English-language podcasts

Podcasts

Oral Arguments, with Context

An episode can be the start of a conversation. Explore recent releases, share your thoughts, and meet through a ThinkMatch Roundtable.

Ask friends about this

Episodes to discuss

Oral Arguments, with Context

In re Jiaxing Super Lighting Electric Appliance Co., Ltd. — Fed. Cir. (Nov 3, 2026)

21 min

The Federal Circuit considers Super Lighting's LED tube-lamp patent. The design places a strip of LEDs inside the tube and its power supply in one or both end caps. The patent has faced challenges in infringement litigation and Patent Office reexamination. The owner has brought that Patent Office dispute to the Federal Circuit. This appeal focuses on a proposed change to an earlier lamp: moving its power supply from the LED strip into an end cap. Earlier published technology is called prior art. The question is whether the office gave a sufficient reason for an engineer to make that change. Obviousness is the legal test for whether a claimed design would have been an ordinary step for a skilled engineer, rather than a patentable advance. The Supreme Court's KSR decision allows a flexible, common-sense analysis, but calls for a reasoned explanation. Listen for the difference between a predictable design choice and using the patent itself as a recipe to reconstruct the invention. In re J

Discuss this episode

Oral Arguments, with Context

Monette v. Collins — Fed. Cir. (Nov 3, 2026)

26 min

The Federal Circuit hears Monette versus Collins. James Monette sought veterans' disability benefits for a mental-health condition he linked to military service. The Board of Veterans' Appeals denied the claim in 1990. Old service records were later added to his file, and the Board denied the claim again in 2004. The Board recognized the condition as linked to service in 2014, but Monette now seeks to have the earlier denial revisited. He filed a motion alleging clear and unmistakable error, or CUE. This is a very narrow way to attack a final decision for an undebatable, outcome-changing mistake, based on the record and law at the time. The Board rejected that attack, and the Veterans Court affirmed. The Board had held that the later-added records were not legally before it in 1990. That finding concerned constructive possession: treating records as legally available even though they were not actually in the claim file. A separate regulation, section 3.156(c), can require reconsiderati

Discuss this episode

Oral Arguments, with Context

Vicor Corporation v. International Trade Commission — Fed. Cir. (Nov 3, 2026)

43 min

The Federal Circuit hears Vicor Corporation versus the International Trade Commission. Vicor supplied power-converter modules to Foxconn affiliates for use in electronic systems. It later alleged that imported systems used competing modules that infringed its patents, and sought relief from the Commission, or ITC, which can bar infringing imports. Foxconn answered that its purchase-order terms already gave it a patent license: permission to use the patented technology. An administrative law judge rejected that defense. The Commission reversed on that issue and found that two Foxconn affiliates had a license to the patent ending in seven-six-one. Vicor appeals. The dispute turns on routine sales paperwork. Foxconn's purchase orders included a license clause; Vicor's sales-order acknowledgments said no license was granted. The question is whether earlier delivery-date emails had already accepted Foxconn's terms. This is a battle of the forms: buyer and seller exchange documents with conf

Discuss this episode

Oral Arguments, with Context

KalshiEX / Coinbase v. New York & Connecticut Officials — 2d Cir. (Nov 3, 2026)

55 min

The Second Circuit hears Kalshi and Coinbase's requests to block state gambling enforcement while their appeals are pending. Kalshi is registered with the Commodity Futures Trading Commission, or CFTC, as a designated contract market, or DCM: an exchange. Coinbase is registered as a futures commission merchant, or FCM: a broker giving customers access to Kalshi's contracts. Here, people buy and sell yes-or-no positions on sports outcomes; the contracts pay according to whether those outcomes happen. New York and Connecticut directed Kalshi to stop what they described as unlicensed sports wagering. Kalshi challenged those directives in federal court, and Coinbase separately challenged Connecticut's authority over the same contracts. The district courts denied preliminary injunctions, leaving the companies without the temporary protection they sought. The central issue is preemption: whether federal law displaces state law. The companies say these contracts are swaps under federal commod

Discuss this episode

Oral Arguments, with Context

Alvarado-Solivan v. Comisión Estatal de Elecciones — 1st Cir. (Nov 3, 2026)

