English-language podcasts

Podcasts

Oral Arguments, with Context

An episode can be the start of a conversation. Explore recent releases, share your thoughts, and meet through a ThinkMatch Roundtable.

Ask friends about this

Episodes to discuss

Oral Arguments, with Context

Kenny A. v. Georgia Department of Human Resources — 11th Cir. (Nov 4, 2026)

26 min

The Eleventh Circuit hears Kenny A. versus Georgia child welfare officials, about whether to end two decades of federal court supervision of foster care reforms. The case began in two thousand two, when children in state foster care in two Georgia counties sued over the protection and services they were receiving. The underlying concerns were practical: keeping children safe and ensuring that their medical and mental health needs were met. In two thousand five, the state and the children settled on a reform plan that the court approved as a consent decree. A consent decree is both an agreement and a court order, not simply a promise the state can withdraw at will. The plan was revised over the years and included monitored performance goals and conditions for ending supervision. Georgia later asked to terminate the decree, citing changes in legislation, agency operations, staffing, and help obtaining health care for foster children. The district judge acknowledged substantial improvemen

Discuss this episode

Oral Arguments, with Context

Huang v. Paxton — 5th Cir. (Nov 2, 2026)

40 min

The Fifth Circuit hears Huang versus Paxton, a challenge involving two Chinese citizens who live outside the United States but already own rental properties in Texas. Huang lives in Shanghai, and Dai lives in New Zealand. They say they want to buy additional Texas property, but a new state law stands in their way. That law, Senate Bill seventeen, restricts real estate acquisitions by certain foreign individuals and entities. The owners sued the Texas attorney general, seeking to prevent enforcement against their proposed purchases. Their complaint describes existing investments and plans to acquire more property; it is not an account of a completed prosecution under this law. They asked for a preliminary injunction, meaning temporary protection while the litigation proceeds. In the ruling under review, the district court refused that protection and dismissed their claims. It concluded that their future purchase plans did not establish a present injury and rejected their reliance on con

Discuss this episode

Oral Arguments, with Context

Frazier v. Collins — Fed. Cir. (Nov 4, 2026)

40 min

The Federal Circuit hears Frazier versus Collins, about what happens to unfinished veterans' benefits claims after the claimant dies. The underlying veteran had sought benefits including adapted housing, automobile adaptive equipment, and special monthly compensation. He died while claims were still pending, and Frazier was allowed to take his place in the administrative appeal. But the Board of Veterans' Appeals dismissed the housing and automobile claims because they were not for recurring monetary benefits. The Veterans Court rejected that restriction and sent those matters back, while also ruling that Frazier's recovery was limited to reimbursing expenses she bore for the veteran's last sickness and burial. That split result explains the two sides of this appeal: the government challenges which benefits can be pursued, and Frazier challenges the reimbursement cap. Two neighboring statutes organize the discussion. Section fifty-one twenty-one, subsection a, governs accrued benefits:

Discuss this episode

Oral Arguments, with Context

Finjan LLC v. Palo Alto Networks, Inc. — Fed. Cir. (Nov 4, 2026)

41 min

The Federal Circuit hears Finjan versus Palo Alto Networks, a dispute over patents for detecting malicious software. Finjan holds cybersecurity patents and sued Palo Alto Networks in California in twenty fourteen, alleging that its security products used patented inventions without permission. The accused products include a next generation firewall and WildFire, a system for examining potentially dangerous files. The dispute is not simply whether those products detect threats: it is whether they satisfy the specific requirements written into the patent claims. In March twenty twenty-five, the district judge granted summary judgment of non-infringement on the three patents remaining at issue. That ended those claims without a jury trial, because the judge found no genuine factual issue requiring one. Finjan is appealing that ruling. Two technical questions will help you follow the discussion. For the patent called the four-oh-eight patent, the claimed method determines the programming l

Discuss this episode

Oral Arguments, with Context

United States v. Joseph Perez-Gonzalez — 1st Cir. (Nov 4, 2026)

27 min

The First Circuit hears United States versus Joseph Perez Gonzalez, an appeal arising from a Puerto Rico drug-trafficking prosecution. A jury convicted Perez Gonzalez after a case involving the organization known as sixty-five Inc. The prosecution described that organization as a drug-distribution network. Keep two kinds of evidence separate as you listen: what a witness says in court, and an earlier statement attributed to another alleged conspirator. Federal evidence rules allow certain statements made during and in furtherance of a conspiracy, but those statements alone cannot establish the conspiracy or participation in it. The other concept is pretrial discovery: the government's duty to permit inspection of qualifying evidence that it intends to use at trial or that is material to preparing the defense. A continuance means postponing proceedings to allow more time. Rule sixteen allows that remedy for a discovery violation; it does not automatically require a new trial. Listen for

