The Ninth Circuit hears Windy Lund's challenge to the payment terms of her criminal restitution order. The bank-fraud case grew out of a scheme to cash checks stolen from the mail. Lund pleaded guilty, and the district court ordered her to repay the victim. But the paperwork points in two directions. A separate order says payment is due immediately, with no alternative payment schedule. The amended judgment sets payments during imprisonment and supervised release, including at least ten percent of gross monthly income after prison. Lund's lawyer will argue that the conflicting language must be corrected and that her monthly obligation needs a clear ceiling. The government will defend the arrangement as an immediate debt with manageable payments. The panel explores whether it can clarify the orders itself, or must send the case back. USA v. Lund (No. 25-3721) — United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit, argued November 16, 2026. Sources: Official Ninth Circuit oral argument:
The Ninth Circuit considers whether the government could detain Fuentes Guevara without new notice or a hearing, relying on an old removal order. He entered the United States as a child and was released from immigration custody. In 2005, an immigration judge ordered him removed in his absence. He says he never received notice of that hearing. He continued living in the United States, married and had children. About twenty years later, immigration officers arrested him again. He filed a habeas petition, asking a federal judge to review whether his custody was lawful and order his release. The district court denied that request, and he appealed. His lawyer will argue that due process requires a meaningful opportunity to contest this new detention, separate from the validity of the old removal order. The government will argue that a final removal order permits detention, and that objections to the old hearing belong in the immigration appeals process. The panel must decide what it can rev
The Ninth Circuit considers whether Cleo's cash advance app falls under federal laws protecting military borrowers. Staff Sergeant Terrance Moss sued after using the app to get money before payday. He says the service's monthly subscription and fees for faster delivery made supposedly interest-free advances expensive. He brought a proposed class action under the Military Lending Act and the Truth in Lending Act. For covered credit, the military law caps annual borrowing costs at thirty-six percent and restricts forced arbitration. Cleo asked to send the dispute to private arbitration, but the district court refused, and the company appealed. Cleo will argue that its advances are not credit because customers have no legally enforceable obligation to repay, and that optional delivery fees are not finance charges. Moss's lawyer will argue that the agreed repayment date and automatic bank withdrawals make this credit, with fees that federal law regulates. Before those issues comes a thresh
The Tenth Circuit hears Robert Lee Harrison Junior's appeal from a second trial for attempted kidnapping. The case began with a confrontation in an Oklahoma City hospital parking garage. His former girlfriend testified that, after she got into her car, Harrison punched her and ordered her into the passenger seat at gunpoint. She escaped the car, but was wounded by gunfire in the elevator lobby. She survived. An earlier appeal set aside his conviction for completed kidnapping and allowed a retrial for attempt. A second jury convicted him. The central question now is whether the evidence showed an intent to kidnap, rather than only an assault. Harrison's lawyer will argue that the government never proved a plan to take her away. The government will point to his actions and a message about retrieving a vehicle as evidence of that plan. The court will also consider a five-minute limit on the defense opening statement and the admission of photographs showing blood at the scene. Listen for t
The Tenth Circuit hears Angela Leddy's appeal over the medical care her mother, Christa Sullivan, received in the Oklahoma County jail. Sullivan entered jail with serious mental illness and died there in April 2021, after nearly a year in custody. Her daughter sued under federal civil-rights law, alleging that severe weight loss, pressure sores and prolonged immobility were met with inadequate treatment. Leddy is asking for a jury to hear the claims against two doctors and their private employer, Turn Key. The constitutional issue is deliberate indifference: knowingly disregarding a serious medical risk, not simply providing negligent care. The estate's lawyer will argue that the doctors recognized Sullivan's decline but failed to provide effective medication or secure appropriate outside care. The defense will argue that repeated examinations, medication changes and hospital visits show medical judgment, not a conscious disregard of her needs. They also dispute whether a company polic
The Tenth Circuit considers whether an Oklahoma insurance dispute belongs in court or private arbitration. Schau submitted a claim for wind damage to commercial property in Oklahoma City. He sued his insurers, alleging they wrongfully denied coverage and handled the claim in bad faith. The insurers deny those allegations and invoke an arbitration clause in the policy. The district court refused to compel arbitration, and the insurers appealed. Oklahoma law generally excludes insurance contracts from its arbitration statute. A federal law, the McCarran-Ferguson Act, can protect state insurance rules against conflicting federal statutes not specifically about insurance. The insurers will argue that the New York Convention, an international arbitration treaty, itself requires arbitration and is not displaced by Oklahoma law. Schau will argue that the treaty needs implementing legislation, which must give way to Oklahoma's insurance rule. There is also a threshold question: should the cour
