular earlier incident. A state offense broader than the federal definition may not count for the particular enhancement, even if both offenses are called robbery. The key term is mens rea, meaning the mental state required for an offense. Here the dispute concerns the mental state attached to the use of force during a taking: must it be knowing or intentional, or can reckless force also fit? The Sentencing Commission adopted a robbery definition that mirrors the federal Hobbs Act. The

Discuss this episode

Oral Arguments, with Context

United States v. Cruz-Osorio — 1st Cir. (Nov 4, 2026)

43 min

The First Circuit hears United States versus Cruz-Osorio, a cocaine prosecution involving airport surveillance video that was not preserved. The case began when officers found cocaine in a bag during an airport inspection. The defense says the missing footage could have challenged the government's account linking Cruz-Osorio to the drugs. Officers watched events on a live camera feed, and a still image survived, but the relevant video was no longer available to the defense. Before trial, Cruz-Osorio sought the footage or dismissal of the indictment. The district court denied that request after hearing testimony about the loss and attempted preservation of the recordings. The judge found insufficient evidence of an improper government motive and concluded that the defense had not shown the video was irreplaceable. The court pointed to witness testimony, the surviving image, and cross-examination as other ways to examine what happened. Refusing dismissal does not itself mean that the inv

Discuss this episode

Oral Arguments, with Context

United States v. Robert Williams — 7th Cir. (Nov 3, 2026)

34 min

The Seventh Circuit hears United States versus Williams, an appeal following a guilty plea in a prosecution for six robberies and related firearm offenses. The government describes a gun being displayed to intimidate victims during the robberies. The discussion turns to what a guilty plea and an agreement not to appeal do, and do not, foreclose. Two questions help orient the hearing: whether an appeal waiver prevents review at all, and whether complaints about appointed counsel warrant further inquiry. An appeal waiver is a promise to give up specified appellate challenges as part of a plea agreement. It must be knowing and voluntary. Even a valid waiver is not an absolute bar to every challenge: the Supreme Court has recognized a narrow miscarriage-of-justice exception for egregious sentencing errors, not ordinary mistakes. A separate set of rules governs requests for a different appointed lawyer. The Sixth Amendment guarantees effective representation, not a lawyer who agrees with ev

Discuss this episode

Oral Arguments, with Context

Shields v. Port Arthur ISD — 5th Cir. (Nov 4, 2026)

41 min

The Fifth Circuit hears Shields versus Port Arthur Independent School District, a mother's challenge to the dismissal of claims about her son's treatment in special education. Her son, identified publicly as John Doe, is autistic and nonverbal. She alleges that during a fire drill, his teacher hit him with a closed fist and pushed him down onto a curb. She also alleges that school officials failed to act on earlier reports of the teacher's misconduct. Shields will contend that the teacher provoked the encounter and attacked her son, rather than using force for a legitimate disciplinary purpose. The defense will characterize the incident as an attempt to maintain order during the drill. One question concerns substantive due process, the Constitution's protection against certain arbitrary government conduct. Under Fifth Circuit precedent, excessive school discipline generally does not support this particular federal claim when adequate state civil or criminal remedies exist. That rule do

Discuss this episode

Oral Arguments, with Context

Smith v. Smith — 5th Cir. (Nov 3, 2026)

36 min

The Fifth Circuit hears Smith versus Smith, a dispute about medical care for a prisoner with severe chronic pain. Before entering prison, the patient had a spinal cord stimulator implanted to ease his pain, but the device stopped working properly. Doctors recommended repair or replacement, and he says prison officials repeatedly refused under a blanket policy against servicing those devices. The device was later removed, but he maintains that his pain has not been adequately treated. This appeal concerns a medical supervisor, Doctor Smith. The district judge declined to dismiss the claim against him, accepting the pleaded allegations that he either participated in denying care or helped create or implement the policy. That was a pleading decision, not a finding after trial that those allegations are true. The Eighth Amendment prohibits deliberate indifference to serious medical needs, but a mistake, negligence, or disagreement about the best treatment is not automatically a constitutio

Discuss this episode

Oral Arguments, with Context

Greater Guide v. SAPS — 5th Cir. (Nov 3, 2026)

40 min

The Fifth Circuit hears a dispute between businesses that connect online customers with mental health professionals for emotional support animal letters. Greater Guide, which operates American Service Pets, accuses a rival and related defendants of using fictitious customer applications to obtain access to its providers. They then complained about those providers to state licensing boards. Greater Guide says this was a campaign to drive providers away and damage its business. The defendants describe their conduct as legitimate investigation of whether professionals properly evaluated customers before providing the letters. Those competing characterizations are important: the underlying fraud allegations have not been proved at a trial. The district court dismissed the federal claims, ruling that the regulatory complaints were protected and that the computer-fraud and civil racketeering claims were inadequately pleaded. A central issue is Noerr-Pennington, a doctrine generally protectin

Discuss this episode

Oral Arguments, with Context

Fisher v. Texas Tech University — 5th Cir. (Nov 2, 2026)

49 min

The Fifth Circuit hears Fisher versus Texas Tech University, a student speech dispute about a disciplinary record and its consequences for becoming a lawyer. Ellen Fisher was a law student working in a university legal clinic. The university accused her of reacting with celebration to the killing of Charlie Kirk. Fisher disputes that characterization and says the school was punishing protected political expression. The school entered a written reprimand, and the dean reported the discipline to the Texas bar authorities with a recommendation against admitting her. Fisher sued and sought an injunction to undo the discipline and retract the report. The initial order under review denied preliminary relief on sovereign immunity grounds, rather than deciding which of her remarks the First Amendment protects. States ordinarily have immunity from suits of this kind in federal court. A limited exception permits relief against state officials to stop an ongoing violation of federal law. That bri

Discuss this episode

Oral Arguments, with Context

Lignos-López v. Servicios de Terapia Educativa Girasol — 1st Cir. (Nov 4, 2026)

37 min

The First Circuit hears a family's appeal over an injury at a special education school in Puerto Rico. Their child was allegedly struck by another student in December two thousand twenty-one. The parents say he was left injured and bleeding, and that the school failed to seek medical attention or tell them promptly. They describe the incident as part of a larger pattern in which they were kept from learning what was happening to their son at school. Those are allegations, not findings made after a trial. The family's federal claim arises under section nineteen eighty-three, a way to seek relief for federal rights violated under state authority. The school is private, and the district court assumed state action for its analysis without deciding that question. It nevertheless concluded that the complaint did not plausibly allege a constitutional violation. That distinction matters: a school's unreasonable or negligent response does not automatically become a federal constitutional wrong.

Discuss this episode
Older episodes