Discuss this episode

Oral Arguments, with Context

Guerrero v. Johnson — SCOTUS (Nov 4, 2026)

62 min

The Supreme Court considers whether Dexter Johnson can pursue an intellectual-disability challenge to his Texas death sentence. Johnson was convicted of capital murder in 2007, following a robbery, kidnapping, and killing in 2006. His trial expert did not diagnose intellectual disability, and Johnson did not bring that intellectual-disability claim in his first federal habeas proceeding. Later, diagnostic guidelines published in 2013, known as the DSM-five, reduced emphasis on rigid IQ thresholds and increased attention to adaptive functioning, the practical skills needed in everyday life. Evaluations obtained for Johnson in 2019 supported an intellectual-disability diagnosis under the updated standards. Johnson says his condition did not newly develop; what changed was the framework for recognizing it. That history matters because Atkins versus Virginia, decided in 2002, prohibits executing people with intellectual disability. But that constitutional rule existed before Johnson's crim

Discuss this episode

Oral Arguments, with Context

United States v. Erik Hadad — 11th Cir. (Nov 4, 2026)

27 min

The Eleventh Circuit hears Hadad's challenge to a federal carjacking conviction arising from a dispute over recovering a customer's car. The customer had bought a Honda from a dealership that Hadad operated with his sons. Hadad has described his conduct as an attempt to repossess the vehicle, not an attempt to hurt the customer. The prosecution's account describes a confrontation that escalated: Hadad followed the customer, removed the Honda's temporary license tag at an intersection, and followed him again after he drove away. Prosecutors say that, at a train station, Hadad demanded the keys and lifted his shirt to reveal a gun at his waistband. According to that account, the customer surrendered the keys, and police arrested Hadad at the scene. That is the prosecution's description of the encounter; the meaning of the gun evidence is sharply contested in the argument you will hear. The federal carjacking charge requires more than showing that the customer was frightened: it requires

Discuss this episode

Oral Arguments, with Context

Jyoti Gautam Murray v. Metro Fibernet, LLC — 7th Cir. (Nov 3, 2026)

34 min

We hear a dispute that began with the advertised monthly price of home internet service. In their proposed class-action complaint against the company operating as Metronet, customers say they signed up after seeing an advertised price, then discovered an additional mandatory monthly charge. The complaint calls it the Technology Services Fee, also known as Tech Assure. The customers allege that the charge was separate from the advertised base price and applied even if they never requested a technician's visit or equipment repair. Their complaint explains why that mattered: someone comparing internet providers by their advertised prices would not be comparing the total amount they would actually have to pay. These are allegations of misleading pricing, not findings that the company committed fraud. Murray and another customer brought the lawsuit seeking relief for themselves and a proposed class of other subscribers. The customers' central objection is not simply that an extra fee exists

Discuss this episode

Oral Arguments, with Context

Centripetal Networks, LLC v. Keysight Technologies, Inc. — Fed. Cir. (Nov 4, 2026)

31 min

The Federal Circuit hears Centripetal Networks' appeal from a patent-review decision in a dispute with Keysight Technologies. The patent concerns a network security device changing the rules it uses to process incoming data. The claimed method prepares rule sets before implementing them, pauses processing when changing rules, and caches unprocessed packets so they can later be processed under the new rules. Caching means temporarily storing those packets, rather than continuing to process them under the old rules. Keysight challenged the patent before the Patent Trial and Appeal Board, arguing that combinations of earlier technical publications made the claimed method obvious. The board agreed and held the challenged claims unpatentable. After the board denied reconsideration, Centripetal brought this appeal. One central disagreement concerns whether the earlier technology teaches caching entire packets, not merely selected portions. A packet may include a header and a data payload; so

Discuss this episode

Oral Arguments, with Context

Antonio Torres v. Jeremiah Cecil Byous — 5th Cir. (Nov 4, 2026)