The Tenth Circuit hears Red T Homes' challenge to Denver's affordable-housing permit rules. The builder sought permits for two small residential projects and faced roughly seventy thousand dollars in fees to support affordable housing. Denver denied its requests to waive the fees. Another route was to set aside homes for income-qualified households, with price limits and ninety-nine-year affordability restrictions recorded against the property. Red T sued, arguing that these conditions make builders pay for a public problem their projects do not create. The district court dismissed the case because it viewed the affordable-housing option as a permissible regulation, rather than a taking that required compensation. The appeal focuses on that alternative. Red T's lawyer will argue that forcing a developer to transfer homes or accept binding restrictions is itself a taking, so the fee demand still needs constitutional justification. Denver will argue that these are lawful housing-use rest
The Tenth Circuit hears a whistleblower case over federal student-aid money paid to Stevens-Henager College and related schools. Two whistleblowers sued on the government's behalf, alleging that the schools claimed federal funds while violating rules against paying recruiters based on student enrollment. The government took over only part of the lawsuit, focusing on a bonus plan at Stevens-Henager. The whistleblowers wanted to continue other allegations, including claims against additional schools and an individual defendant. The district court struck their post-intervention complaints, reasoning that the government's complaint had replaced them. The government's narrower case later ended in a defense jury verdict. The whistleblowers now seek to revive claims the earlier rulings prevented them from pursuing. On the takeover question, the whistleblowers and the government will argue that taking over some claims does not automatically wipe out the rest. The defendants will argue that the
The Second Circuit hears an appeal about the airline GOL's bankruptcy reorganization. The dispute is not just about what the airline owes its creditors, but which claims those creditors would give up under its plan. The plan included releases protecting other people and companies connected with the restructuring, not just the airline itself. Certain creditors received notices explaining that they would be treated as agreeing to those releases unless they opted out. The bankruptcy court approved the arrangement, but the U.S. Trustee challenged it. The district court ordered the third-party releases and the injunction enforcing them removed from the plan. GOL now seeks to restore those protections. Its lawyer will argue that clear notice and an opportunity to opt out can establish consent in bankruptcy. The Trustee will argue that silence does not amount to an agreement to surrender separate claims against other parties. Listen for the distinction between receiving adequate notice and ac
The Ninth Circuit hears a California dockworkers' class action against S S A Terminals and other port companies. The workers paid fees to obtain or renew TWIC cards so they could enter ports for work, and say they were not reimbursed. They also received wage statements with company numbers on the front and company names and addresses on the back. They sued over both the card expenses and whether those pay statements properly identified their employers. The district court ruled for the workers on the card expenses, but for the companies on wage statements. The companies appeal the reimbursement ruling; the workers cross-appeal the wage-statement ruling. The two appeals put a practical pair of workplace questions before the court: who must pay for access to the worksite, and how clearly a pay statement must identify the employer. Andrikos v. SSA Terminals (No. 25-569) — United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit, argued November 16, 2026. Sources: Official Ninth Circuit appeal
The Tenth Circuit hears Defending Education versus Sullivan and two related appeals over Colorado's anti-discrimination law. Advocacy groups, medical plaintiffs, an athletic-clothing retailer and a Christian bookstore challenged the law after a 2025 amendment expressly included chosen names and forms of address in its protections. They want to use names and pronouns consistent with their beliefs about biological sex, including when dealing with transgender customers or members of the public. The retailers say they will serve everyone, but fear that a complaint about their speech could trigger enforcement. They sued before any enforcement against them, claiming the law chills speech and compels words they reject. The district court denied temporary injunctions, finding no sufficiently credible enforcement threat. A later ruling let several plaintiffs continue litigating, while dismissing three advocacy groups for lack of standing. Standing means the right to bring a concrete dispute int
The Eleventh Circuit hears Preston Damsky versus Chris Summerlin, a University of Florida law-school expulsion case. Damsky posted on X that Jews must be abolished by any means necessary, linking his words to another writer's call to abolish the white race. A Jewish law professor asked whether he meant murdering her and her family; his response turned back to the comparison rather than giving a direct answer. The university says this was a threat or promotion of violence, not simply an offensive viewpoint: it points to frightened students, missed classes and additional security. Damsky says the exchange was provocative off-campus speech, not a threat to carry out violence. He challenged his expulsion, and a district judge ordered temporary reinstatement. Summerlin, the dean of students, brings this appeal for the university. An earlier appellate stay put the reinstatement order on hold; the argument here concerns whether that preliminary injunction should stand. The university will arg