26 min

The First Circuit considers a sex-discrimination suit by the former communications director of Puerto Rico's State Elections Commission. He says that after a new commission president took over, she stripped him of duties, assigned work to women, and fired him. The commission responds that he held a confidential trust position and that the president could choose the people she trusted to do that work. A trust position is generally subject to hiring and removal at will, rather than the protections of a career post; that does not itself permit sex discrimination. The district court granted summary judgment for the defendants, deciding the case without a trial because it found insufficient evidence that the stated reason for firing him concealed sex discrimination. He seeks a jury trial instead. Pretext means a stated explanation alleged to hide the real reason. But first, listen for a separate legal question about discharge in Puerto Rico's debt-restructuring process. A discharge releases

Discuss this episode

Oral Arguments, with Context

Gracia Gracia v. FOMB — 1st Cir. (Nov 3, 2026)

25 min

We hear the First Circuit. The litigation began with drivers who already had private auto insurance but also paid Puerto Rico's compulsory-insurance premium. They sought refunds of those duplicate payments and challenged the notice they received about recovering their money. A settlement eventually established a refund-claim process. It also provided for the lawyers to receive twenty percent of the reimbursement claims paid under the agreement. That fee provision is the focus of this argument. As you listen, distinguish approval of a refund claim from actual payment: the agreement ties the fee to claims that are paid. You will also hear an initial discussion of appellate jurisdiction, meaning the appeals court's authority to decide the appeal. Those are separate questions: what the agreement requires, and whether this is the stage at which the appellate judges can decide the dispute. Gracia Gracia v. FOMB (No. 25-1155) — U.S. Court of Appeals for the First Circuit, argued November 3, 2

Discuss this episode

Oral Arguments, with Context

Buergofol GmbH v. Omega Liner Company, Inc. — Fed. Cir. (Nov 3, 2026)

25 min

The Federal Circuit hears Buergofol versus Omega Liner Company. The dispute concerns technology for repairing underground sewer pipes without digging them up. A resin-soaked liner is placed inside the old pipe and hardened, and a thin inner film is then pulled out. If that film sticks to the cured resin, it can tear and leave fragments behind. Buergofol's patent concerns coatings intended to help the film release. Omega asked the Patent Trial and Appeal Board to review the challenged patent claims. The Board found them unpatentable as obvious over earlier patent disclosures, and Buergofol appeals. A patent claim is the wording that defines the protected invention. One question is whether claim eleven requires a release compound to migrate from inside the film to its surface, or also covers a coating applied directly to that surface. That matters because the Board relied on earlier work describing directly applied coatings. Obviousness asks whether a skilled person would have had a reas

Discuss this episode

Oral Arguments, with Context

Rural Empowerment Association for Community Help v. EPA — D.C. Cir. (Nov 3, 2026)

43 min

We hear the D.C. Circuit in Rural Empowerment Association for Community Help versus the Environmental Protection Agency. The dispute concerns air emissions from farm animal waste, including ammonia and hydrogen sulfide, and whether farms must notify state and local officials about hazardous releases. In 2018, Congress exempted those air emissions from federal reporting under CERCLA, the federal Superfund law. EPA followed in 2019 by exempting them from emergency reporting under EPCRA, the Emergency Planning and Community Right-to-Know Act. Environmental groups challenged that rule, saying it cut off nearby communities' access to information about hazardous releases. The district court upheld it, reasoning that Congress had exempted a manner of release that also falls outside EPCRA's reporting requirement. The groups appeal. The question is what the words occurs in a manner mean: does releasing chemicals into the air from animal waste at a farm describe how a release happens, or merely

Discuss this episode

Oral Arguments, with Context

St. Mary Catholic Parish v. Roy — SCOTUS (Nov 3, 2026)

125 min

We hear the Supreme Court in Saint Mary Catholic Parish versus Roy. Colorado pays for up to fifteen hours of weekly preschool for four-year-olds at participating public, private, and religious schools. Providers must offer an equal opportunity to enroll regardless of listed characteristics, including a child's or family's religion, sexual orientation, and gender identity. The parish schools require parents to support Catholic teachings, including on marriage and gender. They say accepting those enrollment conditions would conflict with their religious mission. The Archdiocese directed its parish preschools not to join, and schools and parents sued in two-thousand-twenty-three. After trial, the district court upheld the sexual-orientation and gender-identity conditions; the Tenth Circuit affirmed. A separate religious-affiliation ruling led Colorado to remove an earlier preference for congregation members. The question here is funding and admissions, not whether schools may teach their

Discuss this episode

Oral Arguments, with Context

Heron Therapeutics, Inc. v. Fresenius Kabi USA, LLC — Fed. Cir. (Nov 3, 2026)