38 min

The Fifth Circuit hears Antonio Torres's appeal in an excessive-force case against a Dallas police officer. After an encounter beside a pickup truck, Torres pulled away from an attempted handcuffing and ran. During the chase, he tipped a trash can into the officer's path. The officer fell and hurt his knee, but continued the pursuit. Torres reached a fence and turned around. The officer caught him and struck him twice in the head with a hand that still held metal handcuffs. Torres was bleeding, and he later sued over the force used against him. The central dispute is what was happening at the moment of those blows. Had Torres stopped resisting, or was the officer still bringing an actively resisting suspect under control? The district court granted the officer qualified immunity and dismissed the case. It did not decide whether the force violated the Fourth Amendment. Instead, it held that prior decisions did not clearly establish that the particular conduct was unlawful. The court lat

Discuss this episode

Oral Arguments, with Context

Matterhorn Express Pipeline, LLC v. Federal Energy Regulatory Commission — 5th Cir. (Nov 3, 2026)

37 min

The Fifth Circuit hears Matterhorn Express Pipeline's challenge to the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission. Matterhorn operates a natural gas pipeline within Texas. It also provides interstate transportation under section three eleven of the Natural Gas Policy Act. For that service, it chose a regulatory route allowing it to rely on rates already approved by the Railroad Commission of Texas. The federal commission accepted Matterhorn's operating conditions, but directed the company to change its rates. The disagreement concerns how the charges are designed, not simply whether the total price is too high. Matterhorn proposed a one-part transportation rate. The commission instead required a method called straight fixed variable, which separates recovery of fixed costs from charges for variable costs. It also rejected a minimum rate of zero because it found that Matterhorn had variable operating costs. Matterhorn sought reconsideration, but the commission maintained those requirements. T

Discuss this episode

Oral Arguments, with Context

Terrill Jenkins v. State of Florida — 11th Cir. (Nov 4, 2026)

25 min

The Eleventh Circuit hears Jenkins versus Florida, a challenge to a burglary conviction after a confrontation with his former girlfriend. She had gone to her mother's house, and Jenkins followed her inside. According to her trial testimony, she tried to close the door, but he pushed it open, and a struggle followed. His defense emphasized his previous visits and testimony that he had been welcome there. The jury convicted him of burglary with battery. This appeal concerns his trial lawyer's failure to request a specific instruction about licensed or invited entry, a potential defense to burglary. The lawyer argued that he had permission to enter, but did not ask for the instruction that Jenkins says would have told jurors how to apply that defense. State courts rejected his ineffective-assistance claim, and a federal district judge denied his petition for habeas corpus, his request for federal relief from the state conviction. Jenkins now appeals that denial; this is not another direct

Discuss this episode

Oral Arguments, with Context

Assist Wireless, LLC, et al. v. Federal Communications Commission — 5th Cir. (Nov 2, 2026)

31 min

The Fifth Circuit hears Assist Wireless and other providers challenging the Federal Communications Commission's denial of additional Lifeline payments. Lifeline helps qualifying low-income households obtain phone service. For customers who pay no monthly service fee, its ordinary rules tie provider reimbursement to recent use. After thirty days without use, subscribers receive a fifteen-day chance to resume using the service before removal from the program. Providers cannot claim payment for subscribers who remain in that cure period on the monthly eligibility snapshot date. During the pandemic, the commission temporarily waived the non-use requirements to protect access. The providers later sought higher reimbursements for April twenty twenty-one, using the May first subscriber snapshot. The program administrator rejected those requests, and the commission upheld the denial. The dispute is whether the waiver still covered May first. If the providers are right, the affected subscribers

Discuss this episode

Oral Arguments, with Context

O. E. v. Advocates for Arts-Based Education — 5th Cir. (Nov 4, 2026)

47 min

The Fifth Circuit hears a dispute over access to a New Orleans public charter school. O E, a child with profound intellectual and physical disabilities, applied to the Willow School. His parents asked it to waive the reading and math assessment, saying his disability made the required score unattainable. Willow offered testing accommodations, including extra time and a quiet room, but would not waive the assessment. He took it, did not reach the eligibility threshold, and was not eligible for admission. His family sued under the Americans with Disabilities Act and the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act, the federal special-education law. The district court dismissed the federal claims at the pleading stage and denied a preliminary injunction against the testing rule. O E now appeals. The dispute is about this particular school's duties, not whether children with disabilities have a right to public education. The parties agree he is receiving special-education services at anoth

Discuss this episode

Oral Arguments, with Context

Digital Broadcasting Solutions, LLC v. DISH Network L.L.C. — Fed. Cir. (Nov 4, 2026)