The Second Circuit hears Luo versus A I K Renovation, a fired construction project manager's discrimination case. Luo, who is of Chinese origin, says race and national origin drove his dismissal. The company points instead to job performance and his handling of a worker allegedly intoxicated on the job. He also says he was not paid for his final week of work. A jury found for the defendants on discrimination, and the judge rejected the wage claim for insufficient evidence of the hours worked. The judge later denied a new trial. Luo will argue that inconsistent explanations for his firing and restrictions at trial warrant another chance to present his case. The defendants will ask the court to leave the result intact. Listen for the difference between possible contradictions in a witness's story and grounds for overturning a jury's verdict. Recording note: The official recording cuts off on the judge's trailing 'So, uh' after both sides have finished and the court has announced that it
The Ninth Circuit hears Russell versus Dave, a dispute over cash advances and access to court under military lending protections. At the center is ExtraCash, a product that provides money through Dave's app, with associated fees. The plaintiffs sued Dave and Evolve Bank and Trust, alleging that the charges and lending practices violated the Military Lending Act and other lending laws. The district court rejected the companies' request to send the dispute to arbitration, and the companies appealed. The question here is where these lending claims can be heard, not a final determination of damages. One provision of the military lending statute prohibits requiring arbitration; another says agreements to arbitrate covered credit disputes are unenforceable. Can a customer's opportunity to opt out change that result? And who decides whether the statute prevents arbitration: the judge, or the arbitrator? Listen for the distinction between deciding the underlying lending claims and deciding whe
The Tenth Circuit hears O'Neill Automotive versus Federated Mutual Insurance Company, a dispute over insurance for pollution cleanup. As O'Neill prepared to sell dealership property, environmental investigations found contamination. O'Neill faced cleanup costs and sought payment under Federated's pollution liability policy, but the insurer denied coverage. The release of pollutants was below ground, and the district court ruled that it did not meet a required condition for coverage. O'Neill will argue that the policy's structure and separate reporting rules create an alternative path to coverage for underground pollution. Federated will argue that the words only if make all five coverage conditions mandatory, and that O'Neill cannot satisfy the fifth. The insurer also raises questions about when the pollution began and when the claim was reported; the district court did not decide those alternative grounds. Listen for the distinction between reporting a pollution event and reporting a
The Tenth Circuit hears United States versus Toyne, an appeal from convictions for sexually abusing a minor. Prosecutors accused Jordan Toyne of repeatedly abusing a girl while she was underage. She testified at trial, and jurors also heard a separate young witness describe other alleged abuse, with a diary introduced as evidence. Toyne denied the allegations and challenged the witnesses' credibility, but a federal jury found him guilty of three counts. His appeal focuses on whether out-of-court statements and the way the prosecution presented testimony unfairly strengthened the accusations. One dispute concerns a father repeating what his daughter had told him; another concerns whether the diary qualified for an exception to the hearsay rule. Toyne will argue that these evidentiary errors, together with improper bolstering of a witness, undermined a trial that depended on credibility. The government will ask the court to leave the verdict intact. Listen for the difference between fail
The Second Circuit hears a dispute over whether work inside an immigration detention center was truly voluntary. At the Buffalo Federal Detention Facility in Batavia, New York, detainees worked in a program administered by private contractor Akima Global Services. They cleaned toilets and floors for one dollar a day. Former detainees allege that, when work went undone, guards threatened entire housing units with losing television, telephone, or recreation access, and sometimes followed through. They say that pressure made them work or keep working, even though the program was called voluntary; the company disputes that it coerced them. The detainees sued, and the district court allowed their federal forced-labor claims to proceed as a class action. That did not decide that the company was liable: this appeal asks whether common evidence can establish coercion for the class, rather than requiring separate inquiries into each worker. The company will argue that people joined for differen
The Eleventh Circuit hears United States versus Lagarius Johnson, a challenge to a gun conviction tied to drug trafficking. When police tried to approach Johnson, he ran and discarded a pistol and a backpack. The backpack contained marijuana, baggies, and a scale, and the pistol had been modified to fire automatically. An earlier jury convicted Johnson of separate drug and gun offenses; a second jury convicted him of possessing the machine gun in furtherance of drug trafficking. The issue here is the link between the gun and the drug crime, not simply whether he had both. Johnson will argue that the evidence showed possession but did not establish that the gun helped his drug dealing. The government will argue that the gun's accessibility, the drug evidence, and Johnson's social-media posts allowed the jury to infer that connection. The argument also turns to which trial's evidence the appeals court can review and whether Johnson preserved his challenge. Listen for the difference betwe
