English-language podcasts

Podcasts

Oral Arguments, with Context

An episode can be the start of a conversation. Explore recent releases, share your thoughts, and meet through a ThinkMatch Roundtable.

Ask friends about this

Episodes to discuss

Oral Arguments, with Context

Adidas v. Localityi.com — 11th Cir. (Nov 4, 2026)

33 min

The Eleventh Circuit hears an appeal by two overseas online sellers in a trademark case brought by Adidas. Adidas accused the websites of selling counterfeit products bearing its marks. The district court authorized Adidas to serve the lawsuit by email and by posting documents on a notice website. The sellers' lawyer appeared before judgment, but they did not defend the claims before the court entered a default judgment. About five months later, they asked to set it aside, challenging service and offering settlement negotiations as a reason for the delay. The district judge upheld service and refused to reopen the judgment. Their lawyer will argue that the Hague Service Convention, which governs delivery of lawsuit papers abroad, did not permit this method and left the court without jurisdiction. He will say their settlement efforts justify the time they took to challenge the judgment. The lawyer for Adidas will argue that the electronic service was permissible and that the sellers wai

Discuss this episode

Oral Arguments, with Context

Melgaard v. Wisconsin DNR — 7th Cir. (Nov 4, 2026)

38 min

The Seventh Circuit hears Michael Melgaard's retaliation case against Wisconsin's Department of Natural Resources and two supervisors. Melgaard was a conservation warden who supported a colleague's discrimination complaint against the department. He says supervisors then singled him out for sharing a work vehicle with another warden, contrary to pandemic safety rules. The department investigated, decided no formal discipline was needed, then issued a letter of expectations and a partly negative performance review. Melgaard says those actions, taken together, were retaliation for supporting the complaint. He sued the department under federal employment law and the supervisors personally for alleged First Amendment violations. The district judge dismissed the constitutional claims on sovereign-immunity grounds, treating them as effectively against the state. The judge also rejected the employment claim because the conduct was not sufficiently severe or pervasive to change working conditi

Discuss this episode

Oral Arguments, with Context

TK Elevator v. Church Mutual — 7th Cir. (Nov 4, 2026)

25 min

The Seventh Circuit hears TK Elevator challenge Church Mutual over who must defend it in lawsuits arising from an elevator accident. An employee at an Illinois senior-living facility alleged that she was injured when an elevator fell while she was riding it. She sued the elevator maintenance company, TK Elevator. The maintenance contract called for the property's insurance to cover TK first, without drawing on the company's own insurance. But TK was not named on Church Mutual's primary liability policy. It qualified for coverage under Church Mutual's umbrella policy, which generally sits above other insurance. TK also had coverage from HDI. The district judge held that the remaining HDI coverage had to be exhausted before Church Mutual had a duty to defend TK. The company's lawyer will argue that an endorsement in the HDI policy, read with the maintenance agreement, reverses that order and puts Church Mutual first. Church Mutual's lawyer will argue that a promise to obtain insurance do

Discuss this episode

Oral Arguments, with Context

Vistra v. FERC — 5th Cir. (Nov 4, 2026)

64 min

The Fifth Circuit hears Vistra and other electricity producers challenge a federal rule ending certain payments for reactive power. Unlike the real power that runs appliances, reactive power supports the voltage needed to deliver electricity reliably. Some grid operators separately paid generators for that support within a standard operating range, often called the dead band. Order 904 from FERC ends those charges in transmission rates; payments outside that range are not eliminated by this rule. FERC reaffirmed the rule after rehearing, and the generators sought judicial review. The generators' lawyers will argue that equipment costs and lost opportunities to sell electricity make the rule unreasonable. They will also argue that long-term contracts and investments relied on revenues the rule removes. The lawyer for FERC will argue that this is a normal obligation of connecting to the grid, with little or no additional cost. She will say generators can recover costs through electricity

Discuss this episode

Oral Arguments, with Context

Jones v. SEC — 5th Cir. (Nov 2, 2026)

32 min

The Fifth Circuit hears Robbi Jones and Kipling Jones and Company's challenge to sanctions upheld by the Securities and Exchange Commission. The dispute began with a certificate of deposit pledged as loan collateral but counted toward the firm's required net capital. FINRA, the securities industry's self-regulatory organization, found that this overstated the firm's financial cushion and produced inaccurate records and reports. It also found that Jones gave misleading answers and failed to cooperate fully with its investigation. On FINRA appeal, a two-year suspension was increased to a bar from associating with FINRA member firms in any capacity. The SEC later upheld the violations and sanctions after a review that took years. Jones and her firm now argue that the penalty was excessive and that the process was constitutionally defective. Their lawyer will argue that FINRA functions as a government enforcer, even though it is organized as a private body. He will question whether SEC ove