40 min

The Federal Circuit hears Digital Broadcasting Solutions versus Dish Network, a dispute about patents for recording television and controlling playback. The patents describe recorders that can require a program to be played with its commercials during an initial period, while allowing a different playback choice later. One patent also addresses receiving several programs at once on a single transmission channel, with one command instructing the recorder to receive and store them. Dish challenged the patents at the Patent Trial and Appeal Board using earlier technology. The Board found all challenged claims of one patent unpatentable, and all but one of the challenged claims in the other. Digital Broadcasting appeals its losses; Dish cross-appeals the claim it failed to defeat. So each side is defending part of the Board's work and challenging another part. Digital Broadcasting will argue that the earlier references do not establish the required features and that the petition did not pr

Discuss this episode

Oral Arguments, with Context

Brenda Ramos v. Christopher Taylor — 5th Cir. (Nov 3, 2026)

44 min

The Fifth Circuit hears Ramos versus Taylor, a civil case arising from a fatal police shooting in an Austin apartment parking lot. Officers arrived after a caller reported a man with a gun, and blocked the parking lot's exit. During the encounter, another officer fired a less-lethal round. Mike Ramos got back into his car, the car moved, and Officer Christopher Taylor fired shots that killed him. Ramos's mother sued, alleging excessive force. The central factual disagreement is what danger the moving car presented. Taylor says a reasonable officer could have believed Ramos would drive through the police blockade. His mother says he was turning away from the officers toward a dead end. The district judge refused to dismiss her claim, accepting her allegations for that early stage rather than deciding responsibility after a trial. Taylor later supplied recordings with a records custodian's authentication and again sought dismissal; the judge again refused. That history creates a threshol

Discuss this episode

Oral Arguments, with Context

Carla Hall v. LaSalle Management Company, et al. — 5th Cir. (Nov 3, 2026)

44 min

The Fifth Circuit hears an employment case brought by Carla Hall, a nurse at the Jackson Parish Correctional Center in Louisiana. Hall says she faced racial discrimination in staffing support and workplace treatment, and that her complaints led to threats rather than an effective response. She later resigned and sued. A central dispute concerns a meeting with the nursing staff. Hall says the sheriff told nurses they could hit the door if they continued making racial complaints. The defendants say the remark concerned staff bickering, not complaints about race. They also point to the sheriff asking Hall to stay, and challenge whether her sworn declaration fits her earlier testimony. The district judge granted summary judgment for the defendants, finding the record insufficient to support her remaining claims without a trial. Hall will argue that the court drew the wrong inferences and failed to apply the proper retaliation standard. The defendants will answer that the record presents no

Discuss this episode

Oral Arguments, with Context

Riggins v. Garcia — 5th Cir. (Nov 4, 2026)

41 min

The Fifth Circuit hears Riggins versus Garcia, a lawsuit arising from a death in a Texas jail. After his arrest for driving while intoxicated, Mr. Riggins was booked into Grayson County Jail. Three days later, he was dead. His family alleges that he suffered severe alcohol withdrawal, including seizures, while held in an observation cell, and that jailers failed to summon medical care despite knowing he needed help. A district judge refused to dismiss the claims against four jailers, who now seek qualified immunity on appeal. That ruling allowed the claims to continue; it did not establish that the family's allegations were proved. The jailers will argue that the complaint does not adequately explain what each individual actually knew, and that the symptoms attributed to particular officers were ambiguous. The family will counter that the symptoms must be considered together with the observation-cell setting and each jailer's opportunity to see what was happening. Listen for the distin

Discuss this episode

Oral Arguments, with Context

McKenzie Jones v. Unum Life Insurance Company of America — 7th Cir. (Nov 4, 2026)

33 min

The Seventh Circuit hears McKenzie Jones's dispute with Unum over long-term disability benefits. Jones worked for Whole Foods and stopped working, reporting back pain. He sought benefits through his employer's insurance plan, but Unum ended his long-term payments. The plan did not ask only whether he could work. It also said he must be under the regular care of a physician. That requirement became decisive in court. A district judge found that Jones had not shown the required care and ruled for Unum, without deciding which occupation applied or whether Jones could perform its duties. Jones says Unum did not clearly identify the regular-care requirement as a separate reason for denying benefits until litigation. References to treatment in a denial letter, he argues, are not the same as giving timely, specific notice of that reason. Unum disagrees and argues that the judge had to make a fresh, independent decision about entitlement under the plan. Listen for the difference between adding

Discuss this episode

Oral Arguments, with Context

United States v. Rhode Island Hospital — 5th Cir. (Nov 4, 2026)

