Finding something earlier must always be better, surely? Dr Margaret McCartney has spent thirty years saying that just because something sounds like a good idea, it doesn't mean it has been shown to be one. In this episode, I'm joined by Margaret, a GP and the author of The Patient Paradox. I read her book years ago, when I was a fairly new GP partner, and it changed how I looked at testing and awareness campaigns. We start with why screening people who feel well needs such a high standard of proof, using the PSA test as the example. It was developed to follow men who already knew they had prostate cancer, and the man who brought it into public use later called screening with it a public health disaster. We talk about what Australian data shows when men are given high-quality information, and why explaining any of this is so hard in a ten or fifteen minute appointment. Then we turn to the market in home test kits, subscriptions and full body scans. Margaret explains why a false positiv
"I spent twenty-five years trying to be skinnier and then accidentally got jacked, and I'm happier." That's roughly what Niki Sims, a strength coach at Barbell Logic, posted, and I loved it. In this episode, I'm joined by Niki to ask whether you can change your body without trying to make it smaller. There are still plenty of old gremlins knocking around for women about shrinking our bodies, and she has years of coaching experience to draw on. Niki tells me what made her sit down and write that post: being exhausted by stressing over the scale, and seeing old photos of herself and realising she was skinnier than she thought she was at the time. We talk about why you can't work on your muscle and spot-treat fat, why you need to fuel your training if you want to perform, and what Niki says to a new client who wants to be strong but "could still do with losing ten, fifteen, twenty pounds". Her answer starts with why, and then an honest look at what losing those pounds would take. We also
In this episode, I'm joined by Matt Hussey, a therapist and former journalist behind Griftonomics, who makes videos taking apart the claims of wellness influencers. Matt trained as a therapist after years as a journalist, and now has a private practice. He started making videos to find a better way of talking about mental health and the internet, and the one that really took off was a two minute piece on Mel Robbins. Around the same time he noticed influencers creeping into his clients' sessions, which led him into the world of wellness grifting. We talk about what makes someone a grifter, from exploiting anxiety, uncertainty and mistrust for financial gain, to why borrowed authority works so well and why the biggest podcasts so rarely challenge their guests. We look at Mel Robbins, Steven Bartlett and Mindy Pelz, the questions raised about Jay Shetty's monk story, and whether any of them know they are doing it. Matt's view is that many have bought into their own story so completely th