The Tenth Circuit hears Kendrick versus A W Distributing, a wrongful-death lawsuit involving aerosol computer dusters. Jonathan Kendrick died in a Kansas motel after inhaling gas from those products, a practice known as huffing. The lawsuit seeks to hold the companies that make and sell the dusters responsible for his death. The case began in Missouri but was transferred to Kansas. A federal judge applied Kansas law and dismissed the claims because huffing was illegal and connected to the fatal injury. The appeal asks whether the judge could choose that law and end the case based on the complaint, before a trial. Kendrick will argue that the judge improperly weighed disputed facts, and that Jonathan's purchases and addiction in Missouri matter to which state's law applies. The companies will argue that the pleaded facts already make Kansas law controlling, and that the claims would be barred under Missouri law as well. Listen for the difference between the place of death and where an i
The Tenth Circuit hears United States versus Ivan Lujan, a government appeal over a warrantless car search. Federal officers were looking for Lujan on a warrant alleging that he had violated supervised release. An earlier search of the home where he was living had turned up fentanyl pills and about fifty thousand dollars in cash. When officers arrested him after he stepped out of a gold Honda, they found roughly four thousand dollars wrapped in plastic in his pocket, but no drugs on his person. They then searched the car and found drugs. A federal judge excluded the evidence from that search, ruling that the officers had not established a lawful basis to search the vehicle without a warrant. The government will argue that the earlier investigation, the wrapped cash, and Lujan's movements, considered together, gave officers probable cause to expect more evidence in the Honda. Lujan will argue that suspicion about him or the cash did not establish that evidence would still be inside the
The Eleventh Circuit hears Heather Swann versus the Clay County sheriff and deputies, an appeal over a death in custody. In 2023, Joshua Swann died of a heart attack after more than a month in Florida's Clay County Jail. His estate alleges that deputies beat him and deprived him of food, water, and medical care. The estate contends that dehydration contributed to his death; the defendants dispute that their conduct caused it. A federal judge ruled for the sheriff and four deputies without a trial. The judge treated the civil-rights claims against the deputies as part of the wrongful-death case, and found insufficient evidence linking those deputies to the death. The estate will argue that a jury should decide both its death claim and its claims for injuries suffered before death. The defendants will argue that the complaint sought recovery for death and that the evidence does not connect their actions to that outcome. They will also defend the ruling that no sheriff's policy was proved
The Tenth Circuit hears Thomas versus Stitt, a challenge to how Oklahoma considers parole for someone imprisoned for crimes committed as a child. Dwain Thomas pleaded guilty to murders committed when he was fifteen and received life sentences with the possibility of parole. Over repeated reviews, he has never made it past the parole board's initial screening. He sued state officials, saying the system fails to give him a meaningful chance to show maturity and rehabilitation. A federal district court ruled for the officials, and Thomas appealed. Supreme Court decisions limit harsh sentences for juvenile offenders, but the parties disagree about what those decisions require during later parole reviews. Thomas will argue that his youth at the time of the crimes must meaningfully inform every stage of that process, not merely appear as dates in a file. The officials will argue that the sentencing precedents do not require those additional parole procedures, and that the existing system alr
The Second Circuit hears New York versus Trump, a dispute over moving his state criminal case into federal court after conviction. Prosecutors said Michael Cohen paid Stormy Daniels one hundred thirty thousand dollars before the 2016 election to keep her story from becoming public. They said Trump later reimbursed Cohen, with business records falsely describing those payments as legal services. In 2024, a state jury convicted Trump on thirty-four counts of falsifying business records. Trump challenges that conviction, including the use of evidence that he says concerns official presidential acts. After the Supreme Court's 2024 presidential-immunity decision, he renewed his request for a federal forum. An earlier federal appeal sent that request back for reconsideration, but the district judge again refused removal. Trump will argue that presidential immunity and federal election-law issues justify a federal forum, and that he sought it diligently. New York will argue that he chose to l
The Ninth Circuit hears Vickery versus Empower Finance, a dispute about small cash advances and protections for military borrowers. Two service members used Empower's cash-advance product and sued, alleging that its fees violated lending laws. Users link a bank account so the company can take repayment around payday, and they can pay for faster delivery of the money. Empower's terms also say it will not sue to collect unpaid advances. The immediate issue is where that lawsuit may proceed. Empower asked to send the dispute to arbitration, but the district judge refused under the Military Lending Act's protection against mandatory arbitration for covered consumer credit. Empower will argue that these advances are not covered credit because repayment is not legally enforceable, and that optional delivery fees are not finance charges. The borrowers will argue that the repayment mechanism creates a debt and that the faster-delivery fee counts as a finance charge. Listen for how those defini