Discuss this episode

Oral Arguments, with Context

Melvin Gene Hodges v. Commissioner, Alabama Department of Corrections — 11th Cir. (Nov 4, 2026)

66 min

The Eleventh Circuit hears Melvin Hodges's challenge to his capital murder conviction and death sentence. Hodges was convicted of murdering Beth Seaton during a robbery. A van was used to kill her, and the evidence placing Hodges behind its wheel is one part of the dispute. A co-defendant testified against him under a plea agreement, and cigarette-butt DNA evidence was used to connect him to the driver's side. The jury recommended life without parole by eight votes to four. The trial judge instead imposed a death sentence. After state-court review, Hodges sought federal habeas relief, asking a federal court to overturn his conviction or sentence on constitutional grounds. The district court denied relief, and he is appealing. His lawyer will argue that the denial of expert funding and an inadequate investigation left critical evidence about his childhood abuse and mental condition out of the sentencing case. She will also challenge trial counsel's failure to object when the prosecutor

Discuss this episode

Oral Arguments, with Context

Pearl Resources v. Buckingham — 5th Cir. (Nov 4, 2026)

43 min

The Fifth Circuit hears an oil-and-gas lease dispute between Pearl Resources and the Texas General Land Office. The agency claimed that parts of Pearl's state leases had expired because continuous drilling requirements were not met. Pearl maintained that its well preparation and infrastructure work kept its rights alive. Shortly after the state recorded the partial termination, Pearl filed for Chapter Eleven bankruptcy. The agency went to bankruptcy court to seek a ruling on the leasehold rights. Pearl counterclaimed for breach of contract, saying the termination had blocked development. After trial, the judge rejected the partial termination claim and found damages to Pearl. The judge initially barred recovery on immunity grounds, then reconsidered and held that the state had waived immunity from liability by failing to plead that defense. After offsets, the result was a judgment for more than forty million dollars against the Land Office. The damages reflected delay: increased drilli

Discuss this episode

Oral Arguments, with Context

David Lin v. Franciscan Alliance, Inc. — 7th Cir. (Nov 3, 2026)

33 min

The Seventh Circuit hears David Lin's employment dispute with Franciscan Alliance and Franciscan Physician Network. Lin worked as an infectious disease physician. Early in the COVID pandemic, he advocated N95 masks for staff treating patients with known or suspected COVID. He says the response became part of discriminatory treatment against him. The dispute also involves repeated peer reviews of his antibiotic prescribing. Reviewers criticized some of his cases; Lin disputed the process and complained of discrimination. His lawsuit alleges race and national origin discrimination and retaliation. He also contends that his resignation was a forced departure, rather than a free choice. Franciscan says the reviews were legitimate quality controls and that he chose to resign. The district court granted summary judgment on the federal discrimination and retaliation claims, finding insufficient evidence connecting the challenged treatment to race or national origin and rejecting constructive

Discuss this episode

Oral Arguments, with Context

Irwin v. Hill — 5th Cir. (Nov 2, 2026)

32 min

The Fifth Circuit hears Irwin versus Hill, a dispute over whether an old family settlement can block a new lawsuit seeking answers about a trust. Albert Hill the Third sued over the management of two Hunt family trusts and his rights as a beneficiary. That litigation was settled in 2010, with the agreement incorporated into a federal judgment. Among its terms was a waiver of rights to demand information or accountings from certain trusts while a party was not a current beneficiary. Years later, his daughter Caroline Hill brought a probate-court case about the separate Lyda Hunt–Margaret Trust. She alleges that her grandfather and his co-trustees improperly depleted and dissolved that trust, leaving nothing for the grandchildren. She seeks an accounting of what happened to its assets. The trust was dissolved in 2016, before her grandfather died the following year. The estate representatives opposing her suit say the settlement bars her claims and asked the federal court to stop the stat

Discuss this episode

Oral Arguments, with Context

Pollock v. American Endowment Foundation — 5th Cir. (Nov 3, 2026)