32 min

We hear the Federal Circuit in Heron Therapeutics versus Fresenius. This dispute grew out of a proposed generic version of Heron's drug formulation. Fresenius sought federal approval, and Heron sued over patents covering the formulation. After a trial, the district court found infringement and rejected Fresenius's challenge that the asserted claims were obvious. Fresenius now appeals. The formulation carries the drug aprepitant in an emulsion: tiny oil droplets dispersed in water. Egg-yolk lecithin acts as an emulsifier, helping stabilize that mixture. The claims at issue require fourteen percent lecithin by weight. An earlier Chinese patent application disclosed concentrations from half a percent to ten percent. The question is whether reaching fourteen percent would have been ordinary formulation work rather than a patentable advance. Obviousness asks what a person of ordinary skill would have been motivated to do, with a reasonable expectation of success, based on what was already k

Discuss this episode

Oral Arguments, with Context

United States v. Charles Williams — 11th Cir. (Nov 3, 2026)

23 min

We hear the Eleventh Circuit in United States versus Charles Williams. The dispute grew out of a drug investigation involving two residences connected to Williams. Police collected drug evidence from trash at one address and obtained a warrant to search the other. Williams challenged the connection between that second property and the evidence sought there. The district court adopted a magistrate judge's recommendation and denied his request to exclude the evidence. The argument begins with how a guilty plea affects appellate review of that ruling. Rule Eleven allows a conditional plea reserving a specified pretrial issue for appeal in writing, with the court's and government's consent. Then the discussion turns to probable cause for the warrant and the good-faith exception associated with United States versus Leon. That exception can permit evidence obtained under a warrant later found invalid when officers relied on it objectively reasonably. A judge's signature alone is not enough:

Discuss this episode

Oral Arguments, with Context

In re Jefferson Street Holdings LLC — Fed. Cir. (Nov 2, 2026)

37 min

The Federal Circuit considers Jefferson Street Holdings' appeal from reexamination, the Patent Office's review of an already granted protective smartphone-case patent. The case is designed to shield the phone while leaving its screen accessible, using higher edges at the ends and lower edges along the sides. The patent's claims, its written boundaries of protection, describe a lower side-edge height that is continuous between two transitions. The key question is whether that height must stay constant, or may vary as long as the side remains above zero. That interpretation affects comparison with earlier case designs relied on as prior art. The judges also examine obviousness: whether the claimed arrangement would have been obvious to a skilled designer at the time. A claim can fail that test even without an identical earlier disclosure. So interpreting continuous more narrowly would not, by itself, decide whether making the side height constant was obvious. In re Jefferson Street Holdi

Discuss this episode

Oral Arguments, with Context

General Electric Company v. LPP Combustion, LLC — Fed. Cir. (Nov 2, 2026)

35 min

The Federal Circuit reviews LPP Combustion's challenge to rulings in its patent dispute with General Electric. The patents address how fuel burns and how to prevent premature ignition. One patent uses an inert diluent, a lower-oxygen gas intended to keep fuel from igniting before the combustion chamber. The dispute is whether inert, or non-reactive, excludes every gas containing hydrocarbons, common fuel components. The trial court read the term to exclude those gases. LPP will argue that reactivity depends on the conditions, not just a gas's hydrocarbon content. Patent claims are the written statements that define what a patent protects; claim construction is interpreting them. The other issue involves two patents that sense fuel or combustion characteristics and trigger an additive to adjust combustion when a reading falls outside an acceptable range. The trial court held the challenged claims ineligible under Section one oh one: it viewed them as an abstract idea of sensing, compari

Discuss this episode

Oral Arguments, with Context

Estancias de Cerro Mar, Inc. v. Puerto Rico Aqueduct and Sewer Authority — 1st Cir. (Nov 2, 2026)

47 min

A Puerto Rico developer says the public water and sewer authority is using a privately built sewage pump station without paying the costs it imposes. The developer built the station for a residential project. A nearby housing community was then connected, sending additional wastewater through it. The developer says the authority refuses to take over the station, leaving it to pay for operation and maintenance while the authority continues collecting sewer fees. It filed a federal lawsuit in twenty twenty, seeking compensation and other relief. The Fifth Amendment requires the government to pay just compensation for private property taken for public use. The dispute includes whether the company has a protected property interest in the station, and whether the authority's conduct is a physical taking or instead a restriction on how property may be used. Physical takings concern occupation or appropriation of property; regulatory takings concern restrictions that go far enough to require

Discuss this episode

Oral Arguments, with Context

Maxwell v. Dinis — SCOTUS (Nov 2, 2026)