44 min

The Fifth Circuit considers a federal demand for Rhode Island Hospital's records about treatment of young people with gender dysphoria. The Justice Department says it is investigating possible drug misbranding and health-care fraud involving puberty blockers and hormone treatments. Its subpoena sought patient records, billing information, personnel files, and communications with drug makers. The hospital and the government discussed production for months. Then the government asked a federal judge in Texas to enforce the demand. The judge entered an enforcement order that same evening, before the hospital had an opportunity to respond in court. The hospital appealed, arguing that it should have been heard before a binding judgment was entered. Later filings and requests to pause enforcement became part of the dispute. A separate Rhode Island proceeding added another complication: a judge there quashed the same subpoena and restricted the government's receipt of patient information. That

Discuss this episode

Oral Arguments, with Context

United States v. Gary Haynes — 5th Cir. (Nov 3, 2026)

42 min

The Fifth Circuit hears Gary Haynes's challenge to his federal convictions. Haynes was an assistant district attorney who oversaw a pretrial intervention program in Louisiana. The program offered some people facing criminal charges a way to complete classes and other requirements instead of going through ordinary prosecution. Successful completion could lead to dismissal of their charges. Prosecutors alleged that Haynes and a colleague steered participants to a private vendor's paid courses in exchange for promised kickbacks. A federal jury convicted Haynes of bribery-related offenses, conspiracy to commit money laundering, and obstruction of justice. The argument you are about to hear concerns the fairness of that trial and the evidence the jury was allowed to consider. When does evidence of other alleged wrongdoing help explain a defendant's knowledge or intent, and when does it invite guilt by association? Keep the referral scheme actually charged separate from the other allegations

Discuss this episode

Oral Arguments, with Context

United States v. Nathan Reis — 5th Cir. (Nov 3, 2026)

41 min

The Fifth Circuit considers Nathan Reis's sentence for pandemic-relief loan fraud. Reis co-founded Blueacorn, a service provider that helped applicants obtain loans through the federal Paycheck Protection Program. The company earned money as loans were funded. Reis and others used false applications to obtain money for borrowers who did not qualify. He pleaded guilty to joining the fraud conspiracy. The district judge sentenced him to ten years in prison and ordered more than sixty-six million dollars in restitution. The argument you are about to hear concerns the loss calculation behind that punishment, not whether Reis participated in fraud. How much loan money was actually lost through conduct for which he can be held responsible? Listen for the difference between a warning sign that a loan might be fraudulent and evidence that it was fraudulent. The lawyers will discuss loan spreadsheets, individual applications and the scale of the wider scheme. Keep two consequences in mind: the

Discuss this episode

Oral Arguments, with Context

United States v. Brandon Johnson — 7th Cir. (Nov 3, 2026)

24 min

The Seventh Circuit hears Brandon Johnson's challenge to a police search of his girlfriend's home. In January 2020, Chicago officers were investigating a woman's report that Johnson had threatened her with a gun. His girlfriend let them into the home, where children were present, and gestured toward the stairs while discussing whom they could speak to. Some officers went upstairs with her; others went to a rear room on the first floor and found Johnson. A gun was recovered during a later patdown. Johnson asked that the gun evidence be excluded from his federal prosecution, but the district judge refused. The key question here is whether officers could enter that downstairs room in the first place. Johnson's lawyer will argue that the permission covered going upstairs to speak with people there, not searching the first floor. The government's lawyer will argue that she gave broader permission, and that the gun report and music from the back room justified a limited officer-safety sweep.

Discuss this episode

Oral Arguments, with Context

Coffey v. Kerrisdale Capital Management — 7th Cir. (Nov 4, 2026)

32 min

The Seventh Circuit considers where Elizabeth Coffey's securities-fraud suit against Kerrisdale Capital Management can be heard. Coffey and another investor sold shares of C3.ai after reading a letter from Kerrisdale, a short-selling investment fund, accusing the company of deceptive accounting. Short sellers can profit when a stock's price falls. The investors accuse the fund and its chief of deliberately misleading the market for profit. Those are allegations, not findings of fraud. The letter appeared online, and the fund's chief discussed it on television. Coffey received the letter in Illinois, and the investors sued there. But the district judge dismissed the case for improper venue: the rules about which federal district is a proper place to bring a lawsuit. The judge did not decide whether the letter was fraudulent. The investors' lawyer will argue that the report's broad distribution and an investor's receipt and reliance in Illinois connect the alleged violation to that distr

Discuss this episode
Older episodes