42 min

The Fifth Circuit hears John Pollock's dispute with American Endowment Foundation over advisory rights in a charitable fund. In his application for a donor-advised fund, Herbert Bennett named himself as donor advisor and Pollock as financial advisor. Shortly after that application, Bennett sent a letter saying Pollock could make grants on his behalf. Pollock says that letter made him a donor advisor too, not merely an investment professional. After Bennett died, the foundation would not recognize Pollock's claimed grant-advisory role. Pollock says he stopped serving as financial advisor, but the foundation still would not consider his grant recommendations. The dispute is about his claimed advisory role, not ownership of the charitable money. The foundation disputes that Bennett's letter changed Pollock's rights under the fund agreement. The district court considered the letter, but dismissed Pollock's second amended complaint because he had not plausibly alleged the foundation's accep

Discuss this episode

Oral Arguments, with Context

Safari Childcare v. Penny — 7th Cir. (Nov 4, 2026)

27 min

The Seventh Circuit hears Safari Childcare's challenge to a judgment for Illinois child-welfare employees. Safari and its owner ran a chain of day-care centers that came under repeated licensing investigations and enforcement. They say regulators singled them out for harsher treatment than comparable centers and retaliated after staff called the police or sought help from legislators. They point to hostile internal emails as evidence that officials were working together against the business. The employees defend their actions as legitimate responses to licensing violations, not punishment for complaints. Safari brought equal-protection, First Amendment retaliation, and civil-conspiracy claims. The district court ruled for the employees without a trial. It first rejected the retaliation and conspiracy claims, while giving Safari another chance to present its equal-protection evidence. In the final ruling, the judge struck Safari's additional factual statement for failing to follow local

Discuss this episode

Oral Arguments, with Context

Global Network Management v. Cirion Technologies Solutions — 11th Cir. (Nov 4, 2026)

33 min

The Eleventh Circuit hears a dispute over thirteen hundred eighty memory cards missing from computer servers. Global Network seeks to hold the data-center operator responsible for that physical property. The theory is bailment: responsibility arising from having someone else's property in one's custody. This litigation has already been to the appeals court. In 2023, the court revived the implied-bailment claim because Global Network had plausibly alleged that the operator exercised practical control over the equipment. That allowed the claim to proceed past dismissal; it did not establish that a bailment actually existed or that the operator was liable. The earlier opinion accepted the complaint's allegations as true, including its description of the property as Global Network's. Do not treat ownership as settled when listening to this argument. Keep separate who owns the cards, who may lawfully possess them, and who had physical control. Also listen for what was actually presented to

Discuss this episode

Oral Arguments, with Context

Wesco v. 2026 Noteholders — 5th Cir. (Nov 2, 2026)

44 min

The Fifth Circuit considers a fight over a two-hundred-fifty-million-dollar financing deal for Wesco Aircraft Holdings. In 2022, the company needed cash, and a group of its bondholders supplied new money in exchange for a better position in its debt structure. Other bondholders were excluded from that deal, and the collateral backing their existing bonds was released. The dispute concerns the so-called 2026 notes and their indenture, the contract governing those bonds. Releasing their collateral required consent from two-thirds of the outstanding debt, but the participating group initially held less than that. The group first approved changes allowing new bonds, bought them for two hundred fifty million dollars, and counted those new bonds toward the later vote to release the collateral. The excluded investors say that sequence defeated the protection they had bargained for. Wesco entered bankruptcy in 2023. A bankruptcy judge recommended treating the original bondholders' liens as sti

Discuss this episode

Oral Arguments, with Context

Joe Neguse v. U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement — D.C. Cir. (Nov 3, 2026)

55 min

The D.C. Circuit considers a dispute over lawmakers' access to immigration detention facilities. In June 2025, Immigration and Customs Enforcement adopted a policy requiring members of Congress to give seven days' notice before visiting detention facilities. Lawmakers wanted to inspect conditions and gather information for their oversight work, but several were turned away for failing to give advance notice. They sued, pointing to Section Five Twenty-Seven, a spending restriction that bars the use of covered funds to prevent congressional oversight visits and says members need not provide prior notice. A district court suspended the policy. In January 2026, the Department of Homeland Security reinstated the notice requirement, saying it would use funding not subject to that restriction. The district court again blocked the policy, and the government appealed. Much of this argument concerns standing: whether these lawmakers have the kind of injury that allows them to bring this lawsuit

Discuss this episode

Oral Arguments, with Context

Ralph Bronson Fils-Aime v. Todd Blanche — 1st Cir. (Nov 3, 2026)

37 min

The First Circuit hears a Haitian man's challenge to being sent to Mexico. An immigration judge had already granted him withholding of removal to Haiti, protecting him from deportation to that country. But in July 2025, the Department of Homeland Security told him it intended to remove him to Mexico instead. He says he was kidnapped and threatened with death in Mexico while traveling to the United States. He asked to reopen his immigration case and sought review in the First Circuit. Withholding is country-specific: protection against return to Haiti does not automatically prevent removal somewhere else. A motion to reopen asks the immigration agency to reconsider a completed case in light of new facts. You will hear ultra vires, meaning action beyond an official's lawful authority. Statutory withholding requires a connection between threatened persecution and a protected ground, such as race or nationality. Protection under the Convention Against Torture has a different focus: whether

Discuss this episode

Oral Arguments, with Context

Solomon Btesh v. Isaac Btesh — 11th Cir. (Nov 3, 2026)

45 min

The Eleventh Circuit hears Solomon versus Isaac Btesh. The brothers are disputing their interests in a family bank in Panama and the proceeds of its sale. A family agreement referred disputes to procedures used by a Jewish congregation there. Solomon began arbitration in Panama, then pursued proceedings in Miami. A Miami rabbinical panel issued an award against Isaac, who did not participate in that arbitration. Solomon asked a Florida federal court to confirm the award, meaning turn it into an enforceable court judgment. The judge dismissed the petition for lack of personal jurisdiction: the court's power over Isaac. That differs from the arbitrators' authority under the family agreement. One route discussed here is Rule 4(k)(2), a federal rule for federal claims when no state's courts can exercise jurisdiction over the defendant. It looks beyond a single state, but exercising jurisdiction must still be constitutional. Another route, quasi in rem jurisdiction, concerns specified prope

Discuss this episode

Oral Arguments, with Context

United States v. Mercado-Cañizares — 1st Cir. (Nov 3, 2026)

25 min

The First Circuit hears United States versus Jorge Mercado. After serving time for an armed robbery, Mercado was on supervised release, a period of court-ordered supervision after prison. During that supervision, he possessed a machine gun and ammunition. That conduct led to a new criminal sentence and a separate prison term for violating his release conditions. In an earlier appeal, the First Circuit left the machine-gun sentence in place but vacated the revocation sentence because the judge had not adequately explained why it exceeded the advisory sentencing range. This appeal returns to those limits on revocation sentencing. An upward variance means a sentence above that advisory range, not necessarily above the statutory maximum. Another distinction runs through the argument: retribution means punishment because past wrongdoing deserves it; deterrence aims to prevent future crime. The Supreme Court has held that judges may not rely on retribution for the original offense when revok

Discuss this episode

Oral Arguments, with Context

Joy Laskar v. Hurd et al. — 11th Cir. (Nov 3, 2026)

31 min

The Eleventh Circuit hears Joy Laskar versus Phillip Hurd and Patrick Jenkins. Laskar was a Georgia Tech professor who also ran a wireless-technology startup. University auditors investigated whether the company had improperly used university money, microchips, facilities and staff. Their report was referred to state law enforcement, and a criminal investigation and arrest followed. Laskar denies wrongdoing, saying the company was permitted to use university resources through its research-center relationship. The criminal case was dismissed as time-barred: it was brought too late, not resolved by a jury verdict. Laskar then sued university officials for damages, alleging malicious prosecution in violation of the Fourth Amendment. That civil claim concerns an allegedly unlawful deprivation of liberty through criminal legal process. An earlier appeal allowed his claims against Hurd and Jenkins to proceed at the pleading stage, accepting his allegations as true rather than deciding whethe

Discuss this episode

Oral Arguments, with Context

Robocast v. Netflix — Fed. Cir. (Nov 3, 2026)

22 min

The Federal Circuit hears Robocast versus Netflix. Robocast sued Netflix over patents for automatically presenting online content. Instead of a user repeatedly opening separate pages, the patents describe software that arranges content and presents it in sequence. A Delaware federal judge granted Netflix summary judgment, ruling before trial that the asserted patent claims were ineligible for protection. The court treated them as abstract content organization and display carried out on conventional computers. Robocast challenges that characterization. It says its software structure improves how the computer operates, not merely the user's experience. This appeal concerns patent eligibility, rather than whether Netflix infringed. Patent claims define what an invention's legal protection covers. Under the Supreme Court's Alice framework, the court first asks whether the claims are directed to an abstract idea. If so, it asks whether their features, individually and together, add an inven

Discuss this episode

Oral Arguments, with Context

Hospital Menonita Ponce v. National Labor Relations Board — 1st Cir. (Nov 3, 2026)

55 min

The First Circuit hears Hospital Menonita Ponce versus the National Labor Relations Board. After a hospital-asset purchase in Puerto Rico in 2022, Menonita Ponce faced a dispute over its employees' union representation. The union had represented seven groups under the previous operator. Menonita Ponce recognized the union for two groups, then withdrew recognition, saying the union lacked employee support. The union filed charges alleging unlawful refusals to recognize or bargain and retaliation in hiring; the hospital denies violating labor law. It also filed a separate constitutional lawsuit. It challenges rules limiting the President's power to remove Board members and administrative law judges, the agency's hearing officers. The hospital sought a preliminary injunction, a temporary order stopping the agency proceeding. The district court refused, invoking the Norris-LaGuardia Act's restriction on labor-related injunctions and, alternatively, the hospital's failure to meet the ordina

Discuss this episode

Oral Arguments, with Context

Fraud Free Transactions v. Ping Identity — Fed. Cir. (Nov 3, 2026)

33 min

The Federal Circuit hears Fraud Free Transactions versus Ping Identity. Fraud Free sued Ping for allegedly infringing two patents on checking online users' identities. One adjusts verification requirements to the risk associated with an access request. The other uses an app on a registered phone to approve or deny access from another device. This is out-of-band verification: using a separate channel to confirm the request. The patent owner says its phone-app method improves security over verification by text message or phone call. A Delaware federal judge dismissed the asserted patent claims before trial, finding them ineligible for patent protection. The appeal concerns that threshold, not whether Ping infringed. Patent claims define the invention for which protection is sought. The question is whether these claims cover a specific technological solution or an abstract way of verifying identity. Under the Supreme Court's Alice framework, the court first asks whether the claims are dir

Discuss this episode

Oral Arguments, with Context

McCarthy v. Massachusetts Department of Children and Families — 1st Cir. (Nov 3, 2026)

26 min

The First Circuit hears Audrey McCarthy versus the Massachusetts Department of Children and Families. McCarthy worked as an administrative manager for the department. In 2021, she asked for a medical exemption from the employee COVID vaccination requirement, citing a heart condition. The department's letter acknowledged a medical contraindication, a reason a treatment may be unsuitable, but denied the exemption, citing workplace safety and operational concerns. She brought a disability-discrimination case under the Americans with Disabilities Act and the Rehabilitation Act. The district judge ruled for the department without a trial. The court found that the evidence did not establish a workable accommodation or adequately connect the requested exemption to her asserted disability. McCarthy contends that her own medical record and job duties called for an individual assessment. A qualified individual is someone able to perform a job's essential duties with or without a reasonable accom

Discuss this episode

Oral Arguments, with Context

United States v. Luz Paulino — 1st Cir. (Nov 3, 2026)

19 min

The First Circuit hears United States versus Luz Paulino. The case grew out of a tax-refund-loan scheme in Massachusetts. Investigators described stolen identities and false tax returns being used to obtain and cash bank loans against expected refunds. Paulino later received a prison sentence, and this appeal challenges the calculation of her advisory sentencing range. Those federal guidelines guide the judge, but do not dictate the final sentence. For financial crimes, the amount of loss can increase that range. Actual loss is financial harm the offense caused; intended loss is harm the defendant purposely sought. The central question is whether the court could count intended loss under commentary: explanatory notes accompanying the guideline. The Sentencing Commission later moved that rule into the guideline itself. The judges will discuss whether that change merely clarified the earlier rule, and whether a prior robbery-conspiracy case called Walker controls here. They will also dis

Discuss this episode

Oral Arguments, with Context

National Wildlife Federation v. U.S. Army Corps of Engineers — 11th Cir. (Nov 3, 2026)

29 min

The Eleventh Circuit hears National Wildlife Federation versus the Army Corps of Engineers. The Corps operates reservoirs in the Apalachicola, Chattahoochee, and Flint river system, known as the ACF basin. Those operations affect freshwater reaching Florida's Apalachicola River, floodplain, and bay. In 2017, the Corps adopted updated operating rules for water supply, flood control, and other authorized uses. Conservation groups challenged the manual and its environmental analysis, saying the Corps had understated future harm to downstream habitats and dismissed reasonable alternatives. The Corps, Georgia, and local water providers defend the manual. The district court ruled for the Corps. The appeal centers on NEPA, the National Environmental Policy Act, and the Water Resources Development Act. NEPA calls for environmental review, not a particular environmental outcome. An environmental impact statement, or EIS, examines effects and alternatives. The Supreme Court's Seven County decisi

Discuss this episode
Older episodes