67 min

A federal prisoner's effort to finish his sentence outside prison becomes a Supreme Court dispute over access to judicial review. Maxwell is serving a twenty-year sentence for racketeering and related offenses arising from a scheme to take over a mortgage-loan company and drain its assets. The First Step Act lets eligible prisoners earn time credits through qualifying programs and productive activities. Maxwell says his credits entitle him to move to home confinement or a halfway house, a supervised residence in the community. That would not erase his sentence: those placements still impose restrictions and remain under Bureau of Prisons control. To challenge his continued imprisonment, he filed a petition for habeas corpus, a procedure asking a court to examine whether custody is lawful. The district court dismissed his First Step Act claim because it found he had not properly presented it through the prison's administrative grievance process. The Fifth Circuit affirmed on a different

Discuss this episode

Oral Arguments, with Context

In re Jefferson Street Holdings LLC — Fed. Cir. (Nov 2, 2026)

31 min

The Federal Circuit reviews Jefferson Street Holdings' challenge to patent rejections involving a protective phone case. The design uses lower side edges alongside higher sections, intended to preserve screen access while protecting the device. The Patent Office reexamined the issued patent against earlier case designs, and its appeal board upheld the rejections now challenged in court. A patent claim defines the features for which protection is sought. Here, much turns on whether a height that continuously spans a side must stay constant, or may curve while never dropping to zero. The lawyers will compare differently worded claims, including dependent claims that add restrictions to a broader claim. That is claim differentiation: differences between claims can help determine their scope. Anticipation asks whether one earlier reference already disclosed every claimed feature in the required arrangement. Obviousness asks whether the claimed arrangement, as a whole, would have been an or

Discuss this episode

Oral Arguments, with Context

Enovsys LLC v. Uber Technologies, Inc. — Fed. Cir. (Nov 2, 2026)

29 min

The Federal Circuit considers patents for mobile-device location services asserted against Uber. The patents describe ways to request location data within geographic regions and determine whether devices are moving together. The patent owner says these methods address network overload and tracking problems. It sued Uber for infringement, but the district court dismissed the case without a trial, finding the patent claims ineligible because they covered abstract information processing rather than a technological improvement. A related appeal involving Lyft is being heard alongside it. Eligibility concerns what patent law protects, not simply whether an invention is new. A patent claim defines the invention's legal boundaries. Under the Supreme Court's Alice framework, a claim directed to an abstract idea needs an additional inventive concept to qualify, considering its elements both individually and together. Merely using ordinary computer components is not enough. The patent owner's la

Discuss this episode

Oral Arguments, with Context

Roldan-Cruz v. Commonwealth of Puerto Rico — 1st Cir. (Nov 2, 2026)

34 min

The First Circuit considers when Puerto Rico can be sued over alleged police misconduct. A woman brought federal civil-rights and Puerto Rico tort claims alleging excessive force by police officers. She also sought to hold the Commonwealth and its police agency liable. The district court dismissed the claims against those government defendants on immunity grounds, without deciding whether the officers had used unlawful force. The appeal is being heard together with a second police-related case. The plaintiffs will ask the court to reconsider treating Puerto Rico like a state for sovereign immunity, a protection against being sued in federal court. They will rely on a Supreme Court decision about Puerto Rico's powers and double jeopardy, the constitutional protection against repeated prosecutions for the same offense. That criminal-law ruling did not itself decide this civil-immunity question. The judges will also focus on Section nineteen eighty-three, which allows suits for violations

Discuss this episode

Oral Arguments, with Context

State of Texas v. Oz — 5th Cir. (Nov 2, 2026)

33 min

The Fifth Circuit considers whether federal Medicaid funding rules reach private agreements among hospitals. Texas allows local governments to tax healthcare providers to help finance its share of Medicaid, a joint federal-state healthcare program. Federal matching funds are added, and hospitals receive Medicaid payments. CMS, the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services, is targeting private agreements that redistribute those payments so taxpaying hospitals recover their tax costs. This is the hold-harmless issue: whether providers are being protected from the cost of the tax. CMS says private redistribution can amount to an indirect government guarantee. Texas says the statute requires a guarantee from the state or local government itself, not merely a private agreement. A district judge set aside the challenged rule provisions and bulletins, and the federal government now appeals. Its lawyer will argue that private intermediaries do not remove these arrangements from Congress's pr

Discuss this episode

Oral Arguments, with Context

PT. Zinus Global Indonesia v. United States — Fed. Cir. (Nov 2, 2026)

32 min

The Federal Circuit considers a dispute over antidumping calculations for mattresses from Indonesia. These duties are extra import charges addressing below-fair-value sales that materially harm or threaten a domestic industry. Some mattress models came from multiple countries, and Zinus's warehouse records could not trace every sale back to its origin. That mattered because Commerce needed to identify Indonesian sales, not all sales from the warehouse. The agency estimated the Indonesian share using quarterly ratios. After twice sending the calculations back to Commerce for further work, the Court of International Trade upheld the revised result. Brooklyn Bedding and other domestic producers and unions will seek another remand, meaning a return to the agency for further work. Their lawyer will argue that Commerce rejected some estimates as impossible while accepting inventory data with the same problem: sales apparently exceeding the available mattresses. The government and Zinus will

Discuss this episode

Oral Arguments, with Context

United States v. Joseph — 1st Cir. (Nov 2, 2026)

25 min

The First Circuit considers whether a Bitcoin prosecution was tainted by references to unrelated fraud. Alan Joseph exchanged cash for Bitcoin. In undercover meetings, an agent presented himself as a seller of counterfeit designer goods who needed Bitcoin to pay a supplier. Prosecutors said Joseph knew what those transactions were meant to support. A jury convicted him of money laundering and operating an unregistered money-transmitting business. The jury acquitted him on one other laundering count. The appeal concerns trial testimony about romance scams and cryptocurrency investment fraud, not charges that Joseph ran those schemes. His lawyer will argue that these references portrayed him as a habitual criminal and denied him a fair trial. This is a propensity concern: treating someone's supposed criminal character as proof of the charged conduct. The government will acknowledge that some fraud references were unnecessary, but will argue that the judge's warnings kept jurors focused o

Discuss this episode

Oral Arguments, with Context

Melendez v. Kennedy — 1st Cir. (Nov 2, 2026)

41 min

The First Circuit considers whether a defense lawyer's failure to challenge a phone search undermined a murder conviction. Felix Melendez was convicted in Massachusetts after two earlier juries failed to agree on the murder charge. Prosecutors linked him to the victim's jewelry, some of which he had pawned, and used material from his phone to support their account of his motive and conduct. His trial lawyer did not seek suppression of those phone contents on constitutional grounds. The state's highest court later found that the search-warrant affidavit did not connect the phone to the crime. It nevertheless upheld the conviction, relying on other evidence. Melendez now seeks federal habeas relief, a challenge to the legality of his imprisonment. His lawyer will argue that asking whether the remaining evidence could support a conviction is different from asking whether the lawyer's error creates a reasonable probability of a different result. That probability must be enough to undermine

Discuss this episode

Oral Arguments, with Context

United States v. Damilola Kumapayi — 5th Cir. (Nov 2, 2026)

41 min

Damilola Kumapayi challenges the sentence imposed after he pleaded guilty to a wire-fraud conspiracy. The broader prosecution involved romance scams, fraudulent unemployment claims, and moving the proceeds through bank accounts. He received one hundred nine months in prison. His guilty plea distinguishes him from co-defendants who went to trial. To follow the argument, it helps to separate several legal questions. An appeal waiver is a promise in a plea agreement to give up certain appeals. In Hunter versus the United States, the Supreme Court recognized a narrow exception for sentencing errors so egregious that enforcing the waiver would undermine the justice system's integrity. Ordinary disagreements over sentencing calculations do not meet that standard. A separate question is harmless error: a procedural mistake does not require reversal if it did not affect substantial rights. You will also hear about the presentence report, or PSR, prepared by a probation officer to help the judg

Discuss this episode

Oral Arguments, with Context

South Texas Environmental Justice Network v. FERC — D.C. Cir. (Nov 2, 2026)

94 min

A Texas city and environmental groups challenge renewed federal approval of the Rio Grande liquefied natural gas terminal and its supply pipeline in South Texas. The developer had proposed adding carbon capture and sequestration: collecting carbon dioxide from the terminal and storing it underground. The proposal referred to storage sites close to the terminal. In an earlier appeal, the court required the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission, or FERC, to examine that proposal even if the developer withdrew its application. The developer did withdraw it, and FERC reaffirmed approval after a supplemental environmental review. FERC declined to recommend carbon capture, citing uncertainties over permitting, timing, cost, and infrastructure. The challengers will argue that evaluating a storage site about a hundred miles away did not answer whether the nearby option was workable. FERC and the project companies will defend that investigation and the agency's discretion to decide which alterna

Discuss this episode
